Today's episode from my point of view - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

19

Views

2.7k

Users

16

Likes

60

Frequent Posters

MsFoodyTwoShoes thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#11
ok first of all shilpa's defination of 1 aur 1 ..11 was 🤣 ..nd pls somebdy replace sajid..he has become a hugest fan of rahul.not to wonder he got 9 from him their perfrmance desrvd 18...n the couple who got 18..hang on it ws a 22 marks ka perfrmanc or evn 24 seeing the capability of judges..just becoz the poor kushal accpted that he goofed up that doesnt means you will give him 18..he forgot steps but there was no goof up in props section..charlie was also not dat bad as judges made her..disappointed
Edited by ..SalmanGirl.. - 12 years ago
-Araina- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#12
So we get the least of what we wished for. The constant biased publicity and the not-so-related comments from the judges. Some parts rightly said while others un-needed.

This view is just from reading your topic. I have yet to watch the episode myself. Will comment in detail when I do.
-Nymphadora- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#13
i hate the fact as to how much Rahul Mahajan is promoted!
okey they were good-credit to the choreographer
but they got the 2nd highest marks of the day after Jay Mahi!!???
What The??
thier dance was good-but the marks were too high!-not done,simply not done!the max they deserved was maybe a 22-not more than that
i just hope they reduce RM's coverage in the upcoming episodes,hes getting kind of irritating now!
comming to the dance Dimply was dancing Rahul was maneuvering here😆,never the less a very smart way to hide Rahuls pretty obvious flaws as a dancer

Ravi is a very good dancer,Sargun seemed a bit off-the concept could have worked well.Ravi saying his girlfriend works hard hence she couldnt dance was kind of weird-i mean common almost one part(if not both) of a jodi works for a daily soap!how much time they must be getting to practice,i found the excuse making thing kind of irritating!

Jai Mahhi-i think were the best,they are a jodi to watch out for-they arent the best dancers in the world,but they work very hard-not to forget their choreographer too seems to be someone willing to experiment with them-they are in my opinion going better with every week

Karan and Nisha-were nice,comparison to last week where they didnt dance much,this week was good,thier chemistry and tuning in really good,however i hope somewhere down the line the "mush" factor in thier performances gets reduced and i hope they are given more variety in dancing,and get to show more emotions over just love,like sadness,anger, aggression,hatred etc.Nisha seems to be a good dancer,i hope we get to see more of them

Kushal Elena-ill be honest i didnt like them-no offense meant to anyone-Kushal was very dheela dhaala-it didnt look like he wanted to dance,it lacked the energy and punch
it seemed like he was bored dancing-not to forget Kushal even blanked out-maybe he was unwell or something
Elena was dancing properly on her own,but Kushal was a let down.Kushal looked like he wanted to wrap up the dance and leave.The Judgement given was correct,but i think he deserved atleast a 21,18 was too low.
but i liked the fact that Kushal himself knew and admitted that he did a blunder,rather than making excuses for it

Amar-Charile-i think Charlie is somewhere down the line bogged down by the fact that she is paired with a brilliant professional dancer like Amar.It must be hard for her to even match up with him,she must already be under pressure since she has to work even harder as compared to others to match her Baliye.I feel bad for her-because she is a good dancer if not a brilliant one like Amar.I hope she relaxes a bit,i hope they do better next time,beacuse they do have potential.

