Who is at fault? -Discuss!!

Friends,

The script of Mamta is getting too hard to digest nowadays. Today's episode was really very pathetic... Now what do you all think? Who is to be blamed? Is it Akshay's fault? Is it Mamta's or is it Sid's? Or is it the pathetic storyline and scrip that is driving us crazy??😕 What is it???

Why are such situations arising that lead Akshay to get upset with Mamta and Sid? Do you feel he is suspecting Mamta again? Do you feel he suspects both sid and Mamta? Why was he so mad at them? Are Mamta and Sid right with whatever they are doing? Are they not to be blamed? And what about the whole family, who just keep watching when all things go wrong? Is it their fault?

Is Akshay wrong when he told Mamta and sid that he wil never suspect Mamta, as he has full trust in his wife. But he cannot stop others from talking, he has lost all patience to fight against all odds all the time. Was Akshay wrong when he said that they both should not give rise to situations where people speak ill of them? Was he wrong? What do you all feel?

Is Sid wrong in being close to Mamta, taking care of Mamta at this point of time?

Can we discuss?

hey folks
this is the discussion of the week!!!!
now about A, m and S...
well, M is 30- 40 % at fault... when she isnt suppose to be around sid she doesnt need to go start sitting next to sid all the time.
A - proabbly 20% as he shouldnt have left his wife alone when she was sick
and now SID - oh gosh, he is 100% wrong!!!!!
i mean come on, what a hypocrite... he tells akshay not to listen to karan and bua and then goes to belives karan when he said that he did spk to aks... how stupid?? and if he has his memory back then why still stay? call up your mom and get away from here...
im a major fan of sid, i love him the most in the show, but still he's being really grey right now..

its the pathetic storyline and scrip that is driving us.....so many problems hav rised... there is no fault of Mamta or SId neither Akshay.... its just circumfarance....
Akshay is nt suspectin SM.. hes confused... he dunno which path 2 choose n wat 2 do..... SId i sjust helpin Mamta n taking care of her........

Let me begin like this--there is no one else to blame but the writers--they don't know how to make real life situations.

But still--let me write my views--
already written in another thread--can't resist--posting it again here--sorry

What is sid doing in Akshay's bedroom with Mamta 😕 ?Why he is spending time with Mamta? 😕
Everytime he is seen with Mamta,why?First,he danced with Mamta like a lover(he invited her to dance like a friend) ,he crossed the limits.He wanted to hv private moments with Mamta,he even wanted Mamta to cut the b'day cake before everyone come,he wished to make it a
private affair.And Mamta is entertaining Sid(why to blame only sid),but may be she is too innocent to say someone 'no' 😕 😡
Heyyy Sid,hv u lost ur brains ?Doesn't he know the do's & don'ts?Doesn't he know how to behave with a married woman?What u doing is wrong ,unbearable.

Akshay is correct--why creating situations & giving bua & company chances to talk against them.
See prblms,tensions everyday in the house.Akshay has to answer all those questions--he is sick of it--he is only human--he is frustrated--he is tired of facing these unnecessary prblms--Can't he get angry?

Then,Ohhhh big big sweet dialogues from Sid like a 'mahaan' in yesterday's episode--
he was advicing Akshay-He says,it's a shame to doubt Mamta,heyy ,Akshay is not doubting Mamta,
he is doubting u,Sid--and yes,Sid has feelings for Mamta--nobody can deny it--and it is wrong--we can't blame if Akshay doubts Sid
Sid says ,he is a true friend of Mamta--Can't see her suffer --never can hurt Mamta--
Waah Waah ,and what he is doing?It's Sid who is hurting Mamta indirectly,not Akshay.Sid is bringing tears in Mamta's eyes
If u r a true friend of Mamta and loves her truely,then tell the truth that u hv got ur memory back
& leave the house--pls Sid --think man

And one more thing--Doctor asked Sid to take care of Mamta--Why, there is no one else in the house who can take care of her(Damaayanti can't ,Shaina can't)--It's only Sid who can take care of her--and he is there in the bedroom 24 hrs--can't help laughing 😆 😆 --ridiculous

I don't know why I'am wasting my time & energy ,discussing on these craps
But I can't bear this injustice done to Akshay's character 😭 😭 --Don't know why
Akshay is always been made the scapegoat 😭 😭

But I will always be there with u Akshay 👏 ,no matter what --😊

I am not writing these comments just bcos I am an Akshay and Mamta fan... I am seeing the reality and the truth behind the story and hence writing this... So please do not take anything to heart!!!

Firstly, Akshay never suspected Mamta even when he had that heated argument with Mamta and Sid. His only cause for anger was, why do Mamta and Sid always end up together, why do they show to all that they are really close? Why on earth do they give rise to situations that make others at home to suspect them? Now, being the husband of mamta, i feel Akshay has all the right to ask Mamta this simple question. Afterall, it he who has to defend and support Mamta whenever such problems arise. Akshay was not wrong, when he said that he is fed up of fighting for his wife before others... He has lost his patience now... I ask, Did not Akshay side and support Mamta and even Sid always in the past when they both were being talked ill of???? How many times can a husband keep repeating the same? Does he not have right to even tell his wife and close friend not to give room for such talks? Was he wrong? He is afterall human... So there is a limit till which he can stay calm. He has now reached a stage wheer he is getting really frustrated when he sees people talking against his wife... Why cant Mamta understand this basic thing???? I fail to understand... sorry!!!

