Would it have been different if...?

RosyRosh thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#1
So after having witnessed MANY opinions .. some valid some questionable 🤣 on the forum, I think its about time I come back with my own posts with my own perspectives on the current show happenings. 🤔

Comments and Likes are much appreciated

1. The topics about whether Billi and Asad had a Chitty Chitty Bang Bang.

My POV: NO. 😳

Come on now guys, we can all use our own IMAGINATIONS and GENERAL KNOWLEDGE and YEARS of HEALTH CLASS CURRICULUM to know that NOTHING happened! 🤣 Opening up a dudes SHIRT, tearing your own clothing and putting your HEAD on someone's chest DOES NOT equal .. well... you know. 😆
Its just not possible. AND, if there is any DOUBT that something did, than can we please remember that all MSK (Tanveer) is concerned with is SHAKING Zoya's TRUST. She said in very beginning that she has NO interest in him, and ONLY his money and wealth. PLUS she is PREGNANT. now Granted even in pregnancy, the act in question can happen, but this is INDIAN television. 😆 lets not forget. I doubt they would show a PREGNANT woman, doing the dirty with someone. 🤔 Gul is simply concerned with throwing the AUDIENCE in twists and turns. As much as I have concerns at times with her story-telling, i do have ULTIMATE faith that she would NEVER show the lead having intimate relations with a woman OTHER than the female main lead. 🤔

The reason Im bringing this up again is only because I know many members were giving Asad beef for all this and bringing up RAPE and this and that.. YES it was sexual harassment.. but it wasn't rape. NOTHING HAPPENED and even if we did, unless we know for sure something DEFINITELY happened, i dont think we should title it something 😆 and I think most of us are sure that Asad is still PURE. 😆 BIGGEST symbolism of that was his WHITE outfit. 😉 WHITE=PURITY. Gul could have gone with ANY OTHER color option for Asad's sherwani.. but she CHOSE WHITE. Im sure thats the BIGGEST clue to us from the CV's. 😉 Tanveer's main intention was to SHAKE Zoe's trust, and make ASAD believe he did something he shouldn't have ONLY so she can come back and say that he is her BABY DADDY.

2. Zoya's TRUST

Okay, so as much as I UNDERSTAND that Zoe's reaction to the whole Sleeping fiasco was VALID and JUSTIFIED, because ANY WOMAN who sees her man with another woman in such a compromising position would FEEL betrayed and hurt. So I GET IT.

However, here is what I just don't get at all:

Zoe knew Billi's plan right? She was well aware that MSK was planning a SR with Asad. So taking into consideration THIS fact and also the FACT that she and Asad have also had some close encounters, but HE NEVER took advantage of her or NEVER crossed a line with HER .. I kind of expected Zoe to Give Asad a Chance to SPEAK at the least. I mean, I get it that he does deserve the same treatment as he has given her at times when he doubted her and misunderstood her, but Asad has ALWAYS been that way. Thats his CHARACTER. Zoe's character is more UNDERSTANDING and someone who would give others a chance to justify right? 🤔 So considering the facts, I really expected her OUT OF CHARACTER to give Asad a chance to speak.

Now, Here is where the title of my post comes into play:
Would it have been different if..?

Guys, if Asad had SAID "I LOVE YOU.", would Zoe have given him a chance to justify himself? 🤔 I feel like Dilshaad's convo's with Asad FORCING him to confess to her.. and him not being able to was PURPOSELY there for this moment. If Asad had made it clear to Zoe that he LOVES HER, then maybe Zoe would have had the extra confidance and trust in him to hear him out? 🤔 I mean it is a BIT far-fetched.. but i can't help but wonder what the purpose of all those ATTEMPTED AND FAILED I love you's were for.