Coming to the judges:
1)Terrence-has a very nice way of judging,he gives advise not to forget he gives it very nicely without sounding rude or sarcastic.I feel his comments are the most relevant out of all three.
2)Shilpa-she gets a bit swayed away by chemistry etc,but never the less she gives more or less fair scores.
3)Sajid-i miss Farah yaar!someone get his sister back!!!😭She was a way better judge than him.Sajid'd entertainment criteria of judging is really irrelevant and irritating.This is dance show not a entertainment based show that entertainment is the key.Even a person jumping around like a chimpanzee is entertaining-but can that be called dance?An entertaining performance need not necessarily actually have dance in it...of all the Judges Sajid is irritating-not to forget the fact that he has already made a favorite in Rahul Mahajan-Oh Help!!!

agree with all our pointers😊
nice post
shruti
PS-about Shohaib Sania-are they really going to be participating as a 12th jodi or were they just brought for time pass?
Edited by shruti.nil - 12 years ago
OodlesDoodles thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 12 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: -Babycakes-

The judges are just so biased especially Sajid Khan he's like got the hots for Rahul or something. I believe that even tho khushal did make some mistakes they weren't that bad that they shud be given a 6. I guess the favouritism and the entertainment factor has come in the way for Sajid and hence he is only wanting to see entertainment.

This show is a dance based show and not an entertainment show I'm sure that he must have been told that when he got approached for the show. Tonight the person which I really enjoyed would have to be Jay and Mahi gosh they were great and so was Ravi and Sargun.

I expected Shoaib and Sania to make their entry with a dance especially with all those promos we have seen especially in every break of the last episode. They were okay buh was it necessary to ask for Sanias views? They shud make her the 4th judge then.

Thank God we didnt see as much Rahul as we did next week buh then I don't wanna jinx that Eva. Less laughing from
Shilpa too she was more serious today.

Sajid plz plz just judge the dance that's what ur here for.

Aur kuch nahi and I hope the next episode is good.

Fingers cross



Thats the part I don;t like Preeti. These are judges and you have to be unbiased and it starts getting ugly when judges start to show partiality. Sajid is going over and above with promoting Rahul.

What does he mean by entertainment.Comedy is not the only form of entertainment. Like I mentioned earlier even Love is a part of entertainment so is Sadness. Magic is also a part and yes they could have done better but why not critique them. I am happy for Shilpa as she atleast pointed out the flaw rightly in Kushal's act. Sajid is a dancer and can critique well too but instead he decides to laugh off the flaws off Rahul on the name of entertainment. Now that is not right as he is looking NOT for entertainment but for comedy.

I too was happy we did not see Rahul with his one liners and I think that is to keep him at bay with the guests. He might say things that might not go down well so lets just have him quiet this week So my feeling is next week he will be back to form like last week.

Sania being the guest is asked her opinion and I think that was fine as everyone does that . When you have actors come whether it be JDJ or DID or SRGMP they are asked for their expert advice just like Sania is asked. However why did they ask her only and not Shoaib beats me.
OodlesDoodles thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 12 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: -RD-

I have not seen the thing entirely but definitely i do have a thing or two to say about the judges cause i dont find them fitting enough for the job and specially the kind of remarks they pass , I mean both Shilpa and Sajid dont even know the Z of dancing themselves so really what are they judging the contestants on ..🤔...no surprise there really then that one has absolutely no clue abt the marks they r giving while the other is looking for comic talent in a dance based show😕

And what is NB really about ...judging the popularity of the jodi or discovery of a dancer in a non dancer or how u showcase the skills u already have or ...cause the judging really doesnt make it clear say in Amar's case ...if they are really focusing on the jodi making progress tog then they shud really see the effort side of it more and look at the performance objectively giving all issues equal weightage..tooo much to ask for i guess from a reality show i guess where the popular ones (in recent times) get marked poorly initially to show the fairness of it all while the real idea somewhere is to get the fans into action so that the voting and related hungama begins and gets them the share of attention they are looking for 🤔


Oh and am i glad or what that you are back to writing yr views cause i love the way you write 😊



Hi Pooja thank you so much...🤗its people like you who make me want to write 😊

Actually the notion that everyone gets is that Shilpa and Sajid are not fit to judge a dance show is sad . Both these 2 are good dancers in their own rights. Shilpa is a trained Bharatnatyam dancer while Sajid is a very good dancer having won dance competitions as he mentioned in the episode today. Ages ago in the show Jeena Isika Naan hai Farah had mentioned her biggest competition was always her brother. If she did not win it would be Sajid. Farah managed to make a career out of it but Sajid did not pursue however I think given this knowledge he should be a good judge.With regards to mark Shilpa has been fine its her comments that make her sound like she is clueless but never has her marks really been totally off.

