Did Neeluji and Arvind deserve a 30?

leonardoaugust8 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#1

Firstly ..want to make it clear that I have nothing against these two contestants .. I have always felt Bhabho-Arvind team is like the Sachin-Supriya team of Season 1 ..pure energy and passion. Only person I felt who was undeserving was Rahul Mahajan ..again nothing against him as a person ..but seriously felt he was only in the show to crack bad jokes ..his expressions and antics showed no trajectory despite being pushed through several episodes ..

Coming to today's episode ..today I felt Arvind actually forgot his steps ..After this , I could feel that the energy of Neeluji and Arvind began to wane and they performed mechanically with zero enthusiasm and/or interest. The point that Arvind forgot his steps was recognized by Terrence ..but Arvind gave an explanation that this was due to an injury suffered 10-12 yrs back ..all through this explanation, i noticed Bhabho standing still with a dead-pan/zero expression on her face neither confirming nor denying in any way this explanation ..Obviously she cant deny it ..but still in my mind doubt persists ..as Arvind has danced with double energy and enthusiasm previously and has showed no signs of injury till this episode ..So one cant confirm if he is really injured or if he forgot his steps . I am not suggesting that he is not telling the truth ..still I think he actually forgot his steps . It can also be a combination of both.

I expected the judges to give them an 8 or maybe even a 7..but they gave him a 10 and on the flip side amar-charlie were given harsh comments ..Terrence actually said that today charlie was just a notch below "hawa tight" performance ..so that would mean at least a 10 or a 9 ..Instead they got 7,8 and 9 i think.
Why are the judges being blatantly partial ? ..Such bad scoring could actually spell doom for charmar ..This season has so far been the most inept scoring season on behalf of the judges ..sad but I don't see how this will improve ..Fingers crossed
Edited by leonardoaugust8 - 12 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

11

Views

1.2k

Users

11

Likes

19

Frequent Posters

abhilasha_dream thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
no.. they desrved somewhere around 24 or 25, not 30.
--Saina-- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#3
They should have got 27 or less but not more than that
Edit: It was a typo 🥱 I meant 21 not 27.. They should have got 21 in my opinion
Edited by --Saina-- - 12 years ago
taani_20 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#4
No, they didn't deserve a 30. They were over-marked today. This is not a surprise because it's been happening so often this season, with other jodis as well.

However, I don't think it's right to assume Arvind ji was lying or making excuses. He stated his case, which was fair enough. It's the fault of the judges, because at the end it doesn't even matter if he had an injury or not. They are supposed to be marked on the performance as it was given, with injury or without. Even if he had an injury, no matter what the reason was, the marks should have been based only on the performance, because it's a competition, so even if a contestant is injured or sick its their bad luck, but to still give them high marks is unfair to the other contestants who have given a better performance. But the unfairness is not Neelu-Arvind ji's fault.
Nikki_s thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: leonardoaugust8

Firstly ..want to make it clear that I have nothing against these two contestants .. I have always felt Bhabho-Arvind team is like the Sachin-Supriya team of Season 1 ..pure energy. Only person I felt who was undeserving was Rahul Mahajan ..again nothing against him as aperson ..but seriously felt he was only in the show to crack bad jokes ..his expressions and antics showed no trajectory despite being pushed through several episodes ..


Coming to todays episode ..today I felt Arvind actually forgot his steps ..a point that was recognised by Terrence ..but he gave an explanation that this was due to an injury suffered 10-12 yrs back ..all through this explanation, i noticed Bhabho standing still with a dead-pan/zero expression on her face neither confirming nor denying in any way this explanation ..Obviously she cant deny it ..but still in my mind doubt persists ..as Arvind has danced with double energy and enthusiasm previously and has showed no signs of injury till this episode ..So one cant confirm if he is really inujured or if he forgot his steps ..I think he actually forgot his steps ..


I expected the judges to give them an 8 ..but they gave him a 10 and on the flip side amar-charlie were given harsh comments ..Terrenceactually said that today charlie was just a notch below "hawa tight" performance ..so that would mean atleast a 10 ..Instead they got 7,8 and 9 i think.


Why are the judges being blatantly partial ..Such bad scoring could actually spell doom for charmar ..This season has so far been the most inept scoring season on behalf of the judges ..sad but I dont see how this will improve ..Fingers crossed



totally agree with you..
Espacially red lines . He forget step for sure bcaz if he injured than how can he do reharsals of those act? And reharsal me pta nai chalta ki vo injured he vo step nai ker sakta..

And about charmar
dis totally judges cheat to charmar.
Arvind forgot step they give 30 and charlie forgot step they gave 25 only...

And sajid is very rude with charmar.give only 7 marks..
He insult badly of charmar even amar is crying today...
Dhoxi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#6
I think its not fair like the way they got that much mark wasnt fair.
Piggies thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#7
I seriously thought that the would get a 27 at most. But no, BAM they get a 30. And then Jay-Mahhi also got a 30 and they had such a power-packed performance which was much better than them! But they got the same scores, making their performances equivalent when it wasn't!

And the fact that they are only 3 points away from Ravi-Sargun's performance which is one of the best performances I've seen today makes me even more disappointed!👎🏼
Arvind forgot his steps and he should claim up to that.😳

Because, in his other performances, there was no hint of an injury and it just came up?!
That's a definite lie.
I feel there are a jodi that gets more marks than they deserve. They got a 33 yesterday when they didn't deserve that at all! I felt it was mediocre! Maybe about 28-29, but a 33?NO.

Love,
Piggies🐷
chumchee25 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#8
Totally agree with you!
An injured person usually would place his hands on where the pain is whereas Arvind placed his hands on his head so to me at that point in time indicated that he had forgotten the steps. His justification doesnt go with his actions.
hide thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#9
sajid 🤡 is in love with arvind and always shows partiality and bring this guy's buffoon expressions for the viewers.. they do not deserve 30
leonardoaugust8 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: lats22

sajid 🤡 is in love with arvind and always shows partiality and bring this guy's buffoon expressions for the viewers.. they do not deserve 30



Exactly ..my point . Of course Arvind does good govinda mimic ..but somehow I feel the expressions dont vary from performance to performance ..Hes a good dancer yes ..but yesterday was grossly unfair.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".