Sheetal a positive character or negative???

Page

dushturain

@dushturain

Rocker

Posted: 13 years ago

Ladies and gentleman,

Here I'm presenting my weird idea which just seemed to drop into my not so used nowadays brain. There are so many speculations going on abt who is Arav's father?? Is arnav really arav's dad?? Is sheetal a good character or bad??

To find answers to these questions, first we need to understand sheetal's character.

I think sheetal is a positive character. As arnav said before, they were girlfriend boyfriend. Remembering something else, arnav also said sheetal is like him, introvert and bla bla they became friends quickly. So according to arnav he soon realised his feelings towards her are not romantic.

But what abt sheetal?? We know she doesn't talk much, an introvert, madly in love with ASR , dumped by the same man. What was so easy for asr might not be so easy for sheetal. So she might go crazy for a little while, her ego hurt, hv an one night stand with someone as an act of retribution. After that she realised her fault came back to sense, became pregnant and gave birth. But as she really loves arnav she decided to brought up her son just like arnav. Gave him the name, probably told arav stories about arnav ( not mentioning his name ) and arav obviously wants to be like his dad became a miniature version of asr. Sheetal still loves arnav and thus she keeps karwachauth fasting for him.

If my weird idea fits, it will be an all izz well scenario. Sheetal is a good woman, arav is not arnav's son but still behaves like him and at the end of the track everyone will be happy albeit a little guilty.

Ps: I solemnly swear I don't hv a thing for sheetal. The cvs can also show her a real creep, chudail I won't mind as long as arav is really not arnav's son.

Having Bheja fried everyone thank you I'm going to sleep now.

P.p.s Tia has given a wonderful reply below which is really valid...do give it a read as well :)

Edited by dushturain - 13 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

arshii143

@arshii143

Navigator

Posted: 13 years ago

shital might be a good character.. but raising her son exactly like asr is quite weird..nd also as per your prediction it is gonna take lot of explaination by shital.. we never saw explainations in the history of ipk.. even shyam fiasco was rounded up in hardly 2episodes...😊
I don't think they wil show some random guy as arav's dad.. there must be some drama.. I storngly feel arav is somewhere related to Raizadas..

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

dushturain

@dushturain

Rocker

Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: arshii143
shital might be a good character.. but raising her son exactly like asr is quite weird..nd also as per your prediction it is gonna take lot of explaination by shital.. we never saw explainations in the history of ipk.. even shyam fiasco was rounded up in hardly 2episodes...😊
I don't think they wil show some random guy as arav's dad.. there must be some drama.. I storngly feel arav is somewhere related to Raizadas..

Yes true true...they never explain something properly in their serial...but I think my theory is their shortest route to exit this dimwit track...if they introduce some new character that is definitely going to stretch this track...and spoilers said madhura is here only for few days two weeks already gone...now it's time to end this track with a confession.

Quote

Tia.0

@Tia.0

Sparkler

+ 6

Posted: 13 years ago

Even if I accept your points, I do not believe she is a positive character... At the least she is an obsessed character, at the most a negative character...

The reasons are provided below,

she realised her fault came back to sense, became pregnant and gave birth. But as she really loves arnav she decided to brought up her son just like arnav. Gave him the name, probably told arav stories about arnav ( not mentioning his name ) and arav obviously wants to be like his dad became a miniature version of asr. Sheetal still loves arnav and thus she keeps karwachauth fasting for him. - Agreed. But now she knows that Arnav is married to Khushi... Why is she keeping Karwa Chauth for him? Khushi is already doing it for him and as a wife, this is her right. If she loves Arnav and wants his happiness, then she won't do it anymore accepting that it's not her right anymore. It's not as if she is extending Arnav's life one year on top of what Khushi is already extending by keeping fast.

So now she finally met arnav and realised he is happily married. And she being a good woman doesn't want to interfere into his life. Having said that actually there's nothing to hide or interfere except her own guilt. Her guilt of creating her own asr who loves her which is her son. - Good point. But Khushi has shown in million ways that she is trying to find out Aarav's father. A woman who wants to stay away from their happiness, would try to find another accommodation so that Khushi and Arnav can live happily after. She'd say something like this, "I met my relative today and she invited me to stay at her place. So I'm moving out." Then move to a hotel. So that Khushi has no way to keep looking for Aarav's dad and get tensed.

Instead, she is arranging her clothes in the wardrobe as if she is there to stay forever. How does she know that she won't get a call from her landlord today that her home has been arranged and the key is being sent to her unless she has arranged that situation herself?

