Jodha Akbar 33: Tangled Skeins

sashashyam thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#1

Folks,

I had hoped not to post tonight, for all our sakes, but no such luck for you or for me, it seems😉.

Jodha Akbar 33 was like a ball of wool with which a kitten has been having some fun, a cat's cradle of tangled skeins. One could not really disentangle any of them, but one learnt a good bit while trying to do so. Let us take them one by one, in no particular order.

Jalal: His two scenes today - the first with the banjara troupe, and the other with the would be assassin - were both extremely interesting and revealing.

A month ago, in my first ever post in this forum, Ekta's Emperor Jalaluddin Mohammed: an assessment (https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/jodha-akbar/3647623/ektas-emperor-jalaluddin-mohammed-an-assessment), I had noted, with reference to the payal incident, that it showed not his love for Jodha but his possessiveness towards her, which is not at all the same thing.

He does not kiss the payal as any ordinary lover would. It would be not be like the Shahenshah at all. He tosses it up in the air, but he always catches it, and when it falls into the fire, he burns his hand to retrieve it. This is not so much, as some have thought, a sign of passion for Jodha. He is not yet aware that he is falling in love with her, he does not know what love means. It is rather the possessiveness towards her that, as the line has it, uske parvaan chad gaya tha. For him, the payal symbolizes Jodha, and he will not let go of it or her, even if he has to burn his fingers to secure it.

It was exactly the same today. When he listens to the banjaras' ballad in praise of Jodha's manifold beauties - of face and figure, of her eyes, her lips, her hair, her gait -he goes back in time and sees her again as he had beheld her on the streets of Amer, and he smiles to himself involuntarily.

But immediately, his raw possessiveness towards this girl who is soon to be his begum, his and his alone, rears its head like an angry, hissing cobra. No one, but no one, can be permitted to hear this song and then imagine his Jodha as an object of desire. The cold menace in his eyes and voice as he warns the banjaras - after having rewarded them for this performance - against ever repeating it, is truly frightening, and those poor folk must not have stopped shivering for days!

An aside: Lagta hai ki Sharifuddin ki toh khair nahin. His folly, or impertinence, or both, in dragging his feet about bringing the Amer princes to the Shahenshah as instructed, is sure to cost him dearly, Bakshi Banu or no Bakshi Banu. Note how Chughtai Khan, now a trusted and valued go between with the Amer royal family and thus part of Jalal's inner circle, who dislikes Sharifuddin, neatly does chugli to Jalal about Sharifuddin not having done hukum ki taameel without delay!😉

The averted assassination attempt is even more revealing. Firstly, the Mughal security system seems to be dismal, seeing that a stranger armed with a khanjar managed to get into the Shahenshah's personal tent unnoticed, and that too to within 3 feet of him!

Next, Jalal is far more alert to potential danger than his entourage. He not only spots the khanjar but manages to remove it unnoticed by the bearer of the weapon. But it is when he deals with the man that we get the true measure of a great ruler in the making, with an unerring grasp of human psychology.

By daring the man to cut his throat, Jalal confuses him and puts him at a mental and psychological disadvantage. That man will never again be able to see Jalal as the devil incarnate, especially after he is pardoned and allowed to leave unscathed. Here we see, in Jalal, the seeds of the future Akbar, for it was thru such gestures and such calculated magnanimity, multiplied a thousand fold, that Akbar won over much of hostile Hindustan.

Ruquaiya: My erstwhile favourite is going down the tubes, and fast. What sort of intelligence network does she have that she is still in the dark about Jalal's latest matrimonial venture? Instead, she sits there doing exactly what she ridicules the other begums for doing, accumulating jewellery (note the subtle but unmistakable boost for Rajasthani kaarigari in jewellery!)😉.

I could not understand how it was that Mahaam Anga had not dropped in, or her way to Amer with Jalal for the wedding, to bring Ruqaiya up to speed on this momentous development, and amplify on her earlier warning to her about the need to hold her husband tight and not let him stray. One would have thought that Mahaam would never have passed up such a godsent opportunity to stick a knife into Ruqaiya - who had once reminded her, with true Timurid arrogance, that she was only a dasi - and then twist it with glee. We have missed a classic encounter, alas!

