Some parallels between Pia and Barnali

majumdar thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#1

JW and Walias relationship with Barnali came out in the open finally and in the worst possible way- bhari bazaar mein izzat utar gayi. And for that reason many of us (Sangs and I for instance) had always been harping on the fact that JW should come clean on Barnali to Bani or at least tell her that she has a relationship with Walias but it is so shameful that he would rather not talk about it. Of course not that Bani wouldn't have tried to find out.

But I am equally shocked and disgusted with the way Bani reacted, there was no excuse for such behaviour. Sure, she had a right to be aggrieved that JW had lied to her but she could have discussed that later in private with JW rather than fire him in public.

I am also having jitters about the nature of her conversation with Barnali, she seems to be getting sympathetic towards Barnali and her alleged ill-treatment. Have a feeling that she might ask JW why they had been so unfair to Barnali or at least ask for an explanation. Or maybe even try to redress her grievances knowing her Amma nature. My take. Regardless of whether Barnali's grievances are genuine or not, she should not interfere. What the Walias did with Barnali is none of her concern as long as it does not affect her or her family. After JW has not taken up what the Dixits did to HIM with Bani, why should Bani bother about the Walia khandaan's karnamas and that too with a third person.

As was widely suspected, JW wasn't thrilled when he found out that he is becoming a Papa. Anyone remember how JW had reacted to becoming a Papa the last time round? What a contrast that was to the news of the arrival of his (???) and Pia's baby.

Interesting parallels between Pia and Barnali. Seedhi saadhi gharwalis (Bani/Krishna) pitted against vampish baharwalis (Pia/Barnali). Barnali, if I remember the epi right claimed, to be Walia Sahib's first pasand as was Pia. She bore Walia Sr. 's illegitimate child as Pia is bearing JW's(???). Barnali addressed her lover as Walia Sahib (not first name) and Pia calls her lover Mr. Vollaya, not Jai. And that makes me think if Pia's puppy is Pushky's and not JW's what if Nachiket is not Walia Sr.'s but someone else's. And did Walia Sr. find that out and Barnali try to cover that up and get him murdered and chunwaoed in the purani dyodhi. But that is of course pure kite flying based on data we have now.

Now I have a feeling that when Bani will find out about the ONS and Pia being preggie with JW's child, she would walk out on her marriage to prevent Pia and her child from becoming another aggrieved Barnali-Nachiket duo.

Rgds,

Priyanka

Created

Last reply

Replies

13

Views

1k

Users

8

Frequent Posters

ovaltine thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#2

Good post pri.

(Now I have a feeling that when Bani will find out about the ONS and Pia being preggie with JW's child, she would walk out on her marriage to prevent Pia and her child from becoming another aggrieved Barnali-Nachiket duo)

Yep, I feel this too will happen. Even I am weary of Bani's snooppy nature and her sense of righteousness, I would like her to leave the matter to rest. I think another attempt will be made on jai walia's life and this time she will suspect bernali, dig deeper and open another can of worms.
I feel pia is worse than Bernali because pia is after her sister's husband, mr walia loves bani and vice versa and mr walia doesnt love pia. He is not willing to leave his wife. In bernali's case, senior walia was in love with her and was having a fullfledged affair. He left his wife for his mistress. It makes Pia a more desperate and shameless person than bernali.
555W59 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: majumdar

JW and Walias relationship with Barnali came out in the open finally and in the worst possible way- bhari bazaar mein izzat utar gayi. And for that reason many of us (Sangs and I for instance) had always been harping on the fact that JW should come clean on Barnali to Bani or at least tell her that she has a relationship with Walias but it is so shameful that he would rather not talk about it. Of course not that Bani wouldn't have tried to find out.

But I am equally shocked and disgusted with the way Bani reacted, there was no excuse for such behaviour. Sure, she had a right to be aggrieved that JW had lied to her but she could have discussed that later in private with JW rather than fire him in public.

I am also having jitters about the nature of her conversation with Barnali, she seems to be getting sympathetic towards Barnali and her alleged ill-treatment. Have a feeling that she might ask JW why they had been so unfair to Barnali or at least ask for an explanation. Or maybe even try to redress her grievances knowing her Amma nature. My take. Regardless of whether Barnali's grievances are genuine or not, she should not interfere. What the Walias did with Barnali is none of her concern as long as it does not affect her or her family. After JW has not taken up what the Dixits did to HIM with Bani, why should Bani bother about the Walia khandaan's karnamas and that too with a third person.

As was widely suspected, JW wasn't thrilled when he found out that he is becoming a Papa. Anyone remember how JW had reacted to becoming a Papa the last time round? What a contrast that was to the news of the arrival of his (???) and Pia's baby.

Interesting parallels between Pia and Barnali. Seedhi saadhi gharwalis (Bani/Krishna) pitted against vampish baharwalis (Pia/Barnali). Barnali, if I remember the epi right claimed, to be Walia Sahib's first pasand as was Pia. She bore Walia Sr. 's illegitimate child as Pia is bearing JW's(???). Barnali addressed her lover as Walia Sahib (not first name) and Pia calls her lover Mr. Vollaya, not Jai. And that makes me think if Pia's puppy is Pushky's and not JW's what if Nachiket is not Walia Sr.'s but someone else's. And did Walia Sr. find that out and Barnali try to cover that up and get him murdered and chunwaoed in the purani dyodhi. But that is of course pure kite flying based on data we have now.

