Islam and QH - Request to all muslims

Page

Nazj001

@Nazj001

Beginner

Posted: 12 years ago

QH is a Muslim drama and as every Muslim knows that taking the help of palm readers or ghost drivers is considered as SHIRK i.e. being among the unpardonable sins according to Islam. I don't know how Gul could have missed such an important thing. Does this act was really necessary? They could have used some other way to make Humeira fall in the arms of Ayaan.

Also, Muslim ladies are not allowed to visit the graveyard, How can Zoya go to graveyard.

Now I have a doubt: Is Qubool Hai really a drama based on Muslim cultures.

Quote

Frequent Posters

NERMINE

@NERMINE

Explorer

Posted: 12 years ago

El Saalam Alikom

Unfortunately they are current(common) practices
Gul really shows us the customs of people
There is certain Muslims which unfortunately practical the witchcraft it is blasphemous

But Gul depends what really takes place in the Muslim community

Then a woman has no right to follow the men in the cemetery during the funeral
But afterward the women can go freely to pray on the grave of the deaths with the head covered well

And I know about what I speak I am Muslim practising
I think that you should not mix everything once again it is a fiction and Gul tries at best to depict our community thus you should not blame her

By the fact that if you have wanted a religious series Islamic it is not QH at whom it is necessary to look

And finally I find that this 1st series based on a Muslim family is made well, Gul offends nobody

In any case it is my own opinion

RAMADAN MUBARAK TO ALL MY FRIENDS

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Sana

@sana_sugarbun

Dazzler

Posted: 12 years ago

Im telling everyone since day one Gul is showing all nonsense and baseless things that muslims dont even do. May things are shirk.

Going to Dargas..cmon do muslims go to dargas???🤢

Waiting for meteor showers and praying???

believeing in witchcrafts..ok some of them do but astrologers and all this shit??😡

Quote

nazali

@nazali

Explorer

Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: sana_sugarbun
Im telling everyone since day one Gul is showing all nonsense and baseless things that muslims dont even do. May things are shirk.

Going to Dargas..cmon do muslims go to dargas???🤢
Waiting for meteor showers and praying???
believeing in witchcrafts..ok some of them do but astrologers and all this shit??😡

I actually wants to ask the same question, I'm Malaysian and we are majority muslim and we don't have dargah here...my hubby told me it is consider shrik to ask anything from dargah and u can only ask from Allah SWT...My hubby told me that if I still want to watch the show which he doesn't prefer that I need to make sure I filter it out before I accept the scene in QH...

Quote

Ayra Nuzhat

@-LazyLamhe-

Dazzler

Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: Nazj001
QH is a Muslim drama and as every Muslim knows that taking the help of palm readers or ghost drivers is considered as SHIRK i.e. being among the unpardonable sins according to Islam. I don't know how Gul could have missed such an important thing. Does this act was really necessary? They could have used some other way to make Humeira fall in the arms of Ayaan.

Also, Muslim ladies are not allowed to visit the graveyard, How can Zoya go to graveyard.

Now I have a doubt: Is Qubool Hai really a drama based on Muslim cultures.

Hey!

I agree that muslims taking palm readers/ghost riders/visiting dargah is considered shirk..I totally agree with you but at the same time QH is an family drama with indian muslim characters and not an Islam preaching show!

Unfortunately all of this happens in some Indian muslim communities. I gather you are not from India so you might not have known..So there is no point accusing the PH in this regard. PH is only showing what happens in the indian muslim communities.

As regards to visiting the graveyard...Yes, women are not supposed to enter a funeral BUT they can visit their loved ones grave later..

There are different type of people yah with different beliefs..we may agree with some..may not agree with some but it does not mean it does not exist..likewise there is a variety amongst Muslims themselves..with different cultures..some influenced regionally...Asians/Americans/Gulf/the east all follow islam in their own way(with fundamental intact)...

why only worldwide?? there are different types of muslims in india itself!!! Some visit dargah...some dont...some visit grave ...some dont...etc..(the list may be long)

I only want to say lets just enjoy the show for Asad and Zoya..If you dnt agree with something being Islamic..give it a benefit of doubt that maybe it happens in Indian muslim communties...Allah bless us all and Ramadan mubarak..

ps - I am an indian muslim :)...I have no intention to offend anyone here..we are all QH fans and will remain to be so..Allah Hafiz

Quote

Smarty786

@Smarty786

Beginner

Posted: 12 years ago

+1 . I second that its just a daily soap,so better not to make "Rai ka pahaad" here.

Regarding Dargha- I am a girl and an indian muslim,I GO TO NIZAMUUDIN BABA KA DARGHA whenever i get time. I will be going to KHAWAZA BABA KA DARGAH,AJMER very soon insa Allah.And you know what ruhani sukoon milti hai.its magical and surreal to be there.I get mental peace there.

But there are many others who do not.

I visit my Dad's grave many times whenever i feel very depressed or on his death anniversary.No one stops me.

My point is keep religion out of entertainment and enjoy the show.

Because there is a great diversity in every sects of religion.

P.S. I do not intend to hurt anyone's sentiment.Just replied because i thought its important to tell that every individual is not same when it comes to faith.

Cheers!

Take Care!😊

Quote

Xarina

@Xarina

Sparkler

+ 7

Posted: 12 years ago

If I may step in. These are my views and my views only. I do not wish to offend anyone. If I do, I apologise.

There are certain practices that are carried out under the religion umbrella which have no basis there. They are embedded in the culture or tradition of the area and communities accept it without thinking.

As far as women going to the cemetary my understanding is this:

In the times of the prophet (SAW) women used to follow the funeral procession, wailing, weeping loudly and beating their chests. It is said that he did not like this practice and since then it is said that women do not accompany the body to the cemetary.

I was told this when my mother died last year and we wanted to go and bury her. In the end we decided that we would accompany her body to the grave. We did not wail, weep or beat our chests. It was actually very dignified and we said goodbye to mum with a lighter heart. In essence it is unfair to bar a woman from the graveside but as I say this is my view only.

Quote

Dhani

@Dhani_

Inactive

Posted: 12 years ago

its best if I keep my view private

Edited by Charli_ - 12 years ago

Quote

Sana

@sana_sugarbun

Dazzler

Posted: 12 years ago

The ones who think its ok for Gul to show such stuff as at the end of the day its for entertainment????????Cmon I really dont want to hear such answers. How would you feel if your religion is shown in a completely wrong light???🤢Women are shown really brutal and violent. Acid, burying in walls and grounds, dragging a poor old lady all the way in a sack, keeping her closed in a store room etc etc???W*F is GUL showing??Does she want to show the people that muslim women are so brutal and vicious????If she was so much interested in a Muslim show she should have researched. Watched a few Paki/Arabic serials to get her facts right😡

Quote

Islam and QH - Request to all muslims

Related Topics

Explore Topics