Did the 30 go to the right contestant?

Page

Next Last

maya

@coolfire

Voyager

Posted: 12 years ago

Before I begin, I'd like to put a disclaimer out there that I am not a huge fan of any ONE of the contestants to be biased. I just enjoy good performances.

I seriously felt that today's 30 was misplaced. While Isha and Salman showed a great performance, and the theme was hatke, it didn't have the extra wow factor that demands a 30 these days. (As these days the judges have become quite stingy with their marks, if you've noticed.)

Whereas Rithwik's performance was not only great and had a hatke theme, but it had a soul to it. The sadness of broken relationships affecting childhood and present relationships was portrayed really well. It was moving, and I felt for the story. Even Karan said that this was one of the best themes of Jhalak. In my opinion the judges stole a well deserving 30 from them. I think even the judges felt that as they gave the best couple of the week's title to Rithwik and Sneha instead of Isha-Salman, who scored more than them.

What do you guys think? Was the 30 misplaced? Did the judges make a mistake this time on whom to give the stellar act accolade?

Quote

Frequent Posters

style14

@style14

Elite

+ 5

Posted: 12 years ago

I too loved Rithvik's performance today.. it was really touching... but may be Judges now expect a lot more from him to give him 30. Remo said so himself that just a little bit was missing for "This is it" and I respect his decision.. I hope next week RD gets his 30 again...

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Arnav90

@Arnav90

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 12 years ago

I think it was completely fair, Isha n Salman had gd concept, awesom dance n amazing chemistry, And i wanna say Isha is back, this is what i was also missing from last 2 weeks... Ritwik n Sneha was also bang on in every factor but they little bit miscordinated in their sitting step, But they got highest in total which is totally deserving..

Quote

Shruti

@Shru77

Dazzler

+ 4

Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: Arnav90
I think it was completely fair, Isha n Salman had gd concept, awesom dance n amazing chemistry, And i wanna say Isha is back, this is what i was also missing from last 2 weeks... Ritwik n Sneha was also bang on in every factor but they little bit miscordinated in their sitting step, But they got highest in total which is totally deserving..

yup.. agreed... Isha n Salman really deserved 30

Quote

siya803

@siya803

Voyager

Posted: 12 years ago

i really loved isha salman's act. but the theme was back to childhood. everyone danced with that theme ...but beauty nd d beast???? 😕

Quote

Binge

@Binge

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

Even I felt so! Infact, I thought even Rashmi's act deserved a 10 for the lifts that they had.. but yes, RD-Sneha's act not only catered into an untouched arena but was also executed well. Judges were quite strict in the beginning and later when they gave Isha a 10, I deffo felt something was wrong. Isha's performance was good but so were the other two!

Edited by Binge - 12 years ago

Quote

kyra22

@kyra22

Inactive

Posted: 12 years ago

Thy r well deserved 30 ... Ritvik & sneha got best couple due to there total is more den Isha & Salman ,... if u compare bth act ...

Quote

Rose_7

@Rose_7

Explorer

Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: siya803
i really loved isha salman's act. but the theme was back to childhood. everyone danced with that theme ...but beauty nd d beast???? 😕

Beauty and the Beast because it's a children's fairytale 😊

Quote

Rapier

@Rapier

Rocker

Posted: 12 years ago

Well no one "stole" any 30s from anyone to give it to Isha-Salman. You speak as if they are allowed to give out only one 30. Isha-Salman deserved their 30 and yes, I also feel that Rithwik-Sneha should've gotten a 30 as well. But like I said, just because Rithwik deserved a 30 and didn't get one, does not mean that Isha didn't deserve the 30 she got. Both performances were very good. So to answer your question, yes the 30 did go to the right contestant. However, more than one contestant deserved a 30.

Quote

lilymily

@lilymily

Navigator

Posted: 12 years ago

#10

I personally didn't feel that Isha-Salman's performance 'Beauty & Beast' was worth 30.

Honestly, i felt that they were bit off the theme. You usually don't relate Beauty and beast with your childhood memories. So for me the judges should have deducted their marks for going off the track (concept)

Quote

1 2 3 4 5 6

Did the 30 go to the right contestant?

Related Topics

Explore Topics