neha (mamta) cannot act - Page 4

Originally posted by: Hayati

Hey! i normally am a silent member of IF but i found this a rather interesting topic so i decided to shed some light on this topic as well. Firstly, it does take a lot of skills and effort to master a role and get into the skin of the character. for example, for mamta in this serial her role was really different and demanded a lot of different expressions from the young actress Neha. I do agree that in general Neha and Akshay are not brillant actor but they are acting to inact their roles and doing a good job of it. In the same way, Jai and Bani from KS have different roles that demand different expressions and acting skills from the actor. like i cannot imagine any one who can replace PD and do justice to the character of Bani. likewise i dont think anyone can do justice to the character of Mamta as well as Neha. overall, i think its quite mean to tarnish the names of all these actors by insulting the way they act and all because it is a tough job and i bet half of us would not be able to do half the acting they can. Insulting the way Neha looks and the way Jai and Bani acts is just appaling i mean we have no right to directly insult them that way. they are doing their job and i think they are doing a pretty good job of till now. thats why they have so many fans dont they? please stop this insulting and mud slinging coz the only ppl its gonna hurt are these commendable actors like Jai and Bani and Mamta who would be hurt and extremely demotivated to read post like this.

well, u are right in one sense. that we should stop all the mud slinging. but were we the ones who started it first?😆😆😆

i am not even a die hard fan of neha mehta, but yeah, the way the topic starter pursued her 'expressions' pissed me off. majorly.😡

yeah, i know we can't even do half a good job as these tv stars. that is why we are at home and they are on tv.😊 at least, for the time and money, we spend on them, they should do a good job.😊

the dedication that i see in neha mehta is somehow missing in prachi desai. this is entirely my opinion.😊

no 5 fingers are the same. u can't expect everyone to have the same opinion. and since we are in the topic of bad acting, i thought i'd give the topic starter some examples of who i tink acts badly.😊

if this topic offends you so, pls ask one of the mods to close it. 😊

true, these kind of posts might make them demotivated, but it might also push them to act better.😊 how they will take this critisism, we dun know. so one can only hope they'll take it on a good way. 😊

tt's all. i am done here.😊 hasta la vista darlings.

~leena 😊

Friends, its so true that our likes and dislikes are totally different.. Every member here in IF, has his/her own favourite. So it is obvious that few like Neha , few like Ajay and Anand. Few hate some other actor etc etc.. So this is bound to happen , bcos ours is a Big Big family comprising of nearly 2 lakh members...

This is where the discussions and arguments that we have in our forum gets very interesting, as all members try to opine what they feel... But we always need to remember that we need to write our thoughts in a very constructive manner... We all have the right to speak out and trust us, IF wants all its members to get a clean platform for debating... So you all are welcome to talk about your likes and dislikes. But the only request we do have is that, when you all are in a debate, please do take care of the language you use, please see to it that you do not bash your fellow members, do not bash the other actors...

And Leena , do not worry. This thread is very nicely dealt with by you all... I dont see any reason why i need to close this thread. So far, so good... You all have written what you feel is the best, you all have spoken your mind. As i said, you have a right to speak out. So i am glad that the members here, have spoken their heart out, that too, in a neatest possible way!!! 👏

Originally posted by: sree

Friends, its so true that our likes and dislikes are totally different.. Every member here in IF, has his/her own favourite. So it is obvious that few like Neha , few like Ajay and Anand. Few hate some other actor etc etc.. So this is bound to happen , bcos ours is a Big Big family comprising of nearly 2 lakh members...

This is where the discussions and arguments that we have in our forum gets very interesting, as all members try to opine what they feel... But we always need to remember that we need to write our thoughts in a very constructive manner... We all have the right to speak out and trust us, IF wants all its members to get a clean platform for debating... So you all are welcome to talk about your likes and dislikes. But the only request we do have is that, when you all are in a debate, please do take care of the language you use, please see to it that you do not bash your fellow members, do not bash the other actors...

And Leena , do not worry. This thread is very nicely dealt with by you all... I dont see any reason why i need to close this thread. So far, so good... You all have written what you feel is the best, you all have spoken your mind. As i said, you have a right to speak out. So i am glad that the members here, have spoken their heart out, that too, in a neatest possible way!!! 👏

oh thanks sree! i am glad that all our debates and opinions here are respected. 😊

i agree with jigglypuff and star2

I think the girl, who play mamta's role is a fantastic actress. . She does perform well, at least better than "Bani" form Kasme Se, she is one of the actresses who have same expression, and it doesn't matter if she is smiling or crying.