IP REDUX; Kahaani !!!

Today I will start my analysis with what I have written in "Nemesis" on Aug 3^rd.

Excerpts from Nemesis analysis:-

The wedding is destined to happen SOMEDAY but I loved when Arnav said in the morning of 5^th day (8 days left) - "Humari baat abhi khatam nehin hui" and Khushi sobbed - "aise laga jaise humari saansein ruk gayi ho". For me it was Arnav saying - "Humari KAHAANI abhi khatam nehin hui" and Khushi's sobbing meant - "Breathtaking History". Yes, 8 is the number of salvation, new beginning, rebirth or resurrection. Hence, now since the story of scattered pearls have ended, we are entering the story of "Scattered Chanas" and the unveiling of the incidents involved in the story will take the breath away from Khushi.

SHOGUN:- What is Shogun??? It is "General" who subdues barbarians; It is also the "De facto Ruler" as in a "Caretaker" on behalf of the legal person; it is also defined as the "Commander-in-Chief". They are the warriors cum administrators. In the Japanese history, after 1868, when the shogunate was terminated the ruling power was returned to the emperor. A Shogun's office is always meant to be "Temporary" until the "Ruler" comes and takes it over. A Shogun has always the good purpose to eradicate and fight against the "Evil" and that is why Shogun is called a "Saraathi, Krishna, Commander ' in ' Chief".

"Aaj 2 saal baad Metro durghatna mein jo maare gaye unkein parivaar walon ko jawaab mila hain ... Kabhi kabhi Devtaoon se bhi Galati ho jaati hain ... Devtaaon ne Asur ko banaya aur unhein sakti di par jab woh un sakti ka galat istemaal karne lage, toh Devtaoon ne Maa Durga ko banaya. Rakshashon ko khatam karne ke liye ... kehtein hain sab Maa'on ke taqat ko mila kar "Durga Maa" ko banaya gaya ... har saal Maa aati hain, sab buraayi mitati hain aur wapas chali jaati hain ... taaki hum sab bina kisi darr ke khushi aur shanti se jee sake" ~ Kahaani

Khan:- Kaun thi yeh Mrs. Bagchi???

Rana:- Vidya Bagchi Ek Kahaani thi, Sir

Khan:- Matlab???

Khan:- Aur uska husband Arnab ???

Rana:- Aacha toh aap abhi tak samjhe nahi, Sir???

Rana:- "Apne ne shuru mein unhein ek Kahaani sunayi aur unhone bhi shuru mein humme Ek Kahaani sunayi".

Rana:- Milind Damji toh tha Sir. Naa koi Vidya Bagchi hai, naa koi Arnab jinki shakl Milind se milti ho.

Khan:- Aur Satyaki kaun hain???

Rana:- Main hoon Sir [Flash Back: Satyaki, Arjun ka Saraathi].

Khan:- Lekin usse bheja kisne tha aur usne humaari madat kyun ki ???

Who was this Mrs. Vidya Bagchi??? What was her Kahaani ??? The movie started with one kahaani (story) that Vidya narrated to the cops. There was then another kahaani narrated by the cops to Vidya. Vidya was helped by one kind and noble hearted Police Inspector, Satyaki Sinha (Rana). In a conversation when Vidya enquired Rana about his name, he replied with "Satyaki". Then Vidya promptly answered back - "Arjun ka Saraathi". Did anyone notice that screenplay??? Vidya filed a complaint at the police station and since she was pregnant the station head asked Rana to accompany her to the hotel where she was supposed to be staying. Rana was driving the police car and this is when Vidya was asking him about his name and she replied that his name implies - "Charioteer (Saraathi) of Arjun". This was the beginning of the "War". The story of the movie was decided then in that scene with defining "Vidya as Arjun" and "Rana as Saraathi". To win a war one needs a very prominent "Commander-in-Chief" and that person was "Retd. Colonel Bajpai" to Vidya Bagchi. Since Colonel Bajpai couldn't be Vidya's charioteer in person, she needed one and that is where "Inspector Rana" fits in. But at the end what happened??? At the end, we come to know Vidya's kahaani was "Genuinely" fake but Khan (Cops)'s kahaani was "Prepared" to be fake but Vidya produced and acted her genuine fake kahaani in such a way which had no "Faults" but to believe it's the "Truth". Police later on realized that "who" they thought of pawning all along, in reality used them as a "Pawn". Police sketched a "Plan" to use Vidya and get to the "Criminal" where as they had no idea of getting "Used" by the same Vidya to seek revenge from the same "Criminal". At last she did, and we know her "Kahaani" - "A Mother of a Story". Vidya Bagchi Ek Kahaani thi.

