Indias healthcare system.

Kya.Bolta.Tu thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#1
Ok we all hear in the news some day or the outher people dyeing out of medical negligence and stuff.My Question is that when In Govt medical colleges there isnt enough teachers and faculty members then what kind of Doctors can one expect?Isnt it Goverments duty to make enough provisions that colleges are equipped with new technologies.Sometimes even the equipments are so outdated that there is no use of them.I am myself a medical student and our libraries are outdated,there isnt journals books etc available.


So who is to be held responsible The Govt or the Doctors.
Edited by Wave. - 13 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

11

Views

1.4k

Users

5

Likes

4

Frequent Posters

373577 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: Wave.

Ok we all hear in the news some day or the outher people dyeing out of medical negligence and stuff.My Question is that when In Govt medical colleges there isnt enough teachers and faculty members then what kind of Doctors can one expect?Isnt it Goverments duty to make enough provisions that colleges are equipped with new technologies.Sometimes even the equipments are so outdated that there is no use of them.I am myself a medical student and our libraries are outdated,there isnt journals books etc available.


So who is to be held responsible The Govt or the Doctors.

cases of medical negligence get strongly contested. How many cases have been proved so far?
One reason is that we have a number of unauthorised quacks practicing in the garb of qualified doctors. The govt ought to strike down heavily to curb this menace first. It is true that many govt medical colleges lack basic amenities but there are quite a few good medical colleges in the country too. There is heavy competion among students to bag these seats . The govt ought to take measures to improve the facilities in other colleges too. lack of library facilities should not be much of a problem with the availability of internet facilities in most of the cities.
Lack of equipments or libraries or enough faculty may make it difficult for young doctors but cannot be held as an excuse for medical negligence. There are enough good doctors who have emerged from those very govt colleges. Better management of the colleges and healthcare should improve the situation greatly.
-Believe- thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#3
India's healthcare is free...& it guaranteed everything... thats why people frying everything to eat.😛
.Jane.. thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 13 years ago
#4
India's medical system has a lot of loopholes. There is lack of technology, medical knowledge and above all, corruption. Gone are the days when doctors were considered God in this country.
I know of so many cases where the doctor has diagnosed the patient wrongly. Sometimes, it's a genuine blunder on their part but sometimes, it's just that the doctor doesn't want to patient to recover quickly so he/she can mint more money from more consulting sessions. And yes, I know of a hell LOT of cases where sometimes, this practice has even taken lives of people.
So I blame both the doctors and the government. Government for the lack of infrastructure and doctors for being so greedy for money that they can even play with someone's life.

-Edited-

Just as a footnote, I even know of some very good doctors who are extremely dedicated to their profession and patients so my bitter comment was not meant to generalise and definitely not intended to target all the doctors (:
Edited by PurpleFairy - 13 years ago
373577 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#5

The governance in the country as a whole has many loopholes. I feel it is wrong to say that there is lack of technology and medical knowledge in the country. If that were so then the country wouldnt have been such a hot destination for medical tourism. We have some hospitals practising state of the art technology but it costs. patients from the deveoped countries are also flocking top India as they can get the same quality treatment for almost one third the price without long waiting periods.

The problem is more of an inequitable distribution of the healthcare facilities in the country. There is a wide urban-rural divide. Due to lack of basic facilities in the rural areas hardly any doctor wishes to be posted there. With better facilities and some incentives the govt may succeed in drawing the doctors to these areas.
Angel-likeDevil thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: Wave.

Ok we all hear in the news some day or the outher people dyeing out of medical negligence and stuff.My Question is that when In Govt medical colleges there isnt enough teachers and faculty members then what kind of Doctors can one expect?Isnt it Goverments duty to make enough provisions that colleges are equipped with new technologies.Sometimes even the equipments are so outdated that there is no use of them.I am myself a medical student and our libraries are outdated,there isnt journals books etc available.



So who is to be held responsible The Govt or the Doctors.

