Jodha Akbar 45: Shadows of the Past

sashashyam thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#1

The one image that stayed with me at the end of today's episode was not that of Ruqaiya storming away gracelessly from her shock defeat by the Hindu Begum she detests, and whom she wishes to despise. One knew that lacking both foresight and self-control, she would also lack the astuteness to gracefully congratulate Jodha, and thus minimize the negative impact of her own upset.

Nor that of a victorious Jodha (how she won, by making a move again after her last move, which Ruqaiya had declared to be a very bad one, is a mystery, but then so are many things in Ekta's serials) saying, in a smooth left handed compliment to her husband, that she played the chess game Shahenshah ka maan rakne ke liye, while refusing the Shahi firman with elaborate politeness. The young lady is learning the ropes of public behaviour in the Mughal court, I thought to myself.

Nor that of Jalal later lecturing a raging Ruqaiya on the rules of siyasat and the need to play down your defeats and play up your victories. One catches a glimpse then of a mind naturally astute, capable of doing all it takes, including biding its time, to seize even a very slight chance of victory. A mind honed by his Khan Baba, a master of statecraft a la Chanakya, till its razor sharp edge rivalled that of Jalal's shamsheer.

Nor of Jodha in full Jalal the Jallad mode, raging too, but this time at her Kanha for having bound her to a man jisme maanavta ka koyi ansh hi nahin hai. By now, such declamations from Jodha are par for the course, and do not need more than a passing mention. One does wish, however, that she would not glare so much, with the whites of her eyes showing all round the iris.

Shadows of the past: No, the scene that lingered in my consciousness was that of Jalal - not the Shahenshah - kneeling on the floor of the Diwan-e-Aam, embracing the little Hindu boy, with eyes brimming with unexpected tears. Of the recalled anguish, and the lost look on his face, as the shadows of the past rise again to haunt him.

His father's brother lunging at him, sword in hand and murder in his heart, livid with hatred for Humayun, as Jalal cowers behind his aunt, who manages to shield him from her husband and save his life. Bairam Khan and Mahaam Anga standing by him, and with him, against all odds, with rocklike loyalty, yes, but also with genuine affection and caring.

As Jalal says, no one knows better than he the trauma that the absence of parents causes to the abandoned child. Not every child would have his good fortune in the presence of his Khan Baba and Mahaam Anga, he adds, but still Bhale hi wo walidein ke bina sari duniya ki fateh kar le, par wo kahin na kahin, andar, akela hi rahta hai.

So there it was again, up front and centre, the hurt that is still unhealed and festers within him, and the loneliness that eats away at the innermost core of his being. I have written of this often in my earlier posts, and I will not repeat any of that now. Today, the wounds of the past in Jalal's zehen were ripped open again by sheer chance, and the simple plea of an uncomprehending and yet courageous little Hindu boy.

The denouement of that scene was incredibly moving. And the striking, and strange thing was that the pain that was so visible in Jalal's eyes was mirrored in Ruqaiya's face,which twisted in empathy. A lifelong friendship cannot be dismissed or written off so easily; it has its own intimacies and symbiotic bonds.

Jalal's reversal of his original judgement is not on the merits of the case, which were in any case very poorly set out by the complainant. In any autocracy, the incredible folly of the husband in not stating his real complaint - about the seizure of his house and his cow and of the attempt to convert him to Islam by force ' and instead railing against the regime as a whole in loud tones, would have produced the same punitive response (it is to be noted that the response is from a Minister, not from the Shahenshan directly). The wife then makes matters worse by attacking the Shahenshah directly and dragging in his marriage to a Hindu queen. It is no wonder that Jalal's temper flares up and she is sent to prison as well.

But for the equally incredible good sense of the child ' his Aapka mere liye kya aadesh hai? brings the Emperor up short - things would have stayed as they were. And if his parents had had even a fraction of his natural, diplomatic articulateness, they would have got justice from the Shahenshah right at the beginning.

