Analysis of 27TH Nov elimination of SM

madhvi2386 thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#1
Hello all Nach Balian members, My analysis of maybe why Sweta and Manav might have been eliminated instead of Gauri and Gauri. I just saw article on Sweta-Manav being voted out. It also mentioned that Heten-Gauri (HG) were also in the danger zone. HG did not perform well in the last episode so it was expected. Also I think they looked quite tired and ill when they performed on Nov 20. I could imagine their schedule being hactic because Hiten and Gauri has to go shoot for Kuki saas bhi Kabhi Bahu thi and Nach Baliye practice. Hiten is also in Karam Apna Apna and he has to go shooting for that also. My point being that no wonder they look very exausted, since it is time consuming and very energy draning to go around. And so by wedsday when they perform live they always look exausted. It was one of their bad days and lets face it everybody has bad days. Manav and Sweta (MS) did marvolous job and they shouldn't have been in danger zone. Tanaaz and Bhaktiyar should have been in the danger zone instead of Manav and Sweta because they screwed up quite bad last week. I saw an article that they both scored well in solo performances, so three cheers for them for bouncing back. I hope they do something different in this round other then jummping jex. Frankly I am getting tired of their repeated western dance movements.

Anyway back to the topic. The article had also mentioned that both SM (Sweta and Manav) and GH (Gauri-Hiten) jodies scored total of 48 points, well that means that there was some form equality in the score. This was chance for audiences to vote out Gh, not because I hate them. Infact, I am one of this jodies big fan. They are one couple who have improved from their first performance alot compare to others. And I totally respect that they had put their best effort into all their performances to try to improve every week, except their last performance. I was affraid that maybe this last performance which was worst for them compare to even their first performance would bring them in danger zone. And I had thought if that happened then maybe other jodies will take advange to votimg them (GH) out because they are not that good at dancing compare to other jodies and their scoring board is not good compare to manav and Sweta. Manav and Sweta have improved alot from their first performance and always tried to do something different and I always enjoyed theirs and HuTi performances always. However big surprise, more like shock, the audiences and other jodies voted out MS. So that tells us that it must have been each jodies solo performances that made difference in the voting out of one jodi. The article said, while Gauri and Hiten both got 24 and 24 for their solo performances bringing them to total of 48 points. Manav had goten perfect 30, however Sweta very badly screwed up her performance and got 18 and so their total comes to 48 points.

This means Indian audiences are voting based on jodies current performances, and not comparing their past performances to see how each did in their previous performances. Lets be truthful here, do you remember what you ate one week or two weeks ago. I can't even rember what I ate two days ago unless it was very good food.😆. While, Manav no doubt, did very good in his solo round and sweta screwed up the solo round. Then, this might have costed them of being voted out. It had nothing to do with popularity of one couple to other. At least Gauri-Hiten were consistant in the scoring that means that there was at least balance in the way they danced. I think it was easy for the audiences and jodies to choose between HG and MS, based on their current performances. Either choosing to vote out jodi that has balanced scoring between them or choosing to vote out jodi that has one performing better and other not performing up to mark. I think the adiences chose the jodi that performed bad overall in solo performance only. I mean look at Sweta and Raja when they were voted out the first time. Arjun and Gurdeep were average performer as a whole that day compare to Sweta and Raja. While Sweta was very graceful and best performer in that round, Raja was horrible performer in that round and did not move his body at all. The unbalance in dancing of one partner not dancing weel had costed them to be voted out. Hey, the rule is that one jodi has to get voted out each week and frankly if I made the rules, then they all would have been winners of this contest in the end and I would have given them all trophy😉. It takes a lot of courage to get up there and dance when you are not dancer and accept critisism from judges. Now that the competetion is geting tough and as Kunal Kohil said in the last round, on Nov 20th, that even one bad performance can knock you out of the performance. I think that is what had happened to Manav and Sweta. Sweta not perfoming up to mark compare to manav for the first time after so many round of performing very well might have contributed for them being voted out. This is my opinion of why Sweta and Manav are voted out instead some might have expeted for GH to get voted out. Also a possible issue of the certain SIM card scandle with MS might have caused decrease in voting. But I think everybody most likely forgot about that by now. I do not think GH's popularity might have caused SM to get voted out. Because SM survived in the competetion this far based on votes of their fans. People blaming Gh for being more popular than SM and getting more votes just becaue they are good actors is I think just most ridiculous therory. If Gh were popular then MS or other jodies for that matter than they wouldn't have been in danger zone. I do not write much in any forums but when I do it sound like I am writing my 50 page biology saminar thesis paper. 😛😆😉.

P.S- Please do not start bashing any couples because I am getting tired of reading fan mails bashing one couple or other because one said bad thing of other fan jodi. If I hurted any fans feeling please forgive me, that was not my intension. I like all the jodies and I am fan of all NB2 jodies. I like something about each of the jodies. I wrote sincerely as I could.


