One Minor Girl, Many Arabs

punjini thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#1
One Minor Girl, Many Arabs
By Mohammed Wajihuddin
Times of India | September 9, 2005
They are old predators with new vigour. Often bearded, invariably in flowing robes and expensive turbans. The rich, middle-aged Arabs increasingly stalk the deprived streets of Hyderabad like medieval monarchs would stalk their harems in days that we wrongly think are history. These Viagra enabled Arabs are perpetrating a blatant crime under the veneer of nikaah, the Islamic rules of marriage. Misusing the sanctioned provision which allows a Muslim man to have four wives at a time, many old Arabs are not just marrying minors in Hyderabad, but marrying more than one minor in a single sitting.

"The Arabs prefer teenage, virgin brides," says Jameela Nishat, who counsels and sensitises young women against the malaise. Two of her volunteers, Shahida Yasmeen and Tasneem Sultana, in their early twenties experienced the trauma of being scanned by an old Arab. A few months ago, they accompanied an undercover television reporter who was following these sham marriages. They reached a home where half a dozen other prospective brides were gathered. "It resembled a brothel. The girls were paraded before the Arab who would lift the girls' burqa, run his fingers through their hair, gaze at their figures and converse through an interpreter," says Yasmeen recalling
the day.

Most girls inspected by the Arab were minors, and forced by a complex union of their parents and Islamic clerics to yield to the preliminary probes of the Arab.

Curiously, the high priests of the All India Muslim Personal Law Board (AIMPLB) and the fatwa brigade of Darul Uloom Deoband, who are gearing up to defend the legality of Islamic Courts in the Supreme Court, seem to have shut their eyes to this phenomenon that is aided and abetted by Hyderabad's Qazis or clerics.

Many Qazis prepare both marriage and divorce formalities together. While marriages require the grooms to be present, divorces are a bit different. A talaaq can be given verbally, through a letter, an email, telegraph, phone or even sms. "Many talaaqs are coming through sms these days," confirms Mufti Abdul Ahad Falahi, a Qazi at a Darul Qaza in Mumbai.
"If a woman who has received an intimation of talaaq doubts its veracity, she can check with her husband. If he accepts he has sent the message, the talaaq will be valid."
Most Qazis solemnise these sham marriages in complete violation of Islamic principles of nikaah and talaaq. A woman cannot be married off to another man unless her first husband gives her a divorce, or she has sought khula (separation) and has completed idat (a period of three menstrual cycles from the day of the talaaq).

Maulana Hameeduddin Aqil, head of a prominent Muslim body Millat-e-Islamia, dismisses such marriages as sinful. "They are committing a sin. It's not nikaah, it's prostitution by another name," says the frail, seventy five year old.

Impoverished and easily lured by the promise of a better future, many Muslim parents are increasingly pushing their daughters into this flesh trade that has a convenient respectability of an Islamic marriage. The Arabs, in collusion with the greedy Qazis, marry girls for a short period. In some cases, for a night.

On the first of August, forty five year old Al Rahman Ismail Mirza Abdul Jabbar, a Sheikh from the UAE, approached a broker in these matters, seventy year old Zainab Bi in the walled city, near the historic Char Minar. The broker procured Farheen Sultana and Hina Sultana, aged between thirteen and fifteen, for twenty thousand rupees. Then he hired Qazi Mohammed Abdul Waheed Qureshi to solemnise the marriage. The Qazi, taking advantage of an Islamic provision, married the girls off to the Arab. After the wedding night with the girls, the Arab left at dawn.

The girls' parents were promised their share of the booty by the broker but when it didn't, they went to the media. The girls are not too disturbed by the whole episode.
"The Arab would have given us money. We can't marry an Indian because our parents are too poor to pay dowry," the girls told Noorjahan Sidddiqui, a co-ordinator with Confederation of Voluntary Association, a Hyderabad-based NGO.

Muslim families that cannot afford to match the dowry demands of Indian grooms, are the first preys of old Arab grooms who not only give them the sanctity of marriage but also thousands of rupees. Unlike in India, in the Arab countries, it's the boys who pay girls the dowry. While rich Arabs go West to get white brides, transitory or otherwise, those with modest revenue streams look towards the East, especially Hyderabad where it seems, a well-oiled machinery is in place.

Hyderabad has a long history with Arabs. During their heydays, the Nizams (1724-1948) recruited many Arabs in their army. Subsequently, some of them guarded the Nizams' coffers and their harems too. Many Arabs married local girls and settled in the Barkas area of Hyderabad (it resembles an Arab street even today).

Muslim politicians in the city never took the issue seriously. "It's not on the poll agenda of any politician," says Mazhar Hussain, director of Confederation of Voluntary Associations, a social welfare outfit. Even Majlis-e-Ittihadul Muslameen, the party that Hyderabad's Muslims have voted repeatedly, has done nothing about it.
You cannot deny that the fortunes of many families have changed through such marriages," argues MIM's seventy three year old president Sultan Salahuddin Owaisi , seated at his palatial bungalow situated at a distance from the filthy slums of his faithful voters. Not politicians, not Islamic clerics, not even a majority of citizens, it appears, are too angered by the issue.

In the middle of this small world that looks part victimised and part practical, is a local mosque where a Friday sermon is coming to an end. A lanky imam reads out an "important" announcement: A Muslim body invites the faithful to discuss the evil effects of Television.

