Sur Kshetra Discussion Thread - Page 14

Created

Last reply

Replies

137

Views

19.9k

Users

29

Likes

209

Frequent Posters

pakeezah thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: shirani7

I am so sad Imran is out 😭 I loved his unique voice


**************

Im going to miss Imraan too, both his voice and jokes😭 but i think Nadeem being
the more classically trained and experienced singer got chosen over him to be able
to keep up in later rounds.

He got full marks in episode after that so maybe it was the right decision. Its either
Nabeel or one other now for the sur taaj and i cant see imraan or nadeem winning
over nabeel for the chair.

anyways i saw that imraan and mulazim got taken by Atif for his Jazba tour to USA
after the Sur Kshetra show episodes were wrapped up so he got something out
of being on the show. I hope even Bollywood will choose him to play back. theres
something so melodius about Imraans voice, it will be a shame if people cant hear
him after show gets over.

pakeezah thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
episode 24th November

himesh sang well i like his new lively behaviour. mulazims
mimicry of himesh was side splitting.

so happy nadeem got full marks!

i wonder why Ashaji always looks at runa laila as soon as
performance finishes to discuss the marks. she should
just giv her own opinion, not try to influence.

Diljaan was wonderful.

I was touched that both Aman and Diljaan have so much love
for Atif inspite of his sometimes uncalled for criticism of their
performance. I hope he respects their love and shows he is
worthy of it. Diljaan especially is heartbreakingly honest in showing
his respect and love for Atif. I hope all these boys become big
stars and are very successful in life. They are very special people.

Whatever Atifs abilities as a singer, his confidence is amazing.
He doesnt let the peoples criticism get to him but pushes himself
to perform even more in front of them. And no one has his voice
so his singing sounds unique and that is his plus point. It must
be frustrating for his detractors. You can do practise and get sur
or whatever but how do u get a voice like that?

I hope Atif will practise sur too however, because he should keep
singing even when his rockstar days are over because his voice
is so different and pleasing in playback. His voice and a correct
sur will give him long long career in playback.

Ayesha is so sweet. I didnt like her in beginning but she is
become a positive aspect of Sur Kshetra with her sweetness
and pretty face and neutrality.

Im glad Abida ji is back. I dont miss Ismail Durbar at all. Some
nice good vibes make a nice show. Im relieved that there havent
been really negative vibes nowadays.

That was the biggest drawback of the show. It was driving people
away from watching the show.



November 25th.

Highlight - for me was Abida and Atifs performance in beginning
and Mulazims performance in middle. Mulazim is very special and
unique. ive downloaded his songs and listen to them over and over
again. such a husky but pleasing sound to his voice and his control
over sur and the little variations he does in his songs...ufff! kya kahoon?

I think nabeel deserved the surtaaj but ...as long as he does get
the remaining seat...buddha is technically superb but i prefer
Diljaan when both are at their best.

One thing was when everyone stood up to applaud Abidaji and
Atifs performance only Ashaji kept sitting down and didnt stand
up. I thought that was in poor taste because Abidaji is a colleague
and good manners dictates that one should stand up when everyone
else is.

Now ive forgotten what was shown for next week. I hope its
good. I think yashraj performs.






April2007 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: pakeezah

episode 24th November


himesh sang well i like his new lively behaviour. mulazims
mimicry of himesh was side splitting.

so happy nadeem got full marks!

i wonder why Ashaji always looks at runa laila as soon as
performance finishes to discuss the marks. she should
just giv her own opinion, not try to influence.

Diljaan was wonderful.

I was touched that both Aman and Diljaan have so much love
for Atif inspite of his sometimes uncalled for criticism of their
performance. I hope he respects their love and shows he is
worthy of it. Diljaan especially is heartbreakingly honest in showing
his respect and love for Atif. I hope all these boys become big
stars and are very successful in life. They are very special people.





In answer to the hight lighted...

I don't think they have any love...they are just humble and in this situation they have to show respect..

Everyvbody has seen Atif bullying Aman..nobody is going to forget that..I am sure Himesh is telling him to ignore it and make best of a very bad situation. Aman knows that he was demoralized by Atif and abused..nobody can love their abuser..
pakeezah thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
u dont hv show humility and politeness by walking

up to captain hugging him and kissing him.

atif doesnt hv to put his arm around aman and sing with

him.

one can show love and respect like nabeel and mulazim

do for himesh ji by bowing head and speaking politely.

its because equations are different with atif and aman

and diljaan than yashraaj and buddha. yashraj and buddha

dont hv that much affection for atif as the other two.


but you dont hv to believe. pls keep thinking the way you

do. that is your way of thinking.
pakeezah thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
December 9th. missed seeing in full but caught mulazims
solo. fantastic. i love mulazims voice. im praying he gets
a producer to bring out an album.