3. Why I think AsYa SHOULD marry in Ajmer.

Not only because i really want them to ☺️ but I feel like it is the RIGHT time. Yes granted they need to build trust in each other but I feel like that is WHAT this whole fiasco was for. To get the trist thing SETTLED. Once that is settled, I feel Asad and Zoe should really MARRY in Ajmer. So MANY different things are still YET to happen, and frankly, I don't think the TRUTHS that still need to be revealed will have AS MUCH AFFECT as they SHOULD unless AsYa tie the knot. Because, Asad and Zoe need to be shown DEALING with the upcoming revelations A COUPLE. And this is just my opinion. 😳

4. AyRa Got Engaged

But Why? And by that I mean.. AFTER all the FAILED attempts in their engagement.. i find it a Bit WIERD that they got engaged so easily. Or is just : Third times a charm? (it was the 3rd time right? 😆). Im MORE THAN happy that they did! God I LOVE THEM and i think many people know that 🤣.. i just fnid it a Bit FUNNY and ODD at the same time that:

When AyRa relationship was BUILT: Engagement,
AsYa relationship BROKE.

Knowing that these two couples have such huge PARALLELS Im just not understanding the contradictions in their storylines.

I STILL expect: AS ANKIE (MisHumptyDumpty) has repeatedly pointed out in her posts as well, that BOTH couples will MARRY at the same time. BUT, if that is the case, then WHY the stretching? Why did AyRa engagement break twice before the 3rd time?

5. Humz and Zoe

WHAT THE HECK was the purpose of showing humz not seeing Zoe's face is she was to EASILY see it at the wedding? I mean I am thinking about it and Humz hasn't seen the FACE of her WELL WISHER. She has merely seen the fact and now knows the name of her future HUBBY's Bhabhi. 🤔 BUt still.. i find it was WIERD and RUSHED. 🤔

6. Raazia's Mr. India's

How the HECk did Raazia get out of that MENTAL asylum? How the HECK did BILLI get IN without the doc's not telling DADI? How did Raaz Get out without docs telling Daadi? How the HECK did Billi know Raaz was there? Did Raaz CALL tanveer? And if she did HOW DID Raaz have a PHONE on her?

Come on now Gul. REALLY?

__________________________________________

anyways thats all my ramblings for now. 😆 I just had SO MUCH to say for days. 😆 And these arent even all the points. 😆 Just some of them. ANyways, I really am hoping for the healthy responses I used to get WAY back when 😳 So please guys do share! 😳

Before I go, I have one TRAIN of thought for everyone:

WHOSE FAULT is the SUHAAG Raat Fiasco Anyways?

BILLI "slept" with Asad, why? Because she wants his money and property and to piss Zoe off.

Would she have done this if Imran excepted her child? PROBABLY NOT.

So is it Imran's fault?

I think Imran is just a WEAK character and frankly I don't blame him. Billi Entered asYa's life because of ONE woman. RAAZIA. Imran DENIED Tanveer because he is in a relationship with Nikhat and because she left him. But If Imran and Nikhat WERE NOT in an engagment (an engagment fixed by RAAZIA) and if Billi was never called by Raazia, would Imran and Billi have sorted out their issues? Billi may never have targeted Asad or THOUGHT of targetting Asad otherwise.

So is this RAAZIA"S fault?

OR is it Gauffurs fault whose DECIET made Raazia into a CONNIVING woman that she is? OR has raazia ALWAYS been coniving because of which Gaffu FELT the need to cheat on her. 🤔

IDK whose fault it was really.. but trying to work backwards I feel like the whole Suhaag Raat fiasco and billi in Asad's life would not even be the CASE if it werent for Raazia and Gaffur.

Its all the Siddiqui's fault.

Minus their PRECIOUS and DARLING daughter Humz and Daughter/Step-daughter: Zoe. 😆

Okay.. wow this post got UTTERLY long.

Happy Thinking. 😃


---Rosh Out 😎---
Edited by LoveRosh - 12 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

38

Views

4k

Users

18

Likes

95

Frequent Posters

rakhiankita thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
amazing post rosh hats off to u yaar for writing this awwsome post yaar👏 i completely agree with u yaar...and me to want asya should get married in ajmer😳
RosyRosh thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#3
^ Thanks Sweetz!!!