Many of you might have watched Kahaani, yet I narrated the summary above just so you get acquainted with the analysis and can get the essence of what I will be talking today. Let's get back to my analysis - Nemesis now. That episode was when ASR solved the story of "Scattered Pearls" and the past knocked at their door. Yes, that day when ASR turned to Khushi, I quoted ASR meant - "Humari KAHAANI abhi khatam nehin hui" and Khushi sobbed as if her role of becoming "Arjun" have started with the "Breathtaking History" knocking at her door. Yes, Kahaani indeed. A Mother of a Story.

In the world of IPK there are many such small Kahaanis floating around. Some are true, some are fake; some are half baked where as some are prepared to fake. Exactly like Daadi asked ASR - "Yeh Kahaani pakki hain"??? and ASR answered - "Yeh koi kahaani nehin, sach hain". Which one is true??? The one ASR narrated or the one Daadi prepared??? The one Shyam made up or the one Khushi was told??? The one Chachaji narrated or the one Garimaji knows??? Anyone have any idea??? I'll tell you the KAHAANI.

We all know the truth of ASR's Dad, ASR's Mom, Shyam's Sister and Chachaji. Isn't it??? Before I move on I'll just touch slowly on Chachaji part. In my analysis, I have always proved Chachaji have double crossed both ASR's Dad and Shyam's Sister. On Thursday NK said - "Jawab hum kar rahein sawaal tum doge". We have ASR corrected him - "Ulta bolo, jawaab is answer and sawaal is question". There you go with the interrogation for the future when ASR will question about the truth we will have the "Answer" directly from horse's mouth. The truth is with Chachaji as he said - "Jo sach hain wohi moonch hain". The entire gameplan that was planned by Chachaji will be revealed and ofcourse he have to be in prison. Didn't NK say - "Aur main bhi kapde badal ke so jaata hoon ' mujhe nennee aa rahi hain"??? This was followed by Anjali's - "Pyaar mein sab badal jaate hain" and we will have ASR turning to Arnav Malik in love when he will be "Smart" enough to realize the truth of everything where the interrogation with Chachaji will happen. But, the question is what Chachaji did??? As I have said earlier that ASR's Dad didn't commit suicide but he was murdered by Chachaji or was instigated to commit suicide by Chachaji. How??? We have the siblings, Arnav and Anjali on thursday when Arnav asked Anjali about the pills. Anjali replied - "Nivarak jaise ... Prevention". Chachaji wanted to prevent what??? Didn't Shyam's Sister intrude Anjali's Wedding??? Yes, she did and that is when ASR's Mom committed suicide and we have seen how in the previous analysis. But ASR tried to manage the situation as we have seen. Didn't ASR say to Daadi the other day - "tab se main sab kuch thik karne ki koshish kar raha hoon"??? What ASR said to Anjali on Thursday??? He took the promise from Anjali that is she doesn't take care of her health then the wedding rituals will be cancelled and so the same manipulation happened years back by Chachaji to ASR's Dad. The answer we have is Chachaji tried to prevent the truth which he can succeed only if ASR's Dad become "Silent". Doesn't it prove - "Jo sach hain wohi monch hain"??? I loved how NK showed the moustache here and Chachaji and Shashiji wear one. Both of them know the "Crude" truth, isn't it???

So, we have even Chachaji truth completed. But still we have many Kahaanis to be unveiled, isn't it??? We need to know Khushi's truth, Daadi's truth, Garimaji's truth and Shyam's truth. All the entire past depend on these truths. Very interesting, isn't it??? All the more interesting things are the kahaanis which are weaved in and around these characters. Let us see all the kahaanis.