Created

Last reply

Replies

12

Views

1.3k

Users

7

Frequent Posters

punjini thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#2
Yes Abhijit, but in Hyderabad this is being done in a very organised way for many years with the aid of Qazis. This was highlighted in a well-made movie called Bazaar (Naseeruddin Shah and Smita Patil) many years ago.



corvette thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#3
This is an old article as I have seen it before.

Doesnt make the practice any more despicable, but I'm interested in knowing your reason for posting it - is it for our information or do you have a point to make?

😡 Madds 😡
punjini thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: Madmadgirl

This is an old article as I have seen it before.

Doesnt make the practice any more despicable, but I'm interested in knowing your reason for posting it - is it for our information or do you have a point to make?

😡 Madds 😡


Well, it is not so old in my opinion but the practice is certainly age-old. The reason for posting is simply to inform about certain ills in the Indian society which are not being addressed.
corvette thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#5
Poverty is no defence to selling your children for material gain - especially when the child's own quality of life takes a turn for the worse.

However I fear that this practice and others like it will continue to fluorish in the same way the gap between the rich and poor does in India.
MS.ATTITUDE thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#6
this happens everywhere wo christianty hu ya hinduism ya muslims sikh ya koi aur so plz don target one religion or ppl n yes its brutal n its shd b stopped.
koenigbobo thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: MS.ATTITUDE

this happens everywhere wo christianty hu ya hinduism ya muslims sikh ya koi aur so plz don target one religion or ppl n yes its brutal n its shd b stopped.

yeh agree wid u here !! ik religion ko target kerna teek nhee !! sab ik jese hen buraii insan ke under he religion mai nhee !!
chatbuster thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#8

i am not sure i understand all the fuss here. what is wrong is wrong. it's not just parents selling their kids that we are talking about here (and thankfully most of us will never have to reach those corners of economic deprivation and hell to understand why someone would do so). we're also talking about people misusing religious laws and customs. to the extent that happens, it's fair to talk about it and to raise consciousness against such practices. surely, the ability to get a high-tech sms divorce should be shocking? no? would we be protesting so loudly if that happened to someone we loved?
punjini thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: abhijit shukla

I agree with the majority here and reiterate that this is now unique to a religion. Poor parents compromizing their children -especialy daughters, I am sure happens in most religions. In USA a Utah preist was arrested 5-6 months ago for maarying underage girls to polygamists in Utah. If I say that 'Water' is not a typical depiction of a Hindu society - which BTW sarts with an underage girl being married off to an adult, I must accept that 'Bazaar' is not typical of Muslim society either - I didn't think so when I first saw it either.



What was shown in "Water' reflected a reality of Hindu India some 100 years ago, maybe even 50 years ago. The practice of sending widows to Banaras was more prevalent in Bengal. From the past 50 years, Hindu women have progressed a lot especially in urban areas. If you go to Bengal today, you will see widows wearing colourful dresses rather than the mournful white, remarrying and leading the same life as other women!

A great number of reforms have taken place among the Hindus and it is not tabboo to discuss age-old practises and their relevance. In fact, debate or tarka has always been a part of Hinduism. All the saints such as Shankaracharya, Madhvacharya, Guru Ramdas, Guru Nanak etc were people who never shied away from debates. Each of these saints advocated changes in religious and social practices. Even atheism has a place in Hinduism, there are no believers and non-believers.

Coming to 'Bazaar' I'd like to say that this movie definitely depicts the reality of the poor Muslims in Hyderabad, even today. "Nikaah" was another path-breaking movie which depicted the plight of Muslim women.

Being a viewbie, you might want to sound politically correct by saying that these practices exist in all religions. But certain religions which are more rigid than others have obviously not undergone reforms to the extent they would have if they were open. It is easier for malpractices to thrive in such conditions e.g.divorce by SMS. !-
Edited by punjini - 19 years ago
chatbuster thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: punjini



What was shown in "Water' reflected a reality of Hindu India some 100 years ago, maybe even 50 years ago. The practice of sending widows to Banaras was more prevalent in Bengal. From the past 50 years, Hindu women have progressed a lot especially in urban areas. If you go to Bengal today, you will see widows wearing colourful dresses rather than the mournful white, remarrying and leading the same life as other women!

A great number of reforms have taken place among the Hindus and it is not tabboo to discuss age-old practises and their relevance. In fact, debate or tarka has always been a part of Hinduism. All the saints such as Shankaracharya, Madhvacharya, Guru Ramdas, Guru Nanak etc were people who never shied away from debates. Each of these saints advocated changes in religious and social practices. Even atheism has a place in Hinduism, there are no believers and non-believers.

Coming to 'Bazaar' I'd like to say that this movie definitely depicts the reality of the poor Muslims in Hyderabad, even today. "Nikaah" was another path-breaking movie which depicted the plight of Muslim women.

Being a viewbie, you might want to sound politically correct by saying that these practices exist in all religions. But certain religions which are more rigid than others have obviously not undergone reforms to the extent they would have if they were open. It is easier for malpractices to thrive in such conditions e.g.divorce by SMS. !-

brilliantly said Sahana!

very recently, we've had the Imrana rape case in the news as well. and going back some years there was the Shah Bano case. these all reflect the plight of women subject to the diktats of certain wise men, and is similar in some respects to this case. what makes these cases note-worthy to me is that these practices were sanctioned/ condoned by a religious law board or others in positions of authority.

Edited by chatbuster - 19 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".