I know.. i just feel like they should get married for the rest of the story to make sense.. the biggest hurdle was the TRUST thing and I think that will be sorted after the suhaag raat thing... so I dont understand why they shouldnt... 🤔 Plus Ajmer is IDEAL.
CupofCoffeee thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#4
Rosh u r back🤗
unres!
Long Post😆
1) Even I dun think that anything happened between Asad n Tanveer...she wil just try to frame Asad so that he believes that something haooened n later she can make him her Baby Daddy😆
2) Zoya's outburst was very much justified n requred...any girl, in her place wud hav reacted the same way!
U say that even AsYa got intimate so many times but Asad never crossed his limits so Zoya shud trust him, but the point is, he was never lying shirtless with Zoya with all those lipstick marks all over him🤢
Zoya's outburst was due to wat she saw...she saw her fiance in bed with another woman on her wedding day!😲
Zoya knew wat Tanveer said, but she trust Asad's words more than Tanveer's...Asad had assured her that no one can come betweenthem now, not even KISMAT! Asad had blind trust in Tanveer n Zoya had BLIND FAITH in Asad!😃
I think CVs never let Asad confess n all his attempts failed so that wen such a situation comes like now, a big MU can be created! n it was Tanveer bcoz of whom each time Asad cud not confess!
3) Even I believe that AsYa shud marry in Ajmer...thats a Holy Place...their Fate brought them together at a Dargah where he saw her for the first time, so I think they shud marry at a Dargah, so that their Marriage gets those Divine Blessings...God wil always b with them and bring them together no matter wat ❤️
4) AyRa engagement, well, this time Razia with Ayan exactly wat she did wuth Rashid, History repeated!
I dun think AsYa n AyRa stories are gonna go Parallel!
AsYa got engaged twice, whereas AyRa engagement broke thrice! Thats the biggest hint that its not Parallel!
5) & 6) That was a blooper by CVs, nothing special on Humz n Zoya encouner n how Tanveer reached Razia, how she brought her out of Asylum, why Razia looked extremely normal after all that shock treatment was all a blooper n CVs let it go without much details!
Whose Fault...I think Razia n Tanveer for now!
n in the long Run its Gaffur Siddique!
Great post Rosh...loved the symbolism of white!
U r finally back, we missed u so much🤗
Keep bringing more of uch sensible posts ❤️
Edited by nupsie - 12 years ago
abditory. thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#5
Can I unreserve it late at night like after 3-4 hrs?😳 err I will do it now I guess wait
First of all I seriously dnt think any show unlike QH has bought such a heart-wrenching way to break a marriage. It has got so intense and on such a high point that its making us crazy!!
Asad - He is a man of his principles. He belives in himself and always has his own point. He knows how to handle a situation perfectly without any fuss. But this time tables has turned. He doesn't have anyone and he never had. He was always self-dependent. He needs to prove his mother, lover and himself that he is not Rashid.
They didn't consume. She just opened his shirt and slept beside him to make it look like that SLEPT but they did not. But she was successful in making people believe specially Zoya. Yes the position in which she saw her lover was too hard but urghh!! She shud have just given a damn thinking abt suhagraat thingy. She shud have given a chance to speak. No offence but I m with ASAD AHMED KHAN!! Dilshad man!! Ek to chance dena chahiya tha bte ko. 17 years he has handled you and took up the responsibility. U think he is like his father?!
I m pretty hopeful for Ajmer track. It better be our savior. I want a dard bhara segment and a passionate confession PHLEASEE no over lighting and blah blah.
I m sure the team has something in their kitty for viewers. And yeesss KSG taking center stage and has full limelight with emotional scenes, its gonna be worth it^^
Ignore mistakes lol 😆
Edited by salmeh. - 12 years ago
Cup-Of-Chai thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#6
Unres

First of all Rosh welcome back! We all missed you. 😳

About the post Amazing and a positive post. Seems like you wrote down all the things that you couldn't say since so many days. 😆 and i agree with all that you have written.

Some of my thoughts:

I don't think anything happened between Asad and Tanveer too. I mean first of all she is pregnant. Then he was unconscious, and he had his Dhoti or whatever it was he was wearing on. 😆 so i can say his "IZAT" is very much still with him.