There is a big difference between Akshay suspecting Mamta and asking Mamta to stay away from sid just bcos he does not want more problems to creep up... Why are Mamta and Sid taking it in the wrong manner?? I again fail to understand...

Now, when Akshay is storming out of the house, Sid stops him.. He starts to tell Akshay about how Mamta sees him as Ram, but Akshay never sees Mamta as Sita... Now why on earth is Sid repeating whatever Tanisha told him???? This is so strange... Does it mean that he is getting carried away with whatever Tanisha told him? Does he ever realise what mistake he is making by believing Tanisha? Again i fail to understand this...

Now, when Mamta gets ill, why does the whole family just sit and keep watching Sid help out Mamta? Why do they need a Bua and Tanisha to teach them facts? Dont they realise that Sid forever being in Mamta's room can again cause problems? Why are they so dumb? I really do not feel anything is wrong in whatever Bua said... Why does Sid remain always in Mamta's room? After giving all those bashans to Akshay for having trust in his wife, how come Sid believes Karan and would ever imagine that Akshay will say these words for Mamta - "Mamta jeeye yaa mare muje koi farak nahi padta". (This the exact dialogue that Karan told Sid, said that Akshay had told him this over the phone... ) Now how can Sid believe this???

Come on now, give me a break.. The story writers seriously need a lot of thiking to do....

i think each of the characters are at fault, but akshay deserves the blame the least.😊

hey, i mean he sure is getting a lot of flak for being a good husband.😡😡 where is the logic there? he just doesn't anyone to speak ill of his wife, which is why he is asking sid & mamta to keep a distance.

i think it's obvious how much he loves his wife from all these actions.😊 it is unfair to push the blame on akshay.😊

mamta to me is at fault the most. she just can't bring herself to be firm with sid. if she was clear about her feelings abt him, sid wouldn't be misunderstanding her or her actions.😕 she sits with him, gets too friendly with him, she lets him hold her hand, dance with her & all that.😕 now when akshay doesn't want her to get a bad name, she finds his thinking wrong?😡😡 where the heck is the logic here?😡😡

mamta is the main cause of problems here.😕 does she love akshay or not?❓ or does she have a place for sid in her heart as well?❓ only she can answer that question.😕

lastly, sid. well, what can i say when i see my fav character in 'mamta' turn into a controversy.😭😭he asks akshay not to suspect mamta when he himself crosses the limit of friendship.😕

haiz... i know that he loves mamta immensely, but showing that love so openly, somemore in front of tanisha & bua who look for every single opportunity to tarnish mamta's name.😔 that is not very practical.😕 the problem with sid is that he thinks with his heart, not his mind.😊 so he gets swayed by a snake like tanisha.😡😡😡

seems tt the future is really bleak fellow mamta fans. 😭😭😭

the 1 in fault is the creatives of MAMTA

i think mamta is at fault like 2%...akshay is at fault like 20% and sid is like 100%

In My opinion all of them are at fault.Its true that Sid does have feelings for Mamta,But..doesnt any1 also feels that Mamta somewhat has feelings for Sid?
Sid finally regains his Memory,what does he see in AM 's relationship? Akshay and Mamta are always in some argument or its either Akshay is Losing trust in Mamta,Yes I admit that Sid has no right to even try to get involve in a Married Woman's life,But...Sid also Loves Mamta and for him this is a Perfect chance for him to reflect on that love.So Sid can not get 100% fault at this.Akshay is also responsible,If he loved and Trusted Mamta soo much,why didnt he even take the time to listen to what she was trying to tell him? Yes he got a temper BUT...he cant jus assume that Sid and Mamta are doing something behind his back.If he really wanted to know and the face the truth,he couls of jus let som1 explain.Then again,he reaches Home after his crying scene and sees Sid by Mamta,Obviously he gets angry,But if he didnt wanted to see another man by his Wife's side,then....Stay by her.
Mamta for me,she's a little tooo innocent.She does things with Sid and then...makes it look as if Sid is entirely to Blame.
I think that the Writers are doing a Wonderful job.they are keeping the Fans anxious and giving them a headache sometimes 😊 But its the Worth it.

all of them are at FAULT--

not only SID, AKSHAy and MAMTA but also ANaNd, DAMYANTI and SHAINA for keeping their mouth shut and listening to DIDi's nonsense talk of crap!

i mean until now, SID hasnt gave anyone a SIGNAL that he do wants to break MAMTA and AKSHAY's love..

he just admitted that he still cares for MAMTA--

but AKSHAY rather than believing MAMTA and SID-- he just listens and DONT even utter any thing when DIDI speaks up--

he SUSPECTS MAMta without even listening to her--

is that what AKSHAY should do--

and regarding ANAND and DAMYANTI-- well they should do something to make AKSHAY understand rather than just stand there like PILLARS and stare at the things happening in their house--

MAMTA have given so MANY tests in tehir life just to prove her SINCERITY and LOVE--

the SRIVASTAVA family should not COMMIT the same mistake of disbelief they have done then bcoz this will really disappoint lots of people especially the VIEWERS!