The surname fuss: A married woman's predicament!

TheSlayer thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Engager Level 4 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 13 years ago
#1
A majority of married women across the globe face a never-ending, never-subsiding trauma of changing their last names to their husband's surnames. Though some are lucky enough to bypass the cultural radar by opting to retain their maiden names, there are those who are left with no choice but to append their male spouse's surnames to their first names. Inasmuch as we beat around the bush and throw the cultural tantrums around, we cannot deny the fact that such rituals are synonymous to involuntary slavery. When such biased, one-sided morals and virtues can be shoved down a woman's throat, why can't men be made to observe such traditions, at least in part?

Please debate.

Created

Last reply

Replies

46

Views

5.4k

Users

22

Likes

47

Frequent Posters

Freethinker112 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
I don't think women should be forced to adopt surname. If you want to keep your existing surname, keep it. 😊
Forever-KA thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#3
And where did that existing surname came from? Father or Mother? lol.
- On individual scale one still has the right to change their maiden name or not take the surname legally if I am not mistakes
- On level of society we cannot go back now as the whole system is built around it. It is like English language which has became the medium to communicate among different people. Even if we don't like it to change it will be a problem.
- On principle, I see your point. lol.
Edited by King-Anu - 13 years ago
TheSlayer thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Engager Level 4 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 13 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: King-Anu

And where did that existing surname came from? Father or Mother? lol.

- On individual scale one still has the right to change their maiden name or not take the surname legally if I am not mistakes
- On level of society we cannot go back now as the whole system is built around it. It is like English language which has became the medium to communicate among different people. Even if we don't like it to change it will be a problem.
- On principle, I see your point. lol.



From the father, I suppose. But I see your point.

Since it's the sperm that fertilizes the egg, should the male parent or spouse be given the authority to dictate the terms?
-Believe- thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#5

I dont think, a person's identity depends on a surnames...I know some people who use to say,''I liked my husband's surname more'' ...One practical difficulty, If anyone want to go outside india, or what about getting visa from outside countries ? For traveling on " spouses visa " claiming visa by virtue of her husband' s visa status , one of the cardinal points foreign countries check is whether in the visa application , husband's name has been taken by the wife a her last name or surname . If not, "spouse" visa could be refused. but she can apply separately and obtain tourist visa for limited period ...government of India shld take up this matter through diplomatic channels and incorporate the spirit of the Indian Law in respect of changing / taking names by women after marriage..😊

The other question is, Men should be allowed to use wife's maiden surname after marriage and and even after divorce??!?!?!😃
Chatoyant. thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#6
I've never liked the idea. Simply because in historical times, and probably even now, its looked upon as a sign of ownership, which makes a woman sound like a piece of property. I believe it should be one's choice, the ones that are pro changing last name should go ahead and do so, while the ones that aren't should have a choice not to.
Personally, I don't believe in these traditions and rituals, so wouldn't change mine. Unless ofcourse, the sole purpose of marrying one is their last name. ;)
Forever-KA thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#7
Xaffron, I do not think this has got anything to do with sperm or egg. lol. It is might is right type of mindset. Since the society in general has always been men dominated it is they who have set the rules and now they have become so common (passport, IDs, school register) that very difficult to go back now.
Prometeus, wife's maiden surname would be her father's name or father's family name. Now imgaine a man taking his father in-law's name instead of father's name lol.
What can happen is that husband adds his wife's name.
Example
Ajay Devgun becomes Ajay Kajol
Shahrukh khan becomes Shahrukh Gauri
Amitabh Bachan becomes Amithab Jaya
Now I don't know much more about who has married whom. lol.
Some information from Wiki
"Historically, a woman in England would assume her new husband's family name (or surname) after marriage, and this remains common practice in the United Kingdom today as well as in common law countries and countries where English is spoken, including Australia, New Zealand, Pakistan, Gibraltar, Falkland Islands, Ireland, India, Philippines, the English-speaking provinces of Canada, and the United States. This remains the most common practice in the United States. In Massachusetts, for instance, a Harvard study found approximately 87% of married college educated women take their husbands' name down from a peak before 1975 of over 90% but up from about 80% in 1990"
Edited by King-Anu - 13 years ago
return_to_hades thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#8

I never understood the tradition of changing names. Many people in my grandmothers generation didn't just change last names, but first names as well. Irrespective of who our names come from, our name has been ours from childhood to adult life. It is a part of identity and one should not have to change it. To me the thought of changing my last name is inconceivable. Not just is it unfair, it is such a hassle. Submit official name change forms. Update all your social networks. Update your banks, credit cards, wireless provider, employer, retirement account, voter registration, drivers license and registration – it is a pain in the ass that's not even worth anything.

I would be open to hyphenated last names if my spouse will also hyphenate theirs. The children will also have hyphenated last names. But what if children with hyphenated names marry each other. So hypothetically a Rai-Bacchan were to marry a Arora-Khan they would become Rai-Bacchan-Arora-Khan, and what if they in turn marry someone with quadruple hyphens? The Sri Lankans will have a run for their money with long names.

Some people are doing away with family names and giving their kids neutral names at birth. So John Doe does not name his kids Jane John Doe & James John Doe. He names them Jane Shannon Rose and James Michael Ryan or something like that. Eventually, many decades down the road, I think names passed through generations may slowly fade away. But who knows.

344471 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#9
We never followed the tradition of keeping family names or changing names after marriage. In fact, I can't even think of people from the older generation in my family who changed their names after marriage.
Polki_Zofi thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#10
Having the husband's surname is a beautiful tradition, and there seem nothing wrong in it, unless someone wants to make it issue in a relationship. A relationship always have much to deal with, I think it should be left on people to decide what they want, and should be clear before wedding.

Men giving up their backbone is the most unpleasant thing there can be, and women giving up their brains the next worst thing. But both are common these days, as people want to jump in just as desperately and they later want to jump out. The demands and the issues they never stop, as respect for each other, tradition or tolerance is least. Such marriages will never succeed.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".