Why Daadi said to Arnav - "Kya yeh kahaani pakki hain"??? Which Kahaani??? Of course the one Arnav said. According to him, "Garima Aunty Payal ki Mom hain ... Shashi Uncle ne bahut time pehle unse shaadi ki thi ... aur Payal unki asli beti hain ". So, here we also know that when Khushi's Parents died in a car accident she was adopted by them and since then Khushi stayed with her "Masa and Maasi". This was the version of ASR's Kahaani about Khushi, isn't it??? Let us cross check this version, shall we???

When I watched ASR's Version of the story, the only thing that I could sense was Daadi's happiness. You know why??? Because, she was confident that what "Kahaani" she made of "Garimaji" is proved by non-other than her grandson. Yes, unknowingly ASR delivered the information just what Daadi wanted to hear. 15 years back the Kahaani that Daadi "Prepared" to make believe have actually worked to her favor. Why will she meet Garimaji then??? This is the reason she said - "Aap unke bare mein bahut kuch jaante ho, hum kal unhein shagun ke waqt milenge". Interesting, isn't it???

Khushi is 23 years old right now and Garimaji brought Khushi to Gupta house 11 years back. But how is it possible if she was married to Shashiji long back and Payal is their "Asli" daughter??? Where was Khushi in between 11 years and 15 years??? We know Khushi was 8 years old when her Parents' died in the car crash and that is 15 years back from now. In the second episode of IPK, when Khushi returned from Seesh Mahal that fateful night, we have Buaji accusing Garimaji of bringing Khushi into this household 10 years back (now 11years after 1 yr of IPK journey). Buaji said that day in her own words - "agar tum 10 saal pehle apni jiji ki beti ko naa uthai laati toh aaj ee naubat nehin aati". WOW. So, we have 4 yrs of Khushi's life "Unknown to us" and we know Garimaji was with Khushi always and she brought Khushi home when she got married to Shashiji, a widower with a daughter, Payal, 11 years back. So, this is the real "Kahaani" of Khushi and Garimaji which obviously ASR isn't aware of.

Now, what about Daadi's Kahaani??? What about the accident??? What about the "Missing 4 years of Khushi's whereabouts"??? What about her "interaction" with Garimaji??? Lets see what happened then. The "Kahaani" was framed when Khushi's Parents died in a car accident caused by the Mailks that fateful night. Garimaji was the only relative the 8 year old Khushi had with her. That night it was Garimaji who became the "Shogun" for Khushi on bealf of her "Parents". Yes, the "Caretaker". It did got involved in a "Police case" like I said the day Daadi came to RM and we had Naani and ASR coming back and ASR said - "hum police ko inform kar dete hain" where in Naani negated that offer. Remember in that analysis, I said switch the characters of Naani and Daadi there??? Let me paste the excerpts from that analysis to save me from typing . Here you go from "Ksheera Sagar" of Aug 8^th.

Excerpts from "Ksheera Sagar" of Aug 8^th:-

Let me take you again on Monday as I promised when Khushi greeted Daadiji with the "Dirty Water". How did Khushi slip it??? She saw the Lizard. You know what Lizard symbolizes??? I'll tell you. They are cold blooded animal and they signify in Roman culture "Death" and "Resurrection". They are also "Homeless" or "Parasites". They live in other's houses. Due to their scurrying natures, quick pace and lightning reaction times, the lizard is considered the consummate escape artist. This makes them symbolic of our ability to recognize danger and remove ourselves from harm's way when the situation calls for it.

Yes, that scene was for both Khushi and Shyam's Sister. I have explained Shyam's Sister and now I'll talk about Khushi. Yes, I'll confirm here that "Daadiji is responsible for Khushi to be an Orphan". The day Daadiji entered Raizada Mansion, then it was "8days left" for her wedding to be over and Khushi was 8 years old when she lost her Parents. Daadi left for Ashram 15 years back and today Khushi's ages is 23 years. (15+8 = 23). Isn't it interesting??? Now come to Tuesday's episode. We have Naani and ASR entering when ASR said - "police ko inform kar dete hain". That scene we have mentioned Naani and Daadi switched places and here we go. We have NK saying to Maami just before Daadiji's arrival that - "Maasiji par aapke TAARA itna high kyun hain"??? and Maamiji answered - "taara nehin paara". Yes, the "para" of Garimaji will be high when she will face "Daadiji".It has to be. That night Khushi lost her parents and her Parents became "Stars (Taara)" and they were placed high above. The reason of Khushi losing her parents is ASR's Dad and Daadiji as they are someway responsible.