And i think Zoya saying "I love you" to Asad first was so uncalled for. I think Asad should have confessed first. but oh well, at least somebody confessed now i just want a really FILMY confession from Asad. He needs to shout on top of his lungs "I LOVE YOU ZOYA". I am keeping my hopes up high that they will end up marrying in Ajmer And all will be well.

Humeira and Zoya's face off even i made a post about it that what was the point of not showing their faces before if she had to just see her at the wedding so easily? I still don't get it. I was hoping for a really big face-off between Zoya and Humz.

And Razia coming out of the asylum i guess anything is possible in Gul Khan Land. 🤣

Overall nobody is to be blamed. Nobody and i mean NOBODY was at fault except Tanveer. It was all her plan because of her all the lives are a mess now so i hope in Ajmer everyone gets justice. Thats all i have to say for now. 😳 again glad to have you back!
Edited by Cup-Of-Chai - 12 years ago
RosyRosh thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#7
^ Of course 🤣 You guys don't need permission to reserve. 🤣 will wait for your thoughts!
-Nightingale- thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#8
1. The topics about whether Billi and Asad had a Chitty Chitty Bang Bang.

Obviously Tanveer wants to label Asad as junior Billis Daddy so is the drama...I still didnt get the point in the drug thing...in which Asad had Zoyas visuals...

jab kuch karna hi nahi toh uske saath toh drug wala drama kyun...

and can they give the chemist's number from which she gets all these drugs..,..

2. Zoya's TRUST

valid n invalid gone for toss...I am loving it...Mr. Khan has never trusted the poor girl n it ws blind trust over Billo Rani .he and his whole family along wtih Zoya is suffering...so its his turn to pay for it..

3. Why I think AsYa SHOULD marry in Ajmer.

I just hope they dont drag it much...it would sound good if they stretch it more..

4. AyRa Got Engaged

Ayaan is another fool...like Dilshad said..all three are same...dumb n foolish...may be good at heart...He could have hinted Humaira but he never did it...but if he backs of now...I would hate him to core..

5. Humz and Zoe

didnt concentrate much on it..

6. Raazia's Mr. India's

they might have got disappearing drug u c..😆
RosyRosh thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: -Madhubala-

1. The topics about whether Billi and Asad had a Chitty Chitty Bang Bang.

Obviously Tanveer wants to label Asad as junior Billis Daddy so is the drama...I still didnt get the point in the drug thing...in which Asad had Zoyas visuals...

jab kuch karna hi nahi toh uske saath toh drug wala drama kyun...

and can they give the chemist's number from which she gets all these drugs..,..

^ Actually the drug thing was a SMART move on Billi's part because now ASAD himself has doubts if he did something or not. So when she comes and says this baby is yours, Asad may EASILY believe it. Me also wondering where they get all these DRUGS from 🤣 Peechle janam mein Raaz and Billi may have been evil chemists or something 🤣
2. Zoya's TRUST

valid n invalid gone for toss...I am loving it...Mr. Khan has never trusted the poor girl n it ws blind trust over Billo Rani .he and his whole family along wtih Zoya is suffering...so its his turn to pay for it..

Yeh I mean again im all for him getting a taste of his own medicines, but from Zoe's CHARACTER perspective.. knowing she is ALWAYS telling Asad to LISTEN to others.. one would think she would have heard him out ..

3. Why I think AsYa SHOULD marry in Ajmer.

I just hope they dont drag it much...it would sound good if they stretch it more..

hmm.. agree.

4. AyRa Got Engaged

Ayaan is another fool...like Dilshad said..all three are same...dumb n foolish...may be good at heart...He could have hinted Humaira but he never did it...but if he backs of now...I would hate him to core..

I dont think he will back out. Again I tink AyRa and AsYa are meant to marry at the same time.. because of past parallels.. i just dont get why the CREATIVES stretched their engagement.. it was pointless in my POV.

5. Humz and Zoe

didnt concentrate much on it..

6. Raazia's Mr. India's

they might have got disappearing drug u c..😆

🤣 LOL!

viya.mallik4eva thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#10
Oh look who's back! 😃 Great post Roshni. Glad you could finally type and not just like 😛

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".