Bhatiyani -- Realization, Repentance or Revenge??

Page

Hibernated

Posted: 11 years ago

What shall the personality of bhatiyani be named as? I disliked her for the tactics she played but the actions of hers today are telling a completely different story. The way she called Jayvantabai and asked her to narrate ramayana was itself a miracle, the associated character here is kaikeyi, jayavantabai mentioned of kaikeyi to make her realize of her intentions. The way bhatiyani herself called upon jayavantabai isn't indicates that somewhere deep down the lane she knows that she is at fault, her inner soul isn't letting her breath and she is pricked by her heart every now and then. Isn't such person liable to forgiveness? Subah ka bhula sham ko ghar laut aye to use bhula nahi kehte hain, isn't this applies to bhatiyani too, if she has realized her fault. I don't want to mention about things which happened afterwards but right now at this juncture i find a change in bhatiyani. Sometimes at some moment our evil side dominates our our gud one but that doesn't means that we are culprit. I found a good sign in bhatiyani today for her acceptance about her insecurities because of pratap. Is this incident sufficient to forgive her? Will she be back to her evil tactics? Will jayvantabai forgive her? Will bhatiyani be able to accept pratap as king of mewar?

Is this REALIZATION of what bhatiyani was planning against Pratap or Is this REPENTANCE of her acts as she can now feel the pain jayvantabai would have felt when she was trying to harm him or is this a kind of REVENGE to kill pratap winning jayvantabai's trust again?

There are many unanswered questions. Pls share ur views.

Quote

Frequent Posters

Nandini

@NandiniRaizadaa

Trailblazer

+ 4

Posted: 11 years ago

Well history tells us that at the end of his life udai Singh had announced that son if his favourite queen dheer bai bhatiyani will be the king

History does not say much about bhatiyani but for udai Singh to have proclaimed her son as king against the wishes of all others show that bhatiyani had ambitions for her son till the end

So I don't think repentance is the path followed by bhatiyani

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

642126

Hibernated

Posted: 11 years ago

I don't feel anything for her.

She was in extreme pain at that time and looked for support. When a person is in so much pain she or he does blurt out their guilt.

She got back to square one after she got normal going by how she taunted Pratap.

Bhaatiyani does feel she is wrong. But then she feels she can't help it and it is in a way justified as she is doing all this for her son. Then she also tries to rationalise it (to feel better about herself) that she wouldn't have done it if Pratap were born from her and not Jaywanta.

She is a crazy person. She rather hopes for everyone (including God!) to "understand" her "pain" and "helplessness" (!) and agree to let her have her own ways - that it is be a Rajmata herself and make her son the King.

We'll have to see more episodes and her behaviour now to see how much she has changed!

Quote

Khyati

@cherryberry293

Dazzler

Posted: 11 years ago

Nicely written post 😊

I don't think she's repenting or regretting anything.
She was in a pain and needed some1s help ...

And history says that she hated Pratap and always wanted to crown her son

Quote

MONA

@Dear10

Trailblazer

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

dont know about bhatiyani but uday singh ke rang abhi se badalte dikhayi dene lage 😆 poor pratap nanhi si jaan jisko dekho lene par tula hai. shamsh khan ko sbse bada khatra to humayu se hai wo pratap ke pichhe kyun pada hai 😆 insabko humayu hi harayega jesa history kehti hai 😆

Quote

Melosa

@Melosa

Explorer

Posted: 11 years ago

Udai singh really IS changing. Like, I was thinking. For his new-born, he was actually RISKING MP'S LIFE!!! (when he forgave all the people who were likely 2 b a threat to Pratap just so that Jagmal gets punya!) I was S.H.O.C.K.E.D!

Quote

714873

Hibernated

Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: Nandiniraizaada
Well history tells us that at the end of his life udai Singh had announced that son if his favourite queen dheer bai bhatiyani will be the king

History does not say much about bhatiyani but for udai Singh to have proclaimed her son as king against the wishes of all others show that bhatiyani had ambitions for her son till the end

So I don't think repentance is the path followed by bhatiyani

yes we are considering things as per history. I just wished you all to keep the history aside for one minute and think and a normal viewer of this show about which assume that you are obscure. Now just let me know, don't you think the way bhatiyani expressed her feelings to jayvantabai was a sign of change? What you would have done if you would have seen ur enemy repenting for der acts? Self realization is the best medicine of treatment

Quote

714873

Hibernated

Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: Skepblun
I don't feel anything for her. She was in extreme pain at that time and looked for support. When a person is in so much pain she or he does blurt out their guilt.
ok i can understand this point but i feel somewhere in heart she is aware of the fact that her intentions are not right. Though she is not genuinely trying to get it over but atleast she knows that she is wrong, isn't it self realization?

She got back to square one after she got normal going by how she taunted Pratap.
i think it can not be regarded as taunt, it was normal leg pulling as it happens between mother and child

Bhaatiyani does feel she is wrong. But then she feels she can't help it and it is in a way justified as she is doing all this for her son.
yes thats what i wanted to discuss upon, bhatiyani knows it very well that she is wrong but she is blinded by love towards her son

Then she also tries to rationalise it (to feel better about herself) that she wouldn't have done it if Pratap were born from her and not Jaywanta.
bang on!! I loved this point.

She is a crazy person. She rather hopes for everyone (including God!) to "understand" her "pain" and "helplessness" (!) and agree to let her have her own ways - that it is be a Rajmata herself and make her son the King.
actually i feel that somewhere in heart she is afraid of pratap and jayvanta bai, she thinks that she will loose everything and her son will be lost in the light of pratap. She seems very insecure to me

We'll have to see more episodes and her behaviour now to see how much she has changed!

thanks for d reply my answers are in bold

Quote

714873

Hibernated

Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: cherryberry293
Nicely written post 😊

I don't think she's repenting or regretting anything.
She was in a pain and needed some1s help ...

And history says that she hated Pratap and always wanted to crown her son

i dun know why but i feel she has two sides, she doesn't know which one to choose. She knows she is wrong but can't do anything. I really don't know the category she must be place, a person who knows that he/she is wrong but doesn't wants to change, whats this called?

Quote

714873

Hibernated

Posted: 11 years ago

#10

Originally posted by: -dear10-
dont know about bhatiyani but uday singh ke rang abhi se badalte dikhayi dene lageÂ 😆Â poor pratap nanhi si jaan jisko dekho lene par tula hai. shamsh khan ko sbse bada khatra to humayu se hai wo pratap ke pichhe kyun pada haiÂ 😆Â insabko Â humayu hi harayega jesa history kehti haiÂ 😆Â

hey mona ji 🤗
sach me mujhe smjh nahi aa raha sab k sab pratap k peeche kyu pde hain wo to bachha h abi ek taraf sauteli ma dusri tarah shams khan, aur uday singh b kal pagal ho gaya tha k jin logo se khatra h pratap ko un sab ki saza maaf kr dia 🤢

Quote

1 2 3

Bhatiyani -- Realization, Repentance or Revenge??

Related Topics

Explore Topics