Nonetheless, it is only because Jalal, after that intial spurt of anger at the parents, has the kindness of heart, and the empathy, to understand the plight of the child deprived of both his parents, that he sets aside his own rule and restores to the child his home and his happiness. It takes a meaure of greatness, especially in an absolute ruler, to recognize his mistake and to correct it.

That he explains the reason for his doing so to the whole assemblage is another mark of a great ruler, the recognition of the need to carry his people with him.

It is also significant that this time, he does not dress his reversal up in reasons of state, as he did while explaining to his advisers his decision to marry Jodha. It is primarily an emotional response to an emotional wrong, and he has no hesitation in acknowledging it as such. Or in weeping in public, or exposing his inner wounds to the public gaze. He is too strong a character to have such reservations; he goes by what he feels is right, and he will then not change his path for anyone or anything.

This needs to be noted. I have always held that while Jodha might, in the future, amplfy and strengthen Jalal's positive traits, such as a sense of justice, of fairness to all his subjects, religious tolerance ( a very, very rare trait anywhere in the world at that time) and so on, she does not create them. They are already present in him, and they have already surfaced at various moments independentl y of Jodha: his assertion, when chastising Adham Khan for his atrocities in Malwa, that even in a war, there would be no oppression of women, children or the aged is a case in point.

The rest is incidental. That some of the other begums taunt Ruqaiya about her defeat, and that they see a new tolerance towards the Hindus in the Diwan-e-Khas incident, and attribute it to Jodha, are both predictable. Ruqaiya's crushing response to them is accurate, but it will not dampen the malice of those over whom she has always ridden roughshod, and who now rejoice to see her hold, as they perceive it, weakening.

By the end, Bharmal & Co, are finally departing, after Jalal's slightly tongue in cheek assurance that thanks to his havng married their daughter, Amer is totally safe. Jodha is once more in full battle mode, any need for surface amenities to her patidev having departed with her parents.

I for one cannot understand why Jalal needs to force his Shahi firman on her; it seems to have become a matter of his ego now. She, having predictably left the Diwan-e-Am before Jalal showed his soft side, is ready to bite his head off. And so she does, metaphorically speaking.

I am pretty sure that when the Motibai vs Adham Khan case comes up before Jalal, and Mahaam Anga fixes the evidence as she did in Malwa. Jalal will pronounce the death sentence largely to force Jodha to accept the firman after all and use it to save Motibai's life.

And so we start all over again, with the next round of the battle of this quintessentially Odd Couple: Rhett and Scarlett, or Petruchio and Kate: take your pick.

Shyamala B.Cowsik

NB: A historical footnote for those interested in such matters. The Emperor Akbar and Queen Elizabeth I of England were contemporaries for practically the whole of their very long reigns: Akbar from 1556-1605 and Elizabeth I from 1558-1603. They also appear to have both had a very rough and endangered childhood.

After her mother, Anne Boleyn, was executed for treason by her father, King Henry VIII, the Princess Elizabeth was always walking a tightrope with her terrifying father. Later, she was constantly exposed to the risk being executed for treason by her elder stepsister Queen Mary, whenever some of the Protestant opponents of the rigidly Catholic Mary plotted to assassinate her and replace her by the non-Catholic Elizabeth. Jalal seems to have been equally at risk from his uncle, and then was always on the run from his father's enemies in the court of Sher Shah Suri.

That they both surmounted all this childhood trauma and went to become very great rulers who wrote their names in history is truly remarkable

Edited by sashashyam - 12 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

53

Views

6.5k

Users

28

Likes

308

Frequent Posters

Sexylicious. thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
I know right!! Jodha and Ruqqu scene was amazing. Thankx for the awesome post.
Res for now
SonyaBlade thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#3
Thanks for the post Aunty. It was a good episode...even with 30 minute episodes the story line is moving along at a good pace.

I wasn't going to write my opinion on the episode but well ...here it is anyways.

Personally, this whole childhood episode of Jalal feeling empty inside...its such a pathetic excuse to open up the space for Jodha and him to fall in love with each other that I"m deeply frustrated with the writing of this show, and I"m actually not even sure at this moment if I"m going to continue watching for much longer.