Now I have a feeling that when Bani will find out about the ONS and Pia being preggie with JW's child, she would walk out on her marriage to prevent Pia and her child from becoming another aggrieved Barnali-Nachiket duo.

Rgds,

Priyanka

Priyanka, I just wrote in another post that I think Bani is going to take up the cause of Barnali. Also, I think barnali is setting up to use bani in her war against Jai. Pia and Jigz will use this support to instigate Jai against Bani. I think Bani will leave WM due to circumstances created by Pia, Jigz and Barnali, each have their own motivation. The ONS might just became an afterthought.

Also, how can bani be mad at jai for keeping somthing from her or lying. has she not been doing the same thing to him for months. Also I have yet to hear an explanation from her. She expects him to take wahtever she dishes out at face value while he has to keep her appraised of every little/big detail of his life. Yaar every day I am loosing a little more respect for bani. What happened to her fav bhasan of family honor. She just made a complete spectale of it. The creatives are so setting her up for a fall.

Also what was with pshyco pia today. Usually she gives me the creeps today she gave me the chills. She has lost all strains of humanity today in her quest to get her sis/mom's husband. They way she was emotionally blackmailing him today was freaky.

Poor Jai

Poor Pushkar

Poor Bani

cheers,

meghna

aashyagh thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#4
I just watched the Video and seeing Pia was like 🤢 and Bani couldnt hv been more worse 😡 !!! But I dont understand, why does Bani take Jai for granted? Is it because she hasn't got a proper slap from him or his too much of love and faith is taking her to this heights that she is forgetting her so called sanskar and values of relationships! Its really sad to see that Ekta is messing up with her own creations!!
majumdar thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#5
Ash,

(Is it because she hasn't got a proper slap from him)

Actually all the sisters should have got a proper spanking (rather than pravachans) from KD when kids.

But it is quite interesting that while JW has thrashed his sister, nephews and mistress quite liberally, he has never actually hit his wife.

Rgds,

Pri

aashyagh thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#6
But it is quite interesting that while JW has thrashed his sister, nephews and mistress quite liberally, he has never actually hit his wife.

Rgds,

Pri

***I think she is the most deserving candidate!!
lonely14 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#7

Pri,

What have you done? Blamed the superwoman? Nahi pri, how could you? you broke her heart, bechari now will go n cry.

She had to accuse him infront of the entire world, for the sole reason that it would just be more dramatic, you can't blame her for that. Just because she likes snooping, doesn't mean she is at fault, nope never.

Just because she lacks some brain cells, you can't hold anything against her.

You have to give her some credit, for yelling at her hubby like that in front of everyone, after all coming from a wife who "loves" her husband, "respects" him, "cares" about him and his family name, must've been really hard.

Pri take it easy on the poor little superwoman.

As for Pia and Barnali, i don't want to comment, because well i like both of them😆

Shina

who am i??? thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#8

It was indeed a nice post...but what Pia told Jai yesterday is making me crazy
Mr.Walia main janthi hoon aap is bachae ko accept nahi karengae..is liye mare paas pushkar ke saath janae ke alava koi aur rastae nahi tha an all the while she had her evil grin on her face"

And to add to my munna's turmoil i am sure the righteous bani will support Barnali and nachiket once she comes to know abt that will and Jigs dirty game(which i am more than 100% sure Jai has no clue!!!) and this will only lead and add to her VANAVAS.

ARCHIE 😊
majumdar thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#9
"Mr.Walia main janthi hoon aap is bachae ko accept nahi karengae..is liye mare paas pushkar ke saath janae ke alava koi aur rastae nahi tha "

JW will certainly want Pia to take that raasta, out of WM.

Rgds,

Pri
sangitadas thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 18 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: m3ghna

Priyanka, I just wrote in another post that I think Bani is going to take up the cause of Barnali. Also, I think barnali is setting up to use bani in her war against Jai. Pia and Jigz will use this support to instigate Jai against Bani. I think Bani will leave WM due to circumstances created by Pia, Jigz and Barnali, each have their own motivation. The ONS might just became an afterthought.

Also, how can bani be mad at jai for keeping somthing from her or lying. has she not been doing the same thing to him for months. Also I have yet to hear an explanation from her. She expects him to take wahtever she dishes out at face value while he has to keep her appraised of every little/big detail of his life. Yaar every day I am loosing a little more respect for bani. What happened to her fav bhasan of family honor. She just made a complete spectale of it. The creatives are so setting her up for a fall.

Also what was with pshyco pia today. Usually she gives me the creeps today she gave me the chills. She has lost all strains of humanity today in her quest to get her sis/mom's husband. They way she was emotionally blackmailing him today was freaky.

Poor Jai

Poor Pushkar

Poor Bani

cheers,

meghna



Absolutely Meghna, I was too shocked at Pia's behaviour and attitude today and the way she tries to blackmail Jai, irresepctive of the situation.

Thanks Pri for this post. Was thinking of posting something on tehs elines, but then you saved me. But I will stick to it that the Barnali issue should have been disclosed earlier to Bani.

I am not sure as to the reason why Bani will leave the Walia House after the ONS comes out, cos I dont have faith on the Destructives, not anymore.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".