Who will be Top 3?

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

BullsEye777

@BullsEye777

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

#41

Originally posted by: hamzanuha
Don't Care!

Sorry, no offense, but I've simply lost interest in MCI with biased judges, dramebaaz contestants, & selective editing!

LOL.. Yes there is more than simple 'how is the taste' to the Masterchef contest. I remember writing this before about Kandha ji in Season 1 - a 45+ year old. She lost as that day the task involved making huge quantity of food (for an airlines or something) and had so much running around plus the contestants had to push a huge trolley full of food and reach by a particular time. The poor lady just could not push the trolley and reach on time while another guy ran past her. Masterchef is not a strength test and so there was no reason that someone couldn't have helped this lady push a damn trolley. But that is Masterchef.

And even in this MCI, there is more than just taste. Think of what the prize is and what the winners will get. That will also reflect on who will get selected to top 3. In the end, the chefs do not want to lose face. MCI is like life. Do not consider it to be fair and idealistic.

Edited by BullsEye777 - 12 years ago

Quote

NoComments

@NoComments

Navigator

Posted: 12 years ago

#42

Originally posted by: BullsEye777

LOL.. Yes there is more than simple 'how is the taste' to the Masterchef contest. I remember writing this before about Kandha ji in Season 1 - a 45+ year old. She lost as that day the task involved making huge quantity of food (for an airlines or something) and had so much running around plus the contestants had to push a huge trolley full of food and reach by a particular time. The poor lady just could not push the trolley and reach on time while another guy ran past her. Masterchef is not a strength test and so there was no reason that someone couldn't have helped this lady push a damn trolley. But that is Masterchef.

And even in this MCI, there is more than just taste. Think of what the prize is and what the winners will get. That will also reflect on who will get selected to top 3. In the end, the chefs do not want to lose face. MCI is like life. Do not consider it to be fair and idealistic.

👏 to the bold! Very well put! 😊

I very well remember how Kandla was eliminated in season 1 in that running around task! Even in the Punjab episode here, the first task resembled more of a Roadies format than MCI.. So there is certainly more to taste!

Just to your point - I personally think that in Season 2, Shipra was selected as the winner since that single mother desparately looking for something big.. and yet good looking, attractive and a good cook helped her overall cause. Shazia on the other hand was a better cook, but being a middle class housewife was probably not inclined so much for the type of contract that the MCI winner would need to get into, and hence was adjudged the 2nd best! I even think that she probably would not have taken the Chef job that is typically offered to the runner up!

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

anusha.cochin

@anusha.cochin

Rocker

Posted: 12 years ago

#43

Originally posted by: f.s.m
I like Yasmeen and Ripu ... No one else ..
And I hope Navneet eliminate this week, he is too dramatical when it comes to the offscreen segments .. ( no offence to his fans ) ...

Fawaz bhai..😊

Ripu, Nisha, Doyel/yasmin

Edited by anusha.cochin - 12 years ago