One odd point, why has Ruqaiya suddenly demoted herself from the Malika-e-Hind to merely the Malika-e-Khaas?

Bharmal & Spouse: They are an odd couple.

She is the antithesis of the traditional, strong Rajasthani (now replaced onscreen by a bizarre mutation, Rajvanshi, a rootless entity that could be from anywhere from Kamrup {today's Assam } to Kerala) matriarch. She is eternally in a flood of tears these days, and takes to her bed, exactly like Mrs. Bennet in Pride and Prejudice after her favourite daughter elopes with a good for nothing young man. Where Mynavati should be there as a lightning rod and a safety net for Jodha, she instead imposes an additional emotional burden on her with her unexplained wailing and weeping.

He is square of both face and body, undistinguished and uninspiring, and of late he is also a man hounded by unfamiliar demons - ostracism and public humiliation among his own class, fear of what the future holds. He takes the easy way out, grasping at the escape route Jodha offers him when she refuses to let him tell her whom she would be marrying. It was his responsibility to tell her, so that she would be spared the shock and dismay of either learning it from an outsider, or worst of all, only at the ceremony itself. But he chickens out, and is now babbling of Jodha's niyati revealing the truth to her somehow, and then giving her the strength to bear it. Some father, this!

Jodha: She remains curiously unaffected by the evident and unusual emotional turmoil around her ' whether it is her mother, Motibai, or Sukanya. The tongue cutting incident was a very grave and shocking one, and it is strange that though she is then distracted from probing the kaali zubaan comment, Jodha does not revert to it later. She explains away curious points ' the odd comment about Motibai's 'marriage' let fall by young Mansingh, Motibai's tears, or the hasty departure of Kunwar Pratap's delegation - to herself without showing the least urge to probe them, an urge that would have been expected in such an intelligent young princess. None of this is convincing.

It is even less credible that when the whole of Amer knows about the Mughal Shahenshah being Jodha's bridegroom, she has not learnt of it from someone by now.

By the way, what was it with that gaggle of female servants at the confidential meeting where Bharmal reveals the truth about Jodha's marriage, whereas his 3 daughters are all kept out of it? He could just as well have hired the town crier to announce it to the populace😉!

It is also clear that thanks to Bharmal's pusillanimity, Jodha is now in for a very bad shock at her wedding. She is obviously under the impression that her bridegroom is a Rajput king, who she assumes has taken on the Mughals to help Amer out. Not only this, she is actually expecting this new savior to complete the task the unfortunate Suryabhan had sworn to achieve! The only saving grace today was that the Jalal ka sar mantra was not trotted out, but it was hanging over the scene nonetheless, like a ghostly presence.

Given all this, it is difficult to stop oneself from (virtually) clobbering the First Couple of Amer for their folly and cowardice in keeping Jodha in the dark till the end.

Jokes of the day: The Amer Ministers, who seem to competing among themselves for the first prize for stupidity, suggesting that their King palm Jalal off with Motibai instead of Jodha. I was in stitches imagining Jalal's face when he raises the ghunghat😉! Riyya, my poor girl, you are apparently stuck with Motibai, for she is surely going to Agra with Jodha!

The choice of an Ekta regular, Anurag Sharma, who plays minor roles in her other soaps and who looks about 40, to play the fiery, 20 year old Kunwar Pratap.

This apart, the tone and tenor of his tirade against Bharmal in the latter's own audience hall was so harsh that one would have expected Bharmal or Bhagwan Das to call the visitor to order and have him ejected. Instead, father and son stand there like dummies while Pratap lets them have it with both barrels. Not that I was surprised!

