Finally Ashaji came thru

Page

Mumtaz24

@Mumtaz24

Beginner

Posted: 12 years ago

I have felt from the beginning that Ashaji somehow never gave Vipul the credit he deserved, even when he sang really well. I felt Salim knew that too. She always found something negative to say. Whereas with Dev, even though he did not sing up to par, she always complimented him. I got the feeling that she knew Vipul is a much better singer but she was backing Dev the whole time maybe because Lataji also liked him. Today's episode was the first time I noticed that she gave Vipul due credit and appreciated his singing for the first time. She probably realises that he is a better singer for sure than Dev.

Also in today's episode for the first time, she told Dev that his singing was not quite up to the level that was expected at this stage of the game.

Indian Idol 6 has been disappointing but I honestly believe that from all the singers Vipul deserves to win.

It is also not appropriate for the judges to tell Vipul that he is likely to win. I watched the X-Factor and defintely was shocked that the contestant that won was the one who deserved it the least - I think his name was Gurmeet or something like that. He totally was not deserving and I think the results was most unexpected!!!

Quote

Frequent Posters

Suresh

@suresh555

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

Asha is overly obsessed with Dev, honestly her face lights up when Dev comes on stage. It's nothing wrong to have a favorite but she is very visual about her excitement towards Dev and her lack of expressions for Vipul and Amit. I am very glad that for the first time she had a honest comment towardsDev but I still feel Dev will get the best marks (which we don't see). They praised Dev in his 2nd performance (Koi haseena jab rooth) though I found his 1st peformance from Apne was better than the 2nd one. The other judges are not far behind with their unexpected comments (like what was wrong with Amit's Jhil mil sitaron ka aangan performance?)

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

sunom

@sunom

Inactive

Posted: 12 years ago

I expected fair judgement but...all wrong judgements

Quote

DelhiLover

@DelhiLover

Beginner

Posted: 12 years ago

Vipul ne bahut accha gaya. He is back in his original form.

Ashaji is bias. She never like Vipul before.gud that she gave him nice coments. Vipul is a gud singer. please vote for him

Quote

Dadisa2011

@Dadisa2011

Explorer

Posted: 12 years ago

i personally think that vipul is a great singer but his voice is a bit effiminate to sing playback for all heros. i like amit's and dev voice better. that being said i think Vipul has a great stage presence and his singing style is great. he makes even the most difficult song effortless. i think all 3 contestants are nice and i would be happy no matter who wins. plus this is like an audition for all singers so even if they dont win the trophy they gir enough exposure.

Quote

urvash

@urvash

Explorer

Posted: 12 years ago

Amit is the Abhijeet Sawan that we are looking for.

Quote

nafeesaeed

@nafeesaeed

Explorer

Posted: 12 years ago

I respect Ashajee so much bt sorry to say after this episode i must say k Ashajee never encourage Vipul.every1 shud watch this week episode n decide who is da best singer.Vipul hr lihaz se best singer hey.hmarey liey teeno singers same hain bs jo best singing kre os ko vote dena please n i think vipul is da best.dev cant sing jis level ka vipul ga skta hey.judges most of da time biasd rahey hain iss season main...poorvi ki elemination k baad one week main rating ka difference chek krain tb 34 tha now its on 17...so fair judgment hoti rahey to janta bhi like krti hey...

Quote

Jaspal

@JasToronto

Dazzler

Posted: 12 years ago

Although I want Amit to win because I love his high pitch singing which has a flavour of punjabi folk music but as far as singing is concerned I believe that Devinder is ahead of Vipul and Amit. If Ashaji is not saying what we really want to hear from her, that doesn't mean that she is a bias Judge or she has some sort of soft corner for Devinder.We have seen on Sunday's episode that out of four guest new singers at least 2 called Devinder's name for best singer. They were Daya and Pundit. That indicates that Ashaji is correct in her judgement when she admires Devinder.

Devinder ko dekhtee hi Ashaji ki anko mai ek nirali chamak aa jati hai aur unki baachee khil jati hai😊

I guess in grade 7 Hindi text, I read a short story from Munshi Prem Chand ji, and the title was, " Haar Ki Jeet." It started with these line:

Ma ko apnee bete, shahukar ko apnee laindar ve daindaar aur kissan (farmer) ko apnee lehlahatee kheto (fertile fields) ko dhekh kar jo aanad prapt hota hai wahi aanand baba Bhari ko anpa GHORA (horse) dekhkar prapt hota tha.

I will change these green lines to fit this phrase:

wahi anand Asaji ko Devinder ko dekhkar prapt hota hai.😆😆😆

Quote

Finally Ashaji came thru

Related Topics

Explore Topics