First, his judgement of the husband and wife - what a ridiculous scene in that there was no way back then that a poor couple such as them would have had the audacity to speak before the Shenshah in that manner. The writing of that scene... to set it up that the boy brings back Jalal's childhood memories...so obviously contrived that I was frustrated just watching it.

Okay, the scene when he thinks about his own childhood - its funny to me that as the responsibilities and weight of the kingdom are upon him he doesn't realize that what his father did, what his mother did were for his benefit. He's so selfish that he can't seem to see that. He cant seem to get out of his own self pity enough to observe and realize that without the sacrifices of his parents he would not have a kingdom...and even when his Khan Baba said 'who knows where your parents are or how they are doing" which was said with believable emotion, he doesn't view their actions in that way. He's so in his own world on that one point in his life, that even when he has everything, he is acting like he has nothing. Its not for lack of trying that his mother has tried to be close to him in the present, but he is the one that rebuffs her and prevents that relationship from growing. I"m just appalled that a Shenshah wouldn't realize the obvious about his past situation, that while unfortunate for his upbringing, were necessary for the future of HIS empire.

As for Jodha leaving per-emptively, again this is to set up her obliviousness of the reversal of his decision. I would have much rather her see him reverse the decision and ponder on that, ponder on who her husband really is...what he has been through in his life, and to start to analyze him deeper...instead of this ongoing one dimensional anger that we are being shown.

Anyways... I suppose we shall see where the story line goes...and if I continue to watch this drama. I knew there was a reason why I don't watch indian television for long...

I completely agree with your foreshadowing of why Jalal sentences Motibai to death...but again I"m not impressed with this rational. To play with someones life just to force Jodha into a corner. I"m so irritated...


Edited by SonyaBlade - 12 years ago
doyelpakhi thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#4
Dear Shyamala Aunty !

Thanks a lot for this lovely post! 😊

Can't agree with you more!

As far as the inappropriate behavior is concerned, then like Padshah, like Praja! 😉

Which Emperor, specially in 16th century, would ask his wives to sing in public or play chess in front of the entire court? 😉😆


Edited by doyelpakhi - 12 years ago
ginco thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#5


Great post again , thx for the same ...

Good episode , good pace ... one thing tht i really liked was also ruqu's face when jalal was in dewan-e-khas ... she felt for him n which was gud on the part of cv's to show ...i did not presume tht she might start doubting tht jalal had heart or tht she as a wife was not able to fill the gap after so many years ...because for now ... CV's r portraying her as a dumb , full of air CUPID ...i must say...
but it would have been good is she would have be shown thinking so...at least some concern for jalal...

N with the farmaan thing also , why is jalal giving her a wish ...JO can ask for anything ??? did he not give tht a thought ??...n yes u r absolutely right aunty ji tht JA would definitely announce severe punishment for moti to have JO agree n ask her wish from him...

Now it remains to be seen tht would JO come to know what happened in darbar after she{ as the news has supposedly reached Harem already } left n how would she react .. i guess go to her kanha jee n take her words back ...

Cheers
Kashi
sashashyam thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#6
Thank you, Ash.

I have added a historical footnote; in case you are interested, do take a look.

Shyamala Aunty


Originally posted by: Ashvikfever

I know right!! Jodha and Ruqqu scene was amazing. Thankx for the awesome post.
Res for now

sashashyam thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#7
Thank you, my dear.

I have added a historical footnote; in case you are interested, do take a look.

It is not a question of appropriateness. It is rather one of self-protection, even sheer survival. An Emperor can do anything, including to his wives (Henry VII executed 2 of his 6 wives for high treason on trumped up charges); the praja cannot do anything to the emperor.

If anyone had said to Henry VIII a fraction of what those two said to Jalal , they would not have been jailed. They would have been publicly executed for high treason, and possibly hung, drawn and quartered. Those were brutal times, and that was only a few years earlier than this time, as mentioned in my footnote. Jalal is very moderate, whatever his foolish wife might think An emperor would soon lose control if all and sundry could come and berate him like that. The folly of that couple is unbelievable.