Shyamala B.Cowsik

Edited by sashashyam - 12 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

38

Views

5.4k

Users

21

Likes

125

Frequent Posters

Mallika-E-Bhais thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
Oh I await your analysis ardently!!infact I've scrolled up and down reading most of them!! You are spot on when you say all this. It is true that the Amer nobility are clowns dancing. The worst of all is that they don't realise it! Jodha not knowing of her grooms identity though very suspect, can be explained. Bhaarmal did say that he didn't want anyone to tell Jodha of her upcoming nuptials with the one man she detests- Jalall! So when the MaharJa her father, has forbidden anyone of mentioning it to her, I doubt anyone would want their head to be knocked off their shoulders by relaying this bit to J! But for someone so feisty & intelligent, I too, like you Aunty, find Jodha's passiveness out of character. But I waiting desperately for 5th Aug!!! When they both FINALLY come face to face!!! And now it's going to be aired for a hr!!!!
Morana thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 12 years ago
#3
I really laughed a lot reading your post , it was interesting n very nicely written.
I must say I always like your Pride n Prejudice references , being an ardent fan of both the book n the movies ( not the Gurindar Chadah one though 😆 ).
I wonder why Mainawati herself isn't taking the step , to tell her daughter the name of her fiance, in stead of pinching n EA-ing her husband ?
Glad that Bharmal atleast admitted straight faced that he lacks the courage to say it to Jodha. Jodha trusts her father rather blindly, so she's in for a rude shock.
As for Jodha ignoring all the S/S of some thing wrong in the wind ( rather thickly perfumed with suspicious events I must say ) but may be these events seem to us more obvious , because we viewers already know exactly what is wrong n Jodha is blissfully unaware.
She has always spent her life in such a family cocoon , that it's quite unimaginable for her that her parents, rather her dear daddy can do this to her . N she did wonder why MP left so abruptly , but as she could find no reason , she gave up the attempt ( I'm not saying she shouldn't have probed it ! Hell this innocence look out towards the world she needs to change big time ! Or else she's in for deep trouble ! ).
I know Jodha has a lot of brain n she can use them very effectively if she puts her mind to it , like recognising Jalal, to giving proper answer back to that sell's woman at Agra bazar, or to Ruqaiya later. But may be lately she has gone through a rough phase which, though she didn't express it to other people , Jodha being Jodha , is still there in the form of deep wound , as we saw her today shedding tears remembering Surya. So , her brains are in a slumber phase right now , she refuses to read the signs , just refuses that some thing worse , much worse may be in store for her.
Would like to know your view as to whether my words make any sense , because I'm using my heart to assist my typing fingers, rather than my logical brain. 😆
But may be that's a better way to read Jodha, the girl is still very much in the grasp of her own heart than her clear, sharp brain. 😳
SonyaBlade thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#4
Todays' episode was definitely a mish mash of everything...I agree with you that there is no realistic way in which jodha can be left ignorant of who her future husband is...

BUT, i'm surprised you didn't mention anything about the touching scene between jodha and motibai...and the scene between Jodha and Maan Singh.

Even though the character development for jodha is frustrating those two scenes today out did for me the Jalal scenes. I am actually quite put out with some of the dialogues of Jalal but I wont delve into it right now.

As for Motibai - I truly was impressed with her today, and love Jodha's and her relationship. Today those two won me over with their true affection with one another. In a world where woman are not permitted much freedom you find friends where they are, and as Jodha doesn't seem to be super close to her sisters, the friendship between her dasi and her is truly reflective of Jodha's open mindedness and love for everyone, regardless of station...

As for Maan Singh, too bad we are not going to get to see much of him in the future. i loved how he is ready to protect his \Bhuasa...oh the open love and affection between those two and the playfulness with which they both talk to one another...truly a great scene IMO.

As for Jodha - I think, or at least I'm trying to explain away that they are trying to show a truly devastated jodha right now...the scene where she talks to herself...sort of reflects it. So its amazing how she is able to be so strong even when she is emotionally crippled right now. But that might explain why she seems to be willing to not dig deeper and just takes everyones word at face value without investigating.