Now the kahaani took a turn in a different way. Daadi and Dad realized Garimaji is the only support of Khushi and to save their reputation they decided to make a "Deal" with Garimaji. It is then the "Proposal" of alliance for Chachaji went to Garimaji but there was a "Twist" in the tale. Well before I move to the twist here goes NK's - "Aakash bhai aur Payal bhabhi kahan hain, kitne gifts packing karna hain"??? Remember, what he said on Wednesday??? Yeah and today he said - "Shogun ki thaal ready hain naa" ??? and we have Payal corrected - "Shagun ki thaal". Who is "Shogun" here??? Of course "Garimaji". Hence, here goes the deal by Daadi and ASR's Dad to keep Garimaji quiet and close the "Police Case". But did Garimaji know that??? No and that is why we have Shagun and Haldi done by Maliks. Remember today Buaji and Maamiji's repeat shagun and repeat haldi??? But did they say repeat Sangeet??? No. Buaji corrected what happened in Sangeet that won't be repeated again. So, what exactly happened after "Haldi ceremony" and why the wedding then was called off??? Read me on.

It is after the haldi, Garimaji realized the "Deal" that Daadi wanted to propose. It was Khushi to be sent to an "Orphanage" and Garimaji to be married into Malik family in exchange of withdrawing the "Police Case". What did Maami say today??? She said - "Phatti saree ki shaadi toh EMI mein hui hain, Easy Monthly Installments, every 6 months".Did Garimaji accept the offer??? NO. of course not. She is "Garima". A dignified lady. She is the "Corn Mother". She refused the proposal of getting married into Malik family and certainly not in the family who took away her "Khushi's Parents".

You know why NK said to ASR today - "Hum confused hoke kisi aur ladki ko shagun nehin denge"??? I'll tell you. Because the "Shagun" went for a "Shogun". A woman who have a daughter of 8 years calling her "Amma". Why Garimaji is called a "Shogun" here??? The reason is she is "Caretaker", a "de-facto" ruler on behalf of her real Parents. But why NK said that??? Remember all this happened 15 years back when ASR's Dad was also involved with Shyam's Sister and she was pregnant with his child. Another "Stigmatized" Lady. Why Stigmatized??? Do you think Daadi took the refusal lightly and being a traditional and orthodox woman she will not save her family's reputation??? Of course she will. But now what??? She needed to make a "Kahaani". How??? Here you go.

Garimaji is Khushi's Maasi but she was called "Amma" by her always and here is where Daadi's dialogue to Naaniji fits in. She said on Thursday - "Woh jaante bhi nehin hain ki uss ladki ke Maa Baap kaun hain" ??? which girl and why her parents??? Daadi's question was for Khushi and the moment Naaniji informed about "Garimaji" her face defined both fear and joy. Why fear and why joy??? If Daadi knew Garimaji from her early days then why the question about her Parents will even arise??? Isn't it??? This is because 15 years back a lady who stood up against the 3 wealthy rich people just for the sake of this "Orphan" was unable to prove the relation she has with this "Orphan". The first question was raised why that girl will call her "Amma"??? why not "Maasi". For heaven's sake she was an unmarried woman and having a daughter who calls her Amma. In this situation what will the "society" name her??? Is it so easy in the rural parts of India, those days to survive the stigma??? It is not easy even in these days. When Daadi went to meet Buaji at Guptas she blamed Khushi of "Stigma" didn't she??? She blamed Khushi of framing and dreaming to get married to an affluent family. Isn't it??? The same thing was said about Garimaji that day just because she chose "Khushi" over her wedding and a happy married life. Yes, this is the reason she said - "Ussi ghar mein jawat hain aur hum??? Hum yeh kaise hone de sakat hain". Her apprehension when she prayed to God - "Ek bacchi ko toh biha diya uss ghar mein aur Khushi humari choti bacchi wapas Arnav bitwa ke saath shaadi karat hain" was so appropriate. Garimaji couldn't even share with Buaji or Shashiji and that is why her - "Hum yeh kisse batayein... Kaise Bataiye"??? Of course can you believe how the situation must have been for her that she had to marry a "Widower" with a daughter ??? Daadi accused her that time of Khushi being her illegit child because she refused to send Khushi to "Orphanage" and rejected the "Deal" of withdrawing the Police Case. That day what Daadi framed of Garimaji's character, on Thursday, ASR crystalized that belief but saying - "Sashi Uncle ne unse bahut din pehle shaadi kit hi and Payal unke asli beti hain". But my question is whose "Asli" beti??? Garimaji's or Shashiji's??? Yes, Shashiji's and not Garimaji's. This is why we have seen Daadi's first reaction when she saw and heard "Khushi's name", isn't it??? This is the reason Daadi said to ASR - "Aap unke bare me bahut kuch jaante ho, hum unhein kal shagun ke waqt milenge". Yes, she knew it pretty well that if not she, then Garimaji herself will reject the alliance of ASR and Khushi because how can she get Khushi married to the house who have taken away her "Parents"???Interesting Kahaani by Daadi isn't it???