This is the first time I am seeing this show and I am under the same impression is its about judging people together. If not whats the difference between this show and the rest of the shows. If its a jodi then the jodi should be judged. I am fine wiht what they told Charlie as that was more for Amar to realize that just because he can do it she cannot . Also Charlie has lot of inhibitions which maybe Amar may have not realized to be a huge reason. So although the judges comments were harsh I think it was what Amar needed a reality check. That he needs to understand his partner's weakness and play on it and not on his strength. If he did want to play on his strength then he needs to make sure that like Rahul Charlie gets the least portion of dance. He decided to go bold and so although the marks are not right the comments are fine for me.

What irks me in all this is the unfairness. Its fine to give AMar and Kushal those marks I have no issues as they were not good compared ot the rest but what was not fair is to give those marks to Rahul.

ShivTRSS thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#16
I just hope ki charlie controls her nervousness and gives her best next time. I know she is very much pressurised, but she needs to focus
VishaD. thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 12 years ago
#17
'This is not Comedy Circus. All he did was circus and just because Dimpy did all the dancing does not make his scores right. He should have gotten 7 instead 9. What a joke the judges are making of the dancers in the running. '

I certainly got to agree with this. Sajid was saying he is a big fan of entertainment and giving Rahul and Dimpy that score made me wonder what is Nach Baliye based on? Entertainment or Dancing? We know that Sajid is trying to make jokes but he could also be a little serious about his judging. I felt everyone was good and as for Kushal, i feel he could improve more as Elena is really good and flexible in her moves. Coming to Amar and Charlie, i mean Sajid could have made his remark sound better. Now make the poor girl cry and break her spirit. Its not easy for a non dancer to dance on a stage being watched by many people and later aired on TV. Even i would freak out and dancing next to a dancer like Amar, its like being in a pressure cooker. Hopefully she would be much stronger next week. I also liked Ravi and Sargun's dance and Ravi was really flexible as the Robot. It was one of my favorite. Karan and Nisha was sweet and would hope to see them doing different moves in the coming week instead of just slow and romantic.
-Mmmmm- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: priya.nair


Rahul/Dimpy ' I agree that the cheoreographer has done a awesome job of having dimpy doing majority of the dancing so Rahul's 2 left feet was not noticed. However this is nach baliye and the baliye has to dance. Sajid is in love with Rahul that I feel he is biased in his scoring. Over here when Karan and Nisha got 7 for less dancing the most he should have given Rahul too was 7 instead entertainment and 9. Also why give him the extra publicity of Step of the WEAK.

Kushal/Elena- Ok I watched this twice to see why they got such low scores as to what I missed. Kushal was not as bad as they all made it sound. Ya he could have been better but 6 comeon judges that was way too low when you can give Rahul a 8 the least Kushal deserved was a 7. This was through and through a props act so that cannot be totally blamed on Kushal.




Priya... I agree with your points... The judging is very very inconsistent... Their bias towards Rahul is very visible and its just not fair for the other contestants...

Rahul and his nautanki... Sigh... They shld just name this show nautanki baliye... 🥱



Edited by -Maddy- - 12 years ago
punters thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#19
Agree with all of you here kushal deserved more than 18
SunshineGirl6 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
#20
Well said !!

For me its couple dance rather than one person dancing alone showing their skills...for most of them just run around rather than dancing...
Judges were unfair to Amar Charlie...they lacked the intensity I agree but still judges were a bit harsh..CHarlie is an amazing dancer !!
Kushal was bad...he got the deserved marks !!
Rahul ugghhh WTH are judges doing sidofying him hmph !!
Smita's performance was not upto the mark as well !!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".