Originally posted by: Pari117
We believe that everything has a solution, every disease has got treatment, every mistake has got punishment but what about obsession?? Its a situation where person doesnt know even what he/she is doing. Lifetime imprisonment or death sentence are definately two punishments i can see for zara for murdering savita and attempts to murder indira. But can these punishments ever make her realize her mistakes??? I dont think so, i definately want zara to be punished but along with Self - Realization too.
This post is just an attempt to find out how such obsession can be tamed?? Or can they never be?? And if every problem has got solutions then how can Zara be made realize it. I have seen that usually such patients are tamed by giving electric shocks but i find that it just tranquilizes them rather than realization of their mistakes. Kindly throw some light how can Zara be dealt to make her realize her faults? Or She can never realize it.
Good post Pari , post that makes you think . I want to put my two cents in . I hope that helps you . I am not talking about Zara but I want to talk about condition that Zara is suffering form . It's useless to talk about Zara beacuse she is written and not real . They will change her behavior in no time .so lets take her condition only
ECT is recommended when a severe clinical depression is not responding to other treatments (such as psychotherapy and medications), or when there is a need for a rapid response (such as when there is a high risk of suicide, or the when the depression itself is threatening the health of the person). As such, ECT can be a life-saving treatment because it is rapidly effective, even when other treatments fail.but Zara condition is not . I personally do not approve of this and my university hospital has banned this treatment !but I have seen it's miracle in some patients .
Zara has. Psychopatic personality disorder which is exaggerated by psychosis and part of ther personality is obsessive personality . Now pshychopathic disorder consist of Criminal Predispositions: Tendency for impulsive or opportunistic criminal behavior, excessive risk taking, impulsive or opportunistic violence Tendency for premeditated crimes with controllable risks, criminal opportunism, fraud, calculated or opportunistic violence
Psychotherapy is nearly always the treatment of choice for this disorder; medications may be used to help stabilize mood swings or specific and acute Axis I concurrent diagnoses. There is no research that supports the use of medications for direct treatment of antisocial personality disorder.
I personally do not believe in punishment although its needed to treat criminal behavior as last resort .in Zara' situation she needs good psychotherapist and behavior modification treatment with medication to control her obsessive thought . In plane English Supportive friend who understands her and gives insight in her problems.
these are my POVS.
Edited by Heema22 - 12 years ago
Book Talk