Now let us see what happened after Garimaji was stigmatized by Daadi and family. What happened in those 4 years??? For a unmarried woman and a Mother to rasie a child alone in the society is like a challenge but still Garimaji lived up to her name and she faced all the challenges of the society and as a Mother she is still trying to save Khushi from the "Impending Storm". I loved the screenplay here. Did you notice the "Pickle Jar" on the table even after we finished Shyam's Sister story??? The continuation in the screenplay in FANTASTIC. The same way we had the "Cucumber" on Wednesday implying the "preservation of life" which Garimaji had undertaken since the Khushi came into her life. When Daadi was supposed to meet her the time was 11 pm and it was 5 days left for the contract. Isn't it fantastic???

Number 11 denotes - Imperfection, disorder, Incompleteness and it is also the number which follows "Judgment". Yes, the judgment is coming soon and Garimaji's "Blemishfree" character will be wiped away by non other than Arnav Singh Raizada as Buaji said - "Arnav Bitwa aa rahein hain naa, sab thik kar denge". Look at the Irony??? Daadi was about to come but ASR's half baked "Kahaani" changed her mind just because she thought this will help her "Prepared Fake Kahaani" to be true. Just like Vidya Bagchi in Kahaani we will have Daadi using ASR's Kahaani to prove her "Fake Kahaani" to be true which in turn will lead to the "Actual Truth", isn't it???

What is the truth??? Truth is after 4 years of the accident Garimaji married Shashiji, a "Widower" with a daughter, Payal and provided Khushi a "Legal Name and Life" and she raised Payal and Khushi as her own. Didn't Maamiji say today - "ee raha Payal aur Khushi ke Refugee Camp"??? Garimaji sacrificed her whole life just to raise her "choti bacchi" Khushi along with her another "bitiya" Payal. Can you believe what a GREAT LADY she is??? This is her "Kahaani". The Truth.

This is when ASR will call her "Amma" for she is Garima, she is a Dignified Lady and above all she is the "Corn Mother".

There is one more Kahaani we have here and that is the "Kahaani" of Shyam Manohar Jha. I have already described multiple times about the story of Shyam and his Sister, right??? But did I ever tell you why he entered and how he entered??? No. Though you all know this. Before I proceed let me take you to one of my Analysis of July 25^th where I have mentioned that Shyam might not be his "Real Name"but this is the name we know of him as of now; real or not time will tell.

I thank Sandhya for helping me extracting this old analysis and Bush for the picture. Thank You.

Excerpts from July 25^th analysis ' Aurora Borealis :-

Once there was a woman who had a niece, not blood related but she was her only niece. Her Niece was married to an affluent family, the Maliks. Her Niece's husband was not a very good person who always have been an obstacle for her to visit her "Buaji".Yes, the niece is non-other than Arnav and Anjali's Mom. Her Buaji have a son and a daughter. We don't know the daughter's name yet but her son's name is "Shyam", at least we know THIS name. The daughter's age will be around 20 years, then.