ill hv to look up diljans performance since i missed all the
beginning and saras performance also. sad that sara and
nabeel didnt perform to their optimum level but i know they
are great singers. maybe next time. or did sara get eliminated?

i think nabeel has set such a high level for himself that if he
performs a little worse it seems that he has done bad.

in the end i saw mika and atif handing trophy to diljaan?
best singer? no issues diljaan can be fantastic when he
is in full flow.

oh!!! one issue i have with atif. in precap for next week.
he is asking "asha ji 'hum ko luv kijiye' and i can sing luv songs."
!!!
ATIFFF!!!! hum sab adoring fans ko chhor ke aap asha ji se
love maang rahe ho...aap bhi..na..

hum koyalon ke tarah gaa nahi saktey toh kya hua? hum toh
laila ne jaise majnoon ko, heer ne raanjha ko, ussi tarah se
mohabbat toh karsaktey, na?

zara idhar bhi kabhi dekh liya kijiye.😆


Niki_cool thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 12 years ago
Wow today's episode loved ittt<3

Specially Buddha , Nabeel and Diljaan's ❤️

Nabeel's that line "Udta hi fhirun in hawaon mein kahin😳" His voice really has a charm..😊

Edited by Niki_cool - 12 years ago
s123vi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
today mr. santoshi was chief guest n bst part was d theme of d episode ' captain ki lalkaar!'😊
sara... not bad! tried her best bt cud not get marks!
dijaan...luvd d discussion aftr his performance. both ashaji n aatif added sm fun 2 d show.😆😆 i want 2 say 1 thng...ashaji n aatif cn share a gud bond. they compliment each othr vry well smtyms!😊
nabeel... vry nice! jst wantd him 2 sing on little higher pitch!
yashraaj...rockin!
mulazim...gud bt lackd feelin! aatif may hv found his markin wrong bt 4 me, it was prfct!
budhha...desrved more thn 10 ! i luvd his song n singin!
as usual aatif turnd rude n indirectly targetd ashaji agn. ashaji as always smiled n said" kya bol raha hai?"😲 btw...i wud also want ashaji 2 avoid lookin 2 runaji while gvin marks! she really shud lrn smthng frm abidaji who may not b neutral bt mostly looks lyk 1.

ovrall anothr gud episode!👏
Edited by s123vi - 12 years ago
pakeezah thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
didnt like saras performance. too erratic.
i liked mulazims performance but agree he didnt
perform same level as yashraj nabeel.

diljaan did pretty good considering he came out of his
comfort zone and his voice is actually getting better
and better.

dont agree with captain atif ki if diljaan sings Hhhai Luv you
the girls will run away. the wrong girls might run away, but the
girls who love genuineness and sweetness will all come running
towards him not away😊

two winners again...well yashraj was equally deserving because
of the difficulty level of his song. but nabeels voice quality is too
good. he scores in the all round section but of course the judging
is also on sur and other things so it cancelled out nabeels superior
voice quality.

but honestly speaking if its playback i think nabeel will be the
producers choice.

i dont think buddha deserved only 10. i thought he sang well'
but then i thought nadeem sang well too and he always got
0 based on sur so dont know.

i wish atif wouldnt be so hard on buddha. it is unpleasant to
see atif try to single out who is vulnerable and try to make them
nervous. after all buddha too was one of his admirers till atif started
picking on him. atif, pls show some class. and be nice. what goes
round comes round and in this life you are blessed with everything
it can easily go away because of the law of karma.

still it is admirable the way he forces himself to be pleasant to
ashaji even after an altercation.

ashaji - i hv never liked her and after this show i never want to see
her again. something really unpleasant in her manner. honestly
she showed everyone a side of her which i dont think many people
thought of.

because of her name and talent she does stand out from judges
and tries to sing and what not but for me the negativity that came
out from her outweighs any good she put in.

himesh ji is nice but have to be honest and say that it is atif and
the pakistani contestants mulazim, imraan, nabeel who injected
some liveliness into the show. they have a different very natural
approach to life and also very good sense of humour besides
bringing in a very different kind of singing, pleasant and sweet.

also applaud diljaan for his beautiful character which he brings
out in his singing and yashraaj for the extra he tries to put into
the show, he improved in behavior from the first few episodes and
is now pretty well behaved and also is one of the best trained
and able contestants now although people still seem to prefer
diljaan to him.

ayesha is not the best hostess in terms of ability and presentation
but she is so pleasant and sweet and really looking nice in this.
one of the reasons to watch sur kshetra is how she and atif have
dressed up. they improve the scenery considerably and i wont be
surprised if many just watch the show because the two of them look so nice.

also the way pakistani contestants promote their culture through
their dress up, sometimes the costumes nabeel, mulazim, atif
wear are ones which have never been seen by most people outside
pakistan, not all of them are flattering but they wear it with so much
pride and panache it is touching. so much patriotism.😊jiyo!


Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".