So, what do you think of why Sweta and Manav got voted out? I would appreciate your opinions!! Thank you

Madhvi

Created

Last reply

Replies

19

Views

1.6k

Users

12

Frequent Posters

Hemaru thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#2
I just feel that Shweta-Manav deserved to be there.
peachesnplums thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 18 years ago
#3

i am going to give a detailed analysis only when i have seen the episode...quite a few times, there are discrepancies in what we think, and the marks that judges give...that may be a case here...could be other things too...or could be a simple case of bad performance...it's too early to say what happened...i don't want to conjecture useless things or start an irrational blame game...

meanwhile, you can search my previous posts on M-S, especially the ones I posted after their classical performance...you may find some reasons there...

😭 upset over M-S exit,
peaches...

Edited by peachesnplums - 18 years ago
parii833 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#4
GHT deserve to be there as smuc has SM ..based on the fact that both couples got same score...

but while GHT were both on 24....S scored a 30 while Shweta did horrible scoring a 18
peachesnplums thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 18 years ago
#5
why did you post it twice??? same thread is here as well....mods, please lock one of these, so all replies are together.
s_archana thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#6
Shwetha and manav do not deserve to be out...its gauri and hiten that shud have definitely been out this week..because THEY CANNOT DANCE! ITS AS SIMPLE AS THAT! 😡
parii833 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: s_archana

Shwetha and manav do not deserve to be out...its gauri and hiten that shud have definitely been out this week..because THEY CANNOT DANCE! ITS AS SIMPLE AS THAT! 😡

YA i also wonder how they they managed to score equal to the Stars Dancers on NB2 Shweta and Manav

tuku thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: HSSH

While, Manav no doubt, did very good in his solo round and sweta screwed up the solo round. Then, this might have costed them of being voted out. It had nothing to do with popularity of one couple to other. At least Gauri-Hiten were consistant in the scoring that means that there was at least balance in the way they danced. I think it was easy for the audiences and jodies to choose between HG and MS, based on their current performances. Either choosing to vote out jodi that has balanced scoring between them or choosing to vote out jodi that has one performing better and other not performing up to mark. I think the adiences chose the jodi that performed bad overall in solo performance only.


This does not make any sense. The audience voted after the Nov 20 show to decide who would be voted out. The audience has not even seen the solo performances, so how can you say that they voted for the better couple overall. How can the audience base their vote on a performance that they have not seen yet? Nov 20 Shweta and Manav did a much better job than Hiten and Gauri. The judges said it was Hiten and Gauri's worst performance in the show. So obviously it can be seen that it is still a popularity contest and the scoring does not matter. That is why Hiten and Gauri are still in the competition and Shweta and Manav have been voted out.

Hello excuse me..on NOV 20th MS were better than all other jodies..but how com only ur cribbing on GHT votes...can u tel me y did audience voted for others more than MS...Just dont get a reason of y ppl have voted for GHT..ok..if u wanna know y MS were out u need to go nd break NB creative heads brain for being a reason for there ousted not GH fans or someone else...and 1 more thng..if GHT had max votes then i dont think they wud have landed in bottom 2 for sure...so just dnt cry on GHT instead save ur other jodi b4 eliminating..agn dnt com nd make a fuss here.

tuku thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: ~RexKiRani~

iam upset thats ittttttttttttttttt

i understand ur pain..whn ur favs go it hurts..but just imagine ppl calling names and speaking bad..making 100 post agnst fans and ppl of india..it hurts more...i dont wanna comment..unfortunately it was nt there day....i feel bad abt this whole voting system..because in NB it doesnt matter as all these r established artist...but think abt other shows like FG/II/SRGMPA...i really feel very bad when deserving candidates loose for public.

NB is just dnt abt dancing..if it was then firstly it wud nt have been celebrity couple dancing where some r extremely gud and som nt so gud..populartiy also counts a lot...well thts all i cud say..

Autumnn thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 18 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: hujulover137

Well, I think the bottomline here is that the better and more deserving couple got voted out. Everyone felt the same frustration when NG got voted out.

The way I understand the NB format is that they place the couple in the bottom 2 based on their present performances (and not last week's) and combine it with the last week votes. Both HG and MS having scored low were at the bottom two. The sad part is that the couple who were more talented got eliminated. Since the channel never gives us the actual no. of votes, it is hard to know if they got eliminated through a narrow margin. The only thing it tells us (and that is true for most reality shows) that public votes are based only on emotion and has got nothing to do with talent.

So GHT fans, others are not against you per se....they are feeling bad that through this unfair voting somehow we as Indians are endorsing that talent and hard work doesn't pay off.

Well Said.. Really well said.. 😊

Your writing style is very nice.. 👍🏼

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".