Even today, if you berate a Head of State like that, and in public, what do you think is going to happen to your petition? Precisely nothing. If it had been Nixon, the Internal Revenue Service would have been after you the next day.

Shyamala Aunty

Originally posted by: doyelpakhi

Dear Shyamala Aunty !

Thanks a lot for this lovely post! 😊

Can't agree with you more!

As far as the inappropriate behavior is concerned, then like Padshah, like Praja! 😉

Which Emperor, specially in 16th century, would ask his wives to sing in public or play chess in front of the entire court? 😉😆

sashashyam thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#8
Dear Sonya,

At this rate, I am getting seriously concerned about you. You seem to me to be a prime candidate for ulcers. Relax, my dear. If they did not contrive occasionally incredible scenes, from where would they manufacture enough conflicts to last 400+ episodes? If you want crisp logic, you should go for the film. At just 100 episodes, the serial would not make money for Ekta, and she is not going to all this trouble to satisfy you or me of any of us, but to make money.

As for Jalal's fixations with his not having had his parent or parents with him, he thinks they should have kept him with them. There would have been dangers in either case, and it was not at all sure that the future of the empire would have been better served by farming Jalal off to Mahaam Anga as a small baby. She had no particular resources, and anything could have happened to the child. In their place, I would have kept my son with me. And ideas that get into your mind as a child often never leave. That is what keeps psychiatrists in business!

As for sentencing Motibai to death to bring Jodha to heel, why not? It is now open war, and in a war, all is fair.That is something Chanakya would have approved of. Jalal would, I think, not have implemented the sentence in any case, but he would have been sure Jodha would come seeking the firman.

All this said, I personally think you had better quit, instead of constantly getting exasperated at all and sundry,for there is going to be much more of the stuff that riles you. I am not joking, I really feel it, for I don't want you to be in a state of frustration all the time. What is the point of spending time on something you do not enjoy? And then spending still more time writing about it?

And less of 'the Indian television', if you please, I have watched a lot of US television, and even the ones that are not crude and vulgar are often unbearable for other reasons. The British do good shows based on the classics, though, and so did Doordarshan in the old days. up to the 1990s. Many of those are being retelecast now, like Chanakya.

Shyamala Aunty

Originally posted by: SonyaBlade

Thanks for the post Aunty. It was a good episode...even with 30 minute episodes the story line is moving along at a good pace.

I wasn't going to write my opinion on the episode but well ...here it is anyways.

Personally, this whole childhood episode of Jalal feeling empty inside...its such a pathetic excuse to open up the space for Jodha and him to fall in love with each other that I"m deeply frustrated with the writing of this show, and I"m actually not even sure at this moment if I"m going to continue watching for much longer.

First, his judgement of the husband and wife - what a ridiculous scene in that there was no way back then that a poor couple such as them would have had the audacity to speak before the Shenshah in that manner. The writing of that scene... to set it up that the boy brings back Jalal's childhood memories...so obviously contrived that I was frustrated just watching it.

Okay, the scene when he thinks about his own childhood - its funny to me that as the responsibilities and weight of the kingdom are upon him he doesn't realize that what his father did, what his mother did were for his benefit. He's so selfish that he can't seem to see that. He cant seem to get out of his own self pity enough to observe and realize that without the sacrifices of his parents he would not have a kingdom...and even when his Khan Baba said 'who knows where your parents are or how they are doing" which was said with believable emotion, he doesn't view their actions in that way. He's so in his own world on that one point in his life, that even when he has everything, he is acting like he has nothing. Its not for lack of trying that his mother has tried to be close to him in the present, but he is the one that rebuffs her and prevents that relationship from growing. I"m just appalled that a Shenshah wouldn't realize the obvious about his past situation, that while unfortunate for his upbringing, were necessary for the future of HIS empire.