Cheers,

Sonya
SonyaBlade thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#5
Oh also, from the other thread I think you misunderstood, but let me explain...is not possessiveness, a need to own her and make her his a type of PASSION????

I don't think Jalal loves her at all actually. at least not right now...but its definitely a type of passion isn't it??? The way he thinks of her, the way he forbids anyone to praise her or sing about her beauty...that is his way of wanting to establish his ownership...but only one that cares in some way, whether negative or positive, can act so aggressive.

Jalal's passion - IMO, does not equal love right now, but from the Bhanjara scene I definitely left thinking wow what a passionate man...this is going to be negative for Jodha at the moment, but still Jalal's reaction is simply WOW...
sashashyam thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#6
Sonya dear,

About Jalal, I stand firmly by my interpretation of his threat to the banjaras. In fact, I was surprised by the kind of song they were singing about a princess, it went too far into the description of each of her physical attractions. What to speak of Jalal, I do not think even Suryabhan would have liked his wife to be described like this for the delectation of any aira gaira who might be in the audience. The banjara would have been warned and told not to repeat it, even if not so harshly as Jalal does.

As for the 2 scenes you have mentioned, have a heart😉 ! How much more do you want me to type, till past 2 am with a sore wrist? And don't worry, you will see plenty of Mansingh, who will very likely move to Agra. I am off to bed now.

Shyamala B.Cowsik

Originally posted by: SonyaBlade

Todays' episode was definitely a mish mash of everything...I agree with you that there is no realistic way in which jodha can be left ignorant of who her future husband is...

BUT, i'm surprised you didn't mention anything about the touching scene between jodha and motibai...and the scene between Jodha and Maan Singh.

Even though the character development for jodha is frustrating those two scenes today out did for me the Jalal scenes. I am actually quite put out with some of the dialogues of Jalal but I wont delve into it right now.

As for Motibai - I truly was impressed with her today, and love Jodha's and her relationship. Today those two won me over with their true affection with one another. In a world where woman are not permitted much freedom you find friends where they are, and as Jodha doesn't seem to be super close to her sisters, the friendship between her dasi and her is truly reflective of Jodha's open mindedness and love for everyone, regardless of station...

As for Maan Singh, too bad we are not going to get to see much of him in the future. i loved how he is ready to protect his \Bhuasa...oh the open love and affection between those two and the playfulness with which they both talk to one another...truly a great scene IMO.

As for Jodha - I think, or at least I'm trying to explain away that they are trying to show a truly devastated jodha right now...the scene where she talks to herself...sort of reflects it. So its amazing how she is able to be so strong even when she is emotionally crippled right now. But that might explain why she seems to be willing to not dig deeper and just takes everyones word at face value without investigating.

Cheers,

Sonya

Edited by sashashyam - 12 years ago
sashashyam thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#7
Oh dear, here I am still! Yes, I get it now, but them why do you dislike it? It is perfectly natural, even the mild and inoffensive Saraswatichandra reacfs in exactly the same way in that serial.

And no, Jalal does not love her yet, because he has no idea of what love is like. When it comes, he will fight it tooth and nail till he succumbs. But possessiveness can exist independently of love, or passion.

Shyamala B.Cowsik

Originally posted by: SonyaBlade

Oh also, from the other thread I think you misunderstood, but let me explain...is not possessiveness, a need to own her and make her his a type of PASSION????

I don't think Jalal loves her at all actually. at least not right now...but its definitely a type of passion isn't it??? The way he thinks of her, the way he forbids anyone to praise her or sing about her beauty...that is his way of wanting to establish his ownership...but only one that cares in some way, whether negative or positive, can act so aggressive.

Jalal's passion - IMO, does not equal love right now, but from the Bhanjara scene I definitely left thinking wow what a passionate man...this is going to be negative for Jodha at the moment, but still Jalal's reaction is simply WOW...

