PHOTOS: Is Rani Mukerji copying Vidya Balan? - Page 5

Originally posted by: koiza.k

again its about perspective. If you find rani's comic timing annoying thats your opinion. Many people including me think rani has the best comic timings, she does it very naturally. IMO vidya can never pull a bunty aur bubly or the recent aaiya as she does not have the comic timings which rani has, even kareena cannot. Most of the actors go OTT in such roles but rani is natural and likable even in the most OTT roles she has done.

Originally posted by: Nitu_TheTwisted

i know u have never liked Vidya coz may be she has beaten the asses of both kareena and katrina alone, well that's ur opinion. talking abt pulling off a role is ur opinion as well. Vidya hasn't done any full fledged comical role yet so how far its jusitifed that she can't pull it. Ghanchakkar is coming with Emraan and i am sure she will surprise again.

Rani is almost finished. Aiyya doesn't look like that golden opportunity and Talaash would taken up by Aamir alone. Rani shall join the bandwagon of preity rani tabu manisha urmila juhi etc after this year end..she has no market left for her. but yes she has been outstanding in some roles and she is defintely better from the current actresses except vidya

Nothing against vidya from my side and especially not because of her competition with bebo or kat. I have never praised kat on her acting skills, yes i always say she is a bigger star than vidya. Bebo i think is a brilliant actor, again its strictly my opinion but i feel what she did in JWM vidya might have never done that vice versa with TDP.

I think its too soon to call rani finished, lets see how well aaiya does, No one expected aaiya's trailer to generate so much hype but it did, lets see how it turns out for rani. I agree preity is finished but rani still has it and we'll only know by the fate of aaiya and talaash whether she joins their club or not.