I am still not happy with Judges marking style!!

Page

Shaitaan Haiwan

@Shaitan-Haiwan

Stunner

+ 8

Posted: 13 years ago

The judging has been off this season, in the beginning they were too lenient and now I dont know what they are.

I dont know if anyone will agree with me but I still feel that Darsheel-Avneet are not getting the marks they deserve. I really believed they deserved a 27 for their bachpan act. 24 was too low. Their coordination was really good and the steps were clean. I know it wasnt a "perfect" act (although I barely noticed the mistakes) I am just not happy.

With Rithvik's contemporary, I dont understand WHY he didnt get a 30, Remo did say, you missed "this is it" by just a small margin, but why didnt he explain WHAT exactly was wrong with the act. I dont understand why Remo can overlook Rashmi's mistake in her first performance and give her a 30 but cannot do the same for Rithvik (although I didnt even see any mistakes in Rithviks dance)

And then when we have Isha/Salman...I really dont know why they got 30 for the beauty n beast act, I really found nothing great about it. Where as their other act, the Satrangi one, I liked the concept and colors and they should have gotten a bit higher for that one.

I dont know what the judges are on. Also, I noticed that they always talk to each other before giving out marks, as if their agreeing on a particular number😕 It just seems bizzare to me. There is a reason there are THREE of you, I dont think there is anything wrong with discussing marks but I hope they're not "mark-fixing".

Edited by DIDfan89 - 13 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

Arnav90

@Arnav90

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 13 years ago

I am very Happy with marks though Ritwik deserved 28 or 29 but not 30 as they little bit Miscordinated but Isha n Salman was bang on...

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

gafulu14

@gafulu14

Sparkler

Posted: 13 years ago

me 2 , I noticed that they always talk to each other before giving out marks, as if their agreeing on a particular number😕 It just seems bizzare to me. There is a reason there are THREE of you, I dont think there is anything wrong with discussing marks but I hope they're not "mark-fixing".

Quote

Equine

@Equine

Dazzler

Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: gafulu14
me 2 , I noticed that they always talk to each other before giving out marks, as if their agreeing on a particular number😕 It just seems bizzare to me. There is a reason there are THREE of you, I dont think there is anything wrong with discussing marks but I hope they're not "mark-fixing".

i noticed tht too. thy shld give their individual marks based on their own analysis. i think madhuri n karan get influencd by remo's marks, which is fine smtimes, i guess. he's th master of dance so probly he points out mistakes the other two have missed. smtimes karan changes his marks looking st other two. LOL😆

Quote

51559

Suspended

Posted: 13 years ago

30 is so common.. they gave 30 to those who dont know dancing...

Quote

charmz517

@charmz517

Voyager

Posted: 13 years ago

Rithvik didn't get a 30 because there were some coordination issues in between, but luckily it was overshadowed mostly by the graceful and sentimental act. No doubt it was a beautiful performance, but not as perfect as their performance on Saturday.

I thought Rashmi and Deepak's scoring was a bit lenient on Sunday's episode. They were very cute, but there were also some coordination issues. Just like on Saturday there were points of uncoordinated portions, however, they still got full 30s.

But overall, I loved Rithvik-Sneha's Saturday performance, Salman-Isha's Sunday performance and Deepak-Rashmi's Saturday performance. 👏

Quote

51559

Suspended

Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: charmz517
Rithvik didn't get a 30 because there were some coordination issues in between, but luckily it was overshadowed mostly by the graceful and sentimental act. No doubt it was a beautiful performance, but not as perfect as their performance on Saturday.

I thought Rashmi and Deepak's scoring was a bit lenient on Sunday's episode. They were very cute, but there were also some coordination issues. Just like on Saturday there were points of uncoordinated portions, however, they still got full 30s.

But overall, I loved Rithvik-Sneha's Saturday performance, Salman-Isha's Sunday performance and Deepak-Rashmi's Saturday performance. 👏

yes I agree... Rithvik is the one who deserves 30.. he is an awesome dancer 👏

Quote

Rapier

@Rapier

Rocker

Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: charmz517
Rithvik didn't get a 30 because there were some coordination issues in between, but luckily it was overshadowed mostly by the graceful and sentimental act. No doubt it was a beautiful performance, but not as perfect as their performance on Saturday.

I thought Rashmi and Deepak's scoring was a bit lenient on Sunday's episode. They were very cute, but there were also some coordination issues. Just like on Saturday there were points of uncoordinated portions, however, they still got full 30s.

But overall, I loved Rithvik-Sneha's Saturday performance, Salman-Isha's Sunday performance and Deepak-Rashmi's Saturday performance. 👏

I agree about Rashmi's scoring. I also thought it was a bit lenient on the Sunday's perfromance. I thought it was 8 at best. I think she is a fabulous dancer. But that particular performance getting 27 was not justified in my point of view.