Meri Beti hai, papa kahe ya Rishi Kumar !!! - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

25

Views

3k

Users

8

Likes

31

Frequent Posters

light_28 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: ashish.sachi


See the 1st Episode after leap. Indu & Shweta sitting on terrace of SN. Indu says " Yeh Rishi kumar aise kyun hain" , Shweta replies " Rishi kumar nahin Papa"

Agree Ashish ji.. she tried .. I remeber the episode also but that didnt affest Indu much.. she still continued calling him Rishi Kumar. Fine.. Keep that aside now for sometime..
But when Shwetha said to Zara.. ki yeh apne papa ko rishi kumar kahe ya papa isse mujhe koi pharak nahi padta... and that too in a stern manner, Indu was again hearing this from shwetha but the opposite version. So definitely Indu as a bacchi par ye second time wala dialogue zyaada asar karega because uski apni maa ne jab pehle usse papa kehne ko kaha tha wahi maa aaj uss fact ko completely deny kar rahi thi .. Toh ab mujhe bataiye kya shwetha ne indu ko confuse nahi kiya..??
Are you trying to understand what i mean to say..
A parent(shweta) first encourages a child(indu) to say something which is good but then the same parent in front of other elderly person(Zara) completely denies the fact earlier said just because the parent does not like the other elderly person trying to teach the same good thing. Will not this act make the child feel somewhere at the back of the mind that the the earlier thing taught to him was trivial and was wrong( Here Indu will feell.. Papa se better Rishi kumar hi hai .kyu itna sochnega..Papa kahu ya Rishi kumar..Mummy ko kuch farak and thats what she did last episode.. she spoke out what exactly her little mind took out of that days shwetha's behaviour.Children are damn sensitive and they pick up minute things easily..Its parents duty to be careful in front of them but shwetha simply goes insecure in front of zara and rishi and thats what indu has seen and misunderstood it
@AshishJI..CONGO FOR BECOMING ROCKERZ😊.I saw it now.
Edited by light_28 - 13 years ago
-Paulomi- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: light_28

Agree Ashish ji.. she tried .. I remeber the episode also but that didnt affest Indu much.. she still continued calling him Rishi Kumar. Fine.. Keep that aside now for sometime..
But when Shwetha said to Zara.. ki yeh apne papa ko rishi kumar kahe ya papa isse mujhe koi pharak nahi padta... and that too in a stern manner, Indu was again hearing this from shwetha but the opposite version. So definitely Indu as a bacchi par ye second time wala dialogue zyaada asar karega because uski apni maa ne jab pehle usse papa kehne ko kaha tha wahi maa aaj uss fact ko completely deny kar rahi thi .. Toh ab mujhe bataiye kya shwetha ne indu ko confuse nahi kiya..??
Are you trying to understand what i mean to say..
A parent(shweta) first encourages a child(indu) to say something which is good but then the same parent in front of other elderly person(Zara) completely denies the fact earlier said just because the parent does not like the other elderly person trying to teach the same good thing. Will not this act make the child feel somewhere at the back of the mind that the the earlier thing taught to him was trivial and was wrong( Here Indu will feell.. Papa se better Rishi kumar hi hai .kyu itna sochnega..Papa kahu ya Rishi kumar..Mummy ko kuch farak and thats what she did last episode.. she spoke out what exactly her little mind took out of that days shwetha's behaviour.Children are damn sensitive and they pick up minute things easily..Its parents duty to be careful in front of them but shwetha simply goes insecure in front of zara and rishi and thats what indu has seen and misunderstood it
@AshishJI..CONGO FOR BECOMING ROCKERZ😊.I saw it now.


sahi kaha yaar is POV pe mera nazar hi nehi gaya
nutan7 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: ashish.sachi



Basically you want to forgive each and every thing just on the premise that Rishi believes Zara is Indira.😆. Even though he has been proven wrong in front of world by DNA Reports.

He didn't thought that Shweta would be able to bring Indu or something like that. Basically he didn't even gave a thought about Indu or shweta , his thoughts were completely and totally immersed in Zara/Indira.

This kind of behavior may make him Great lover or something like that , but in my opinion he becomes a person totally self centric ,self obsessed, thinking only about himself and for his happiness , without giving an iota to his responsibilities or to people connected to him.

Such kind of people are not genuine hero in true sense of word.

This was not the Rishi , for which I started watching this serial.

pl. answer one question we have people around us who jump in flood to save life of unknowns
and die and there family suffers. do you call them self fish? they whenever there is question of life and death people having sensitive mind try so save life. rishi did the same
and here the person is not unknown to him. the person who saved his child 3 time.A person who saved his own life .the person who save life of all people in chandani chauk. Rishi tried to save life of such kind person (and succeeded also) . the person may be proved his child's mother and his wife. which is connected to him. if he would have given thought of his own family without saving a police officer ,then he would have called self concentric. saving anybodies life is gr8 job
remember he has not ran away with Zara to live happily with her leaving back his wife and daughter to suffer.he has put his own life in danger to save a person who is connected to him

ashish.sachi thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: nutan7

pl. answer one question we have people around us who jump in flood to save life of unknowns
and die and there family suffers. do you call them self fish? they whenever there is question of life and death people having sensitive mind try so save life. rishi did the same
and here the person is not unknown to him. the person who saved his child 3 time.A person who saved his own life .the person who save life of all people in chandani chauk. Rishi tried to save life of such kind person (and succeeded also) . the person may be proved his child's mother and his wife. which is connected to him. if he would have given thought of his own family without saving a police officer ,then he would have called self concentric. saving anybodies life is gr8 job
remember he has not ran away with Zara to live happily with her leaving back his wife and daughter to suffer.he has put his own life in danger to save a person who is connected to him


You first answer me one thing. Had Rishi jumped just to save Zara because she saved Indu & like?.

Had there been Shweta in place of Zara , would Rishi have jumped to save her , like he did now?. ( Shweta has definitely done much more for Indu than Zara)

The Answer to both above questions is big No.

The fact of the matter is , he is not at all concerned or interested in things like Zara saved Indu's life etc Had Zara would have done nothing for Indu , even then he would have reacted in same way.
His mind & thoughts are totally engrossed with Zara only. And he just wants to be with her , whether in life or death.
Other things or consideration ( which u have mentioned) & responsibilities are not even in his mind.

As I mentioned above , Yes these things made him great lover (no doubt) , but he definitely falls short of the stature of true Hero.

Edited by ashish.sachi - 13 years ago
LOVE_DMG thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#25
i dont care i jst want swetha out of the picture, mailk is far more eaiser to deal with.
nutan7 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: ashish.sachi


You first answer me one thing. Had Rishi jumped just to save Zara because she saved Indu & like?.

Had there been Shweta in place of Zara , would Rishi have jumped to save her , like he did now?. ( Shweta has definitely done much more for Indu than Zara)

The Answer to both above questions is big No.

The fact of the matter is , he is not at all concerned or interested in things like Zara saved Indu's life etc Had Zara would have done nothing for Indu , even then he would have reacted in same way.
His mind & thoughts are totally engrossed with Zara only. And he just wants to be with her , whether in life or death.
Other things or consideration ( which u have mentioned) & responsibilities are not even in his mind.

As I mentioned above , Yes these things made him great lover (no doubt) , but he definitely falls short of the stature of true Hero.

Excellent debate.I like it.
1. the hero of the show is not rishi its Indira Hitler didi his role is only to assist her in her gr8 dids
2. you asked me the Qs and you only gave ans. my ans to first .yes for both the reasons he save Zara
and for second may be or may not be but deffinitely not big no

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".