Madhuri complete fail as a judge

... this season it feels like all she does is randomly throw out a couple of words including that highly irritating "perrrfect" ... does she think its cute? .. ... or does she think she is speaking to 5 year olds? ... . she just parrots what remo says and gives mostly +1 over what remo has given

all we see is manish and kapil with their lame jokes about their supposed crush on MD ... the actors that come all continue in the same vein irrespective of age ... its becoming tiring ...

.. strangely juhi chawla who is not remembered for her dancing skills was a far better dance judge ... i remember she would actually ask that how to we judge the celebrities - based on how far the non dancers have come or should we compare them to other trained dancer competitors ... thats the thing that all us viewers were asking ... apparently knowing dance and judging it are two different things


As someone pointed out in another thread, though MD is a fabulous dancer, this "dance ki devi" always gets beaten by her co dancers (karishma/ aishwarya) ... i never had any hope from that highly annoying Kjo but what has happened to MD this season? ... there is a lot of MD bhakti, but what happened to all her shakti ? 😛 (lame, i know!)

love the way you have put it in words...she annoys me a lot.. all the contestants and guests behave like God has come to earth..and she just enjoys the glory sitting on the chair!! free money, no judging

she is just a showpiece and is there for glamour🤓

Word..While i am an MD fan, she sucks as a judge..Infact all three suck cos of various reasons😆Remo is biased to the core but majority don notice it cos he covers it up by talking about the technical aspects😆 And am still not sure why KJO is here😆 Madhuri on the other hand keeps using the same adjectives again and again & seldom comments on the technical aspects of the performance..The gushing and flirting has kinda become stale as well..Now when you look at DID super moms and the panel of judges there, it honestly pales in comparison..

😆..Haha...I agree w/ the post above as well as with u..all the three judges suck in different ways...KJO as someone said I don't understand why he is even the judge at the first place? Can I say you are the first person on this forum who has analyzed MD wonderfully! You know I have to share this, my cousin is a very smart, intelligent when it comes to studying, but he really sucks at teaching other people, and I guess same can be said for MD. She is a great dancer, but she really is embarrassing as a judge..! I guess that is what human flaws are there in MD's case. just b/c she is a great dance, doesn't mean she can be a great judge! Infact, it is totally opposite in her case just like my cousin...I guess we as human beings expect people who are talented in their areas of interest, are talented as well in the other areas related to their area of interest. But, that is really not the case...😆...Remo yes, he does cover up his faults w/ technicalities...But, I do believe KJO and MD don't deserve to be on the judge seat

There's generally too much actor/actress worship and promotion and not enough dancing on the show, in my opinion. The contestants always have either 1) a crush on Remo, or 2) a crush on MD, or 3) both. Remo always has to be romanced. MD always has to sing and dance.

she sucks. same comments, same *sweet act*s same *perrfect*s same *outstanding*s


she sucks to the core.. i dont like her as a dancer

She's a highly overrated person on Jhalak. Period.

i m her fan