yash not G3 son will be the worst story for PV - Page 3

I think you may be missing the point of the whole story if you say that Yash has no rights on the Scindia property if he is proven to be illegitimate. The story is about how relationships based on love are far stronger than those based on blood or biology. Gayatri did not compare Yash and Aarti's relationships with their step-kinds to Yashoda and Krishna for nothing, right? Even though Krishna was technically Devaki's son, he always saw Yashoda as his mother. The same will be true here. Even if Yash is not Gayatri's biological son, he is her son through love and belonging and the moral will be to show that that supersedes any blood relation or lack thereof.

So I think it could be interesting if he turns out not to be Gayatri's son. 😊

I have a different view. If the CVs are going the Mahabharat route, it does not mean that they have to follow it verbatim. It is not about who is Karan and who is Arjun. What they are trying to portray here is a battle between right and wrong.

From the first episode of this show there has been a strong emphasis on biological child Vs non -biological child. In fact one of SP's biggest grouse during this kidnapping track was how is it that Yash can go against SP who is his blood and stand in support of Aarti and more importantly Ansh who is not Yash's biologically. There has always been this divide among Scindiyas about 'paraya' (outsider) and 'apna' (one who belongs to the family). If Yash turns out to be the lady's son then this issue is going to be brought to the fore front.

There are so many amazing, socially relevant questions that are asked in this track:

1) Just because a child is born out of wedlock, should the child suffer social stigma like Karan in Maha Bharath did and Akash in PV did?

2) If Yash is indeed the illegit son, will they stop loving him? Aren't these bonds formed between hearts? Yash has always claimed that such a bond was the basis of his and Ansh's relationship. Now the Scindiyas will experience it first hand, isn't it?

3) Is it always true that just because someone is your blood, you will love that person more? If Akash is Gayu's blood and Yash is not, can she start loving Akash more than Yash who she has raised since he was a baby?

4) There is also questions raised about 'parvarish' ie upbringing. SP insulted the lady on the fact that "gandha khoon" that is dirty blood will always be dirty blood. In such a case if Yash is the illegit son, according to SP he is the one with the dirty blood but look how he turned out to be. So isn't there some value to upbringing. Does blood always define your identity?

As far as SP's mistake is concerned, yes he should face the consequences but if Yash wants to initially support SP then I think that is wonderful for the simple reason that it shows what a bigger human being he is compared to the Scindiyas who in one stroke was ready to break all ties with Yash and Aarti.

Just look at the wealth of social issues raised in this track. PV has always been a show that makes the audience think and I think that is exactly what it is doing right now with this track.

So what if Yash is the illegit son? Will that make him any less lovable for us viewers. He is still the same person with the same values? Why should the fact that his parentage is different make us viewers frown upon the concept. If for whatever reason the audience cannot accept Yash as the illegitimate child then shame on the viewers.

You are so Right!!!!!

Originally posted by: Sangeeta66

You are so Right!!!!!

What would make that Yash? The basterd son who got his Punar Vivah in the ritch family. What would that do to Gayatri? She is a changed person. I like her now more than in the begining. She is sensitive and loving towards Yash and Aarti and their kids. I don't think it would be smart. But lets see how far they will take this.

It is time for Romance and Happiness. It becomes such a sour show with only Drama.

I think they should find a good Balance in good and bad times, Not only bad and sad lines. It just is to long.

I will be away for three weeks. After I come back I am so curious how far the show will be and if the Romance and happiness has returned and the Shindhia family will have some sweet moments again.

Is there something wrong with being a "bas***d" child? How is that his fault? Why is Yash getting the blame here... he himself wouldn't know the truth behind his birth. Yes, Gayatri might be heartbroken, but this is the reality of what's going on in the world right now. There are so many extramarital affairs where an illegitimate child is born. It's honestly very common nowadays, that it's perfectly natural for the CVs to take this route.

Originally posted by: angake

I have a different view. If the CVs are going the Mahabharat route, it does not mean that they have to follow it verbatim. It is not about who is Karan and who is Arjun. What they are trying to portray here is a battle between right and wrong.

From the first episode of this show there has been a strong emphasis on biological child Vs non -biological child. In fact one of SP's biggest grouse during this kidnapping track was how is it that Yash can go against SP who is his blood and stand in support of Aarti and more importantly Ansh who is not Yash's biologically. There has always been this divide among Scindiyas about 'paraya' (outsider) and 'apna' (one who belongs to the family). If Yash turns out to be the lady's son then this issue is going to be brought to the fore front.

There are so many amazing, socially relevant questions that are asked in this track:

1) Just because a child is born out of wedlock, should the child suffer social stigma like Karan in Maha Bharath did and Akash in PV did?

2) If Yash is indeed the illegit son, will they stop loving him? Aren't these bonds formed between hearts? Yash has always claimed that such a bond was the basis of his and Ansh's relationship. Now the Scindiyas will experience it first hand, isn't it?

3) Is it always true that just because someone is your blood, you will love that person more? If Akash is Gayu's blood and Yash is not, can she start loving Akash more than Yash who she has raised since he was a baby?

4) There is also questions raised about 'parvarish' ie upbringing. SP insulted the lady on the fact that "gandha khoon" that is dirty blood will always be dirty blood. In such a case if Yash is the illegit son, according to SP he is the one with the dirty blood but look how he turned out to be. So isn't there some value to upbringing. Does blood always define your identity?

As far as SP's mistake is concerned, yes he should face the consequences but if Yash wants to initially support SP then I think that is wonderful for the simple reason that it shows what a bigger human being he is compared to the Scindiyas who in one stroke was ready to break all ties with Yash and Aarti.

Just look at the wealth of social issues raised in this track. PV has always been a show that makes the audience think and I think that is exactly what it is doing right now with this track.

So what if Yash is the illegit son? Will that make him any less lovable for us viewers. He is still the same person with the same values? Why should the fact that his parentage is different make us viewers frown upon the concept. If for whatever reason the audience cannot accept Yash as the illegitimate child then shame on the viewers.

Saffi, Jyoti, Samana, Angake ( I think your name is Kirthi, right?)

I don't want that to happen as well but I think that it's going to be shown that Akash is his son and I hope that they don't mess with Yash at all. It will be disapointing and I feel that they (cvs) don't need have Yash as the other womens son. I feel that the cv's can go a different route. Also another twist can be that Akash is really not the son of SP and the DNA test comes out saying he is only because Akash or someone else rigged it! Lol I know that it's far fitched but that can happen. 😃