No body can be held responsible. Things are the way they are because of numerous factors... not just the govt. or the doctors. Anyways,
Firstly, the quality of doctors needs to be checked at college level. The medical students should be given training in the tertiary healthcare sectors(consultative care) and also an improvement in their own college faculty, infrastructure, other amenities. OK, the training is imperative, and this training needs to be supervised by experienced doctors. This will improve the quality of medical students graduating.
The quality itself is poor. So, this fault can be checked this way.
Secondly, the generic drugs need to be introduced which are much cheaper and can be easily affordable, considering the poverty and the number of BPL families dwelling in this country that fail to even recieve a medical appointment in a good hospital.
Thirdly, the existing primary health care clinics/hospitals need to be upgraded in all spheres . Educated trained medical staff, sufficient equipments, technological medical devices and other medical facilities, infrastructure...need to be upgraded or even introduced.
Fourthly, grading and ranking of all the clinics, private, government hospitals by a specially appointed committee.
Fifthy, the hospitals need to update their progess, downfalls and all in a computer site, along with it's grading and other profilic details. People can refer to this, compare between the hospitals, take a decision.
Competitiveness and ranking will always lead to progess.
Sixthy, just by upgrading the existing medical health care centres will not work. New healthcare centres need to be set up for every 2000/1000 people. The urban-rural gradient is clearly visible in the distribution of medical health centres across the country. So, this(i think is a provision of UHC) is to be checked most essentially by seetting up centres for every 1000 people. THIS will really lead to a progessive healthcare - provided, the health care centres have trained faculty, required equipmentsm devices, infrastructure, medicines.
Lastly, have you heard of UHC? Universal Health Coverage, that was proposed by the HLEG(High Level Expert Group) the Govt has appointed? It's been on news for quite a long time :) It is by far one of the best things the Indian govt has come up with IMHO. I dont remember the complete details of this programme, but, do read about it. I think it'll really change the way the healthcare is...
Do not just say the govt isnt doing anything... the government is working towards better health care provisions for it's people, although at slow pace. Afterall, it's the government's loss if there's high mortality rate :)
Edited by Angel-likeDevil - 13 years ago
Kya.Bolta.Tu thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#7
@zorro

The very good medical colleges in India are very less.Most of the Govt medical colleges even dont have teachers all round the year for students,they come on temporary basis from the good institutes,so basically all around the year students are left without any proper lectures and have to prepare for exams themselves.This is for theory part.Same is for rpacticals,that is shortage of lab assistants technicians etc etc.

So basically the sudents coming from these coleges are not par with very good Govt colleges,and they lack proper skills,and these are the people who are responsi for the wrong diagnosis of patients etc and wrong treatment which sometimes causes patients lives.

Well coming to Internet facilities its very shocking this is also limited to some of the coleges only.Most of the Govt colleges dont have this facility.Though these things arent much of a problem,looking at much more bigger problems.

I am not saying there is lack of technology and knowledge in medical colleges,I am saying the standards arent same everywhere,for eg the Govt medical colleges in Delhi are very good eg Maulana azad,VMMC but then you go to NE states or MP UP etc most of the colleges lack the infrastructure and teachers.

@PurpleFairy

Yes there are doc who knowingly dont cure the patient in one go and suggest unnecessary tests so that they can extract more money.Thats a diffrent Q altogether ,and its very disturbing.


Kya.Bolta.Tu thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#8
Does anyone know how many posts yoy have to actually make so that you can post more than 10 messages on the forum.This 10 posts for every 24 hour thing really sucks
Edited by Wave. - 13 years ago
373577 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#9
@Wave
I have to agree that the standards of medical coll in the country are not uniform and this includes both govt as well as pvt. Those in Delhi are quite good. The NE also can boast of some good colleges. From what I heard from my friends the one in Guwahati and Dibrugarh are quite good . They have all the major super specialities, the technology and also good faculty who are regular and dedicated. The IMC should prescribe more strict norms before recognising the colleges. Some pvt ones in Pune, UP and Karnataka are really pathetic.
The six AIIMS like institutes that are expected to come up this year should make things tad better.
Speaking of public healthcare the doctors are often kept busy with unneccesary work like documentation and statistics. Too much data gets collected with scant regard to the quality and relevance of data.
The case of bungling in NRHS and the murder of two doctors who dared to blow the whistle on the wrongdoings of mayawati's goons in healthcare was alarming. When legal system is seen as ineffective or tardy people have little hope to stand for justice and fairness in any system. Undue political pressure and interference in every field is one of the main cause that hampers progress.
373577 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#10
Ever thought that why a doctor can be held responsible for medical negligence but no politician, police, lawyer , engineer or a teacher gets booked for professional negligence?
A patient may already be on the threshold of death when he approaches a doctor and yet the doctor could be charged with negligence when he fails to cure or bring back the person to life from the brink of death but when the other professionals I mentioned above ( the list can get much longer--) fail to perform their duty and often ruining promising lives people hardly bat an eyelid 😕

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".