Sharlene1410 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#8
Thanks so much for sharing this in dept analysis daily I look forward to this since i live in the WI and love the show but do not understand the language also there is some three hours to go before i see it on Tv so this post helps. 🤗
veil_of_roses thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#9
Nice write up Shyamala.
I found today's epi mashed up. tried of Jodha crying & blaming mughals all the time.
Never saw such parents who would put their daughter in such place w/o any warning.
I didnt like Shaguni's return, unless she will tell me specific date of wedding.
I miss smiley as Ruquiya as this one is plain boring.I thought she wud have khabri who wud let her know abt Akbar's new wedding as u mentioned.

-Gargi
skanda12 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#10
Shyamala:
Great great post! Loved it. I have nothing to add!👏👏👏
Regarding the Banjara incident, I too agree that Jalal is not yet in love so what he did must be out of possessiveness. Much like the portrait burning. It is clear that he adores Jodha's beauty, but the minute someone else also voices it, he wastes no time in declaring his intended malice towards anyone else noticing or mentioning her fine points!
But there's the catch ...
... according to him there is nothing but panga in his mind regarding Jodha ... but by which stretch of the imagination is panga compatible with possessiveness? Panga is revenge on an "enemy" while possessiveness is a factor of "ownership". Panga is mind-games while possessiveness is about heart illogicality (nothing to do with mental deliberation).
Think, Jalal, think!
If panga is merely your game, how is it that a sense of ownership and possessiveness about Jodha is coloring the works? Can it be that the emotions of the heart are eating away fast into the intentions of the mind?
At this rate he may soon be all heart and no mind as far as she is concerned, which again is not a good balanced thing to be. He needs to drop his panga, and he needs to love - but with some mental control over extreme love.
Overall about yesterday's episode it seemed to me like the Creatives were trying to show the growing enmity on all sides to this alliance as the context of this shaadi. Here the Rajput clan in all its shades and colours wwas clearly overtly opposed - while on the Mughal side the mutiny was more covert. Sharifuddin not listening to diktats to release the Bharmal brothers suggests silent disobedience, and he's going to have it now from Jalal. Who knows, if Sharif has been leching after Jodha himself, he may well unleash some unmentionable verbiage about her being a "cheez" in front of jalal, and then we will know how hard Jalal may take it!
The upshot of yesterday was that while externals all seem to be ranging up against Jodha-Jalal, the whole milieu is also creating a togetherness space also for them as they are two against the hordes. That's a huge advantage point to start a marriage from. My father always used to say that "elopement" at least protected the pair from having to inherit the in-laws along with the new spouse straightaway. Jodha and Jalal may be surrounded by ill-wishers - and may therefore enjoy more alone-space to start with and find more reasons to rally around each other.
Edited by skanda12 - 12 years ago

Related Topics

Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: Swissgerman

6 years ago

Jodha Akbar FF Who loves Him Most Chapter 78B updated on 08/07/2024

Jodha Akbar FF : --- Who loves Him Most (M) --- Link to my other threads Thread 1 Thread 2 - Thread 3 :::::Thread 4::::...

Expand ▼
Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: Swissgerman

9 years ago

Jodha Akbar FF: Shahzada of Her Dreams Chapter 48 Updated 20/7/2025

... Shahzada Of Her Dreams ... ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::Index::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: Chapter-1.....The beginning Chapter-2:...

Expand ▼
Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: ParijatDeewani

1 months ago

Jodha Akbar Vm Thread

Hey y'all! I've created this thread so that you'll can easily access all the Akdha Vms in one place. Please feel free to add to the list. 1....

Expand ▼
Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: nushhkiee

5 months ago

Jodha Akkineni & Jalal Ahmed of Pale Blue Dot : A Story in Verse 💙

Before you read, This is strictly for die-hard and loyal fans of Pale Blue Dot ...our fellow PBDians ... I've been working on this since...

Expand ▼
Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: nushhkiee

6 months ago

Jodha recreated - A beautiful nostalgia 😍

Hello People.....Our Pari just posted her recreated Jodha look for a paid partnership promotion ... absolutely loved it ... she still captures...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".