Edited by tia.o - 13 years ago

Quote

dushturain

@dushturain

Rocker

Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: tia.o
Even if I accept your points, I do not believe she is a positive character... At the least she is an obsessed character, at the most a negative character...

The reasons are provided below,

she realised her fault came back to sense, became pregnant and gave birth. But as she really loves arnav she decided to brought up her son just like arnav. Gave him the name, probably told arav stories about arnav ( not mentioning his name ) and arav obviously wants to be like his dad became a miniature version of asr. Sheetal still loves arnav and thus she keeps karwachauth fasting for him. - Agreed. But now she knows that Arnav is married to Khushi... Why is she keeping Karwa Chauth for him? Khushi is already doing it for him and as a wife, this is her right. If she loves Arnav and wants his happiness, then she won't do it anymore accepting that it's not her right anymore. It's not as if she is extending Arnav's life one year on top of what Khushi is already extending by keeping fast.

So now she finally met arnav and realised he is happily married. And she being a good woman doesn't want to interfere into his life. Having said that actually there's nothing to hide or interfere except her own guilt. Her guilt of creating her own asr who loves her which is her son. - Good point. But Khushi has shown in million ways that she is trying to find out Aarav's father. A woman who wants to stay away from their happiness, would try to find another accommodation so that Khushi and Arnav can live happily after. She'd say something like this, "I met my relative today and she invited me to stay at her place. So I'm moving out." Then move to a hotel. So that Khushi has no way to keep looking for Aarav's dad and get tensed.

Instead, she is arranging her clothes in the wardrobe as if she is there to stay forever. How does she know that she won't get a call from her landlord today that her home has been arranged and the key is being sent to her unless she has arranged that situation herself?

Wow Tia, What a wonderful reply thanks..yes you do have valid points. It doesn't matter whether sheetal is a good character or bad character when it comes to staying in RM coz flaunting ex girlfriend / boyfriend in front of a wife is not a good idea. She shouldn't hv stayed in RM at any cost bas! and I don't want to talk about the whole basketball thing 🤢 I totally gave those episodes a miss. I remember one of yr post where you said it's not always a woman fault, the husband has the same equal portion of blame...which is sooo true in this track...

Till now the cvs have kept her character open she might be a good person( albeit obsessed /Pyscho ) or a real bad person. The cvs has made a super mess of this track and I hope they clear it properly.

Quote

Midnight

@Midnightsorrow

Trailblazer

+ 4

Posted: 13 years ago

She looked like a mad woman in the precap no positive character behaves like that after knowing the guy is married.

Quote

laksh65

@laksh65

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: tia.o
Even if I accept your points, I do not believe she is a positive character... At the least she is an obsessed character, at the most a negative character...

The reasons are provided below,

she realised her fault came back to sense, became pregnant and gave birth. But as she really loves arnav she decided to brought up her son just like arnav. Gave him the name, probably told arav stories about arnav ( not mentioning his name ) and arav obviously wants to be like his dad became a miniature version of asr. Sheetal still loves arnav and thus she keeps karwachauth fasting for him. - Agreed. But now she knows that Arnav is married to Khushi... Why is she keeping Karwa Chauth for him? Khushi is already doing it for him and as a wife, this is her right. If she loves Arnav and wants his happiness, then she won't do it anymore accepting that it's not her right anymore. It's not as if she is extending Arnav's life one year on top of what Khushi is already extending by keeping fast.

So now she finally met arnav and realised he is happily married. And she being a good woman doesn't want to interfere into his life. Having said that actually there's nothing to hide or interfere except her own guilt. Her guilt of creating her own asr who loves her which is her son. - Good point. But Khushi has shown in million ways that she is trying to find out Aarav's father. A woman who wants to stay away from their happiness, would try to find another accommodation so that Khushi and Arnav can live happily after. She'd say something like this, "I met my relative today and she invited me to stay at her place. So I'm moving out." Then move to a hotel. So that Khushi has no way to keep looking for Aarav's dad and get tensed.

Instead, she is arranging her clothes in the wardrobe as if she is there to stay forever. How does she know that she won't get a call from her landlord today that her home has been arranged and the key is being sent to her unless she has arranged that situation herself?

absolutely, i feel that right from aarav kidnapping track til now everything has been planned by sheetal, she is definitely not a positive character, she is pretending to hide arav's father identity but at the same time creating suspicions in khushi's mind her only target is khushi, she is pushing her to that extent that khushi herself will confront sheetal so that she can say arnav is arav's father.

If she is a positive character, she will not stay in RM and will not behave the way she is behaving now.

Quote

Sheetal a positive character or negative???

Related Topics

Explore Topics