As for Jodha leaving per-emptively, again this is to set up her obliviousness of the reversal of his decision. I would have much rather her see him reverse the decision and ponder on that, ponder on who her husband really is...what he has been through in his life, and to start to analyze him deeper...instead of this ongoing one dimensional anger that we are being shown.

Anyways... I suppose we shall see where the story line goes...and if I continue to watch this drama. I knew there was a reason why I don't watch indian television for long...

I completely agree with your foreshadowing of why Jalal sentences Motibai to death...but again I"m not impressed with this rational. To play with someones life just to force Jodha into a corner. I"m so irritated...

Edited by sashashyam - 12 years ago
Autumn_Rose thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#9
Thank you Aunty for the post. Children always seem to have an effect on jalal. His encounter with the little kid reminded me of an Akbar birbal story I had read as a kid. Where birbal challenges Akbar that there could be someone who can get way with anything.. Birbal hands over a small child to Akbar who pees on the emperor. Lol
sashashyam thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#10
Thanks a lot, Kashi my dear.

As for Ruqaiya's empathy with Jalal's feelings, you would have seen that I had specially mentioned it , saying:

The denouement of that scene was incredibly moving. And the striking, and strange thing was that the pain that was so visible in Jalal's eyes was mirrored in Ruqaiya's face,which twisted in empathy. A lifelong friendship cannot be dismissed or written off so easily; it has its own intimacies and symbiotic bonds.

It was not the Diwan-e-Khas, that is for meetings with the advisers of the Emperor. This is the Diwan-e-Aam, the Hall of Public Audience.

As for Jodha, I don't think she would have moderated her views on Jalal even if she had been there. She did not when she saw that the banjaras had been freed and were performing at the jashn. She has a determinedly closed mind on Jalal, and you would need plastic explosive to open it up.

Shyamala Aunty

Originally posted by: ginco



Great post again , thx for the same ...

Good episode , good pace ... one thing tht i really liked was also ruqu's face when jalal was in dewan-e-khas ... she felt for him n which was gud on the part of cv's to show ...i did not presume tht she might start doubting tht jalal had heart or tht she as a wife was not able to fill the gap after so many years ...because for now ... CV's r portraying her as a dumb , full of air CUPID ...i must say...
but it would have been good is she would have be shown thinking so...at least some concern for jalal...

N with the farmaan thing also , why is jalal giving her a wish ...JO can ask for anything ??? did he not give tht a thought ??...n yes u r absolutely right aunty ji tht JA would definitely announce severe punishment for moti to have JO agree n ask her wish from him...

Now it remains to be seen tht would JO come to know what happened in darbar after she{ as the news has supposedly reached Harem already } left n how would she react .. i guess go to her kanha jee n take her words back ...

Cheers
Kashi

Edited by sashashyam - 12 years ago

Related Topics

Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: Swissgerman

6 years ago

Jodha Akbar FF Who loves Him Most Chapter 78B updated on 08/07/2024

Jodha Akbar FF : --- Who loves Him Most (M) --- Link to my other threads Thread 1 Thread 2 - Thread 3 :::::Thread 4::::...

Expand ▼
Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: Swissgerman

9 years ago

Jodha Akbar FF: Shahzada of Her Dreams Chapter 48 Updated 20/7/2025

... Shahzada Of Her Dreams ... ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::Index::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: Chapter-1.....The beginning Chapter-2:...

Expand ▼
Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: ParijatDeewani

1 months ago

Jodha Akbar Vm Thread

Hey y'all! I've created this thread so that you'll can easily access all the Akdha Vms in one place. Please feel free to add to the list. 1....

Expand ▼
Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: lkdaswani

1 years ago

The Real Akbar.

Hello! This is a continuation of our discussion on just who the real Akbar was. Anyone is free to give their opinion and if all you guys wish to...

Expand ▼
Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: nushhkiee

6 months ago

Jodha Akkineni & Jalal Ahmed of Pale Blue Dot : A Story in Verse 💙

Before you read, This is strictly for die-hard and loyal fans of Pale Blue Dot ...our fellow PBDians ... I've been working on this since...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".