I have said in Nemesis Anlaysis that Shyam's Sister made her brother study "Law" so that she can seek providence and I also said that the entire "Revenge" will be her master plan. Isn't it???

In Kahaani who was the masterplanner??? Yes, he was "Retd. Colonel Bajpai, isn't it???But the "Arjun" was Vidya Bagchi and the "Sarathi" was Rana. Same here Shyam Manohar Jha needed needed a "Sarathi" and that for him was "Khushi". But did Khushi become Sarathi for him from the very first day??? No. Never. The first day Shyam saved Khushi from humiliation and you know why??? Because we go back in history then his Sister was also humiliatied the same way like Khushi and the trigger was the "Maliks ". Yes, that day because of one Malik, Khushi was humiliated and Shyam saved her just because he have seen his sister gone through the same turmoil. He saved Khushi and her Parents that day but why did he change??? How did Khushi become his "Sarathi"??? It was when Khushi rejected him and fell for the man who and his Dad sabotaged Shyam's Sister's life. It is the same family and same history that was repeating itself. But is Shyam good??? No he is NOT. He definitely is man with a mission but he cannot be good because he not only sabotaged Anjali's life, he also stigmatized Khushi's life just to save himself for the mission that he is carrying. He is not just but then again he is "Arjun" for his "Sister" and this is the reason he needed a "Charioteer" and that is "Khushi" for him. Shyam entered with a "Fake Kahaani" and now he is using Khushi's "untrue Kahaani" to reach to his "Goal" and that is "ASR and Anjali". Who is he using "Indirectly"??? Daadi and Anjali. Yes, now Shyam is using Daadi's "Fake Kahaani" of Garimaji and her daughter to reach to his goal and his untilmate goal is "Naming his Sister's Babies". Who is the Colonel Bajpai here??? Yes, Shyam's Sister.

Shyam needed a charioteer and that is "Khushi" and on the other hand Khushi's charioteer is non other than "ASR" because ASR is the "Commander-in-Chief", Nand Kishore, Krishna.

Milind Damji toh tha Sir. Naa koi Vidya Bagchi hai, naa koi Arnab jinki shakl Milind se milti ho. There is atleast Arnav Malik (Raizada), Anjali Malik (Raizada - Jha), Khushi Gupta (Maiden Name) BUT There was NO Vidya Bagchi and there is NO Shyam Manohar Jha.

"Kehtein hain sab Maa'on ke taqat ko mila kar "Durga Maa" ko banaya gaya ... har saal Maa aati hain, sab buraayi mitati hain aur wapas chali jaati hain ... taaki hum sab bina kisi darr ke khushi aur shanti se jee sake" ~ Kahaani

Yes all the Mothers - ASR's Mom, Khushi's Mom, Garimaji, Anjali and Shyam's Sister made "Vidya Venkatesan - Basu" and she is the Arjun here, "Khushi Kumari Gupta" with Arnav Singh Raizada as her "Sarathi (Charioteer), Krishna, Commander-in-Chief".

Didn't Buaji say to Garimaji -"Nand Kishore aur Davi Maiyaan sab thik kar denge"???

Remember what I mentioned on Aug 8th in my Analysis "Ksheera Sagar" when Khushi received the "Conch" by ASR's Mom???

Here goes the Excerpts from that analysis of Aug 8th :-

"Devdatta". This was the name of "Arjun's Conch" whose triumphant blast brought terror to the enemy. This is also the name of Gautam Buddha's brother. What is the meaning of Devdatta??? Devdatta means - "Gift from God". What a perfect gift to Khushi by her Mother-in-law. By the end of this analysis you all will learn why I began with this "Conch".

• How true it was... when Mami said that it was ek par ek free marriage... Khushi did come as Payal's dowry...I only wish if Mami & others knew what she said is true...
• NK assured Arnav that they will give Shagun to Khushi only and not some other girl... Did Dadi got Sr. Malik married in such a manner where he thought the shagun was going for one and went to another... sounds silly and the plot is repeated so many times in shows...but it is possible.