why did Ashaji kinda snub about OP Nayyar

Page

Next Last

apus fan

@sami01

Sparkler

+ 5

Posted: 13 years ago

what I was disapointed about saturday was Asha ji couldn't say 2 words about person who made her star --- that was OP NAYYar

person who made ashaji what she is today

and sunidhi was no right person to talk about shanakar jai kishan by giving example of a song composed by hritik roshan's grand dad roshan

i was so disapointed by fact taht there was no naushad tribute for 50s... madan mohan was good but naushad was a must they needed naushad and c ramachandran included in 50s... i am so upset with indian idol and Ashaji was so rude about OP Nayyar whatever reasons were about their split she stil owes him a lot

Quote

Frequent Posters

IamSwapnali

@IamSwapnali

Inactive

Posted: 13 years ago

I have not watched the episode, but I guess this all started couple of years ago..

I don't recall what the occasion was, but O.P.Nayyar mentioned that it was him to taught Asha to sing. She couldn't even say 'aaa..' earlier. And she used to feel very inferior because of Lata. I think he even went to an extent to say that Lata & Asha's maid was the same, and everyday the maid would tell Asha what kind of song Lata has been recording, which gave her the complex, and it was him to helped her boost her confidence.

I think this is how is started. Even if O.P. Nayyar helped her, I think this was too much to say about Asha at this stage, when both of them have accomplished so much. I mean him saying that he taught her everything is still OK, but what's the point in giving away so many details (whether true or false) now?

Few days after this incidence, there was an interview of Asha, and her answer to one question was that 'I am what I am because of all my music directors, and not any particular one'.

Whatever the truth is, the songs made by these two are too good, and I enjoy them even today!

Edited by ILoveHussain - 13 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

apus fan

@sami01

Sparkler

+ 5

Posted: 13 years ago

am not aware of any such interview but i recall one where he said there could be no singer like Asha ji in 300 years. her words were very bad for a person who is not even alive

Quote

music-a-muse

@music-a-muse

Dazzler

Posted: 13 years ago

Sami, am even surprised she commented about him. was expecting more on that episode. Damp squib it was.

I did not expect anything better. 😊

Quote

apus fan

@sami01

Sparkler

+ 5

Posted: 13 years ago

ya i know so sad yaar but how could they forget Naushad when they gave 50s tribute...was the reason that ?Naushad and Asha have not done many songs together

Quote

music-a-muse

@music-a-muse

Dazzler

Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: sami01
ya i know so sad yaar but how could they forget Naushad when they gave 50s tribute...was the reason that ?Naushad and Asha have not done many songs together

Are you not glad they did not murder naushads songs too😊

I think they chose the more popular, faster paced songs.

Indian idol thought they were being good by choosing the golden oldies, unfortunately, the singers they chose did not have the calibre to sing those wonderful songs.😊

Quote

apus fan

@sami01

Sparkler

+ 5

Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: musicmuse

Are you not glad they did not murder naushads songs too😊

I think they chose the more popular, faster paced songs.

Indian idol thought they were being good by choosing the golden oldies, unfortunately, the singers they chose did not have the caliber to sing those wonderful songs.😊

lol so true yaar bec naushad songs r very difficult to sing but they should have at least used a word or 2 for some legends like naushad/c ramachandran... two of top hit films of Indian cinema ever had naushad music... mughle azam and mother India

Quote

tina

@tina59

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 13 years ago

Asha's ji though a tremendous singer and a legend, am sorry to say as an indivisual, she is highly arrogant.

Her bias towards singers and her staunch opposition towards new compositions are not praiseworthy.

Its very muich true that Asha and Lata were not on good terms and there were ego clashes between them when both were at their peak. It was all later sorted out and they became one again which is wonderful.

I also happen to recall an article which was posted during a season of SA re ga ma and Asha ji was one of the special judges and it was said that she used to hold up shootings bcoz her necklace wouldnt match her saree and for small small issues esp regarding her outfits where everything had to match.

I love asha's songs and singing more than Lata's but personality wise, asha ranks very low in my books

Quote

prerna4rishav

@prerna4rishav

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: tina59

I also happen to recall an article which was posted during a season of SA re ga ma and Asha ji was one of the special judges and it was said that she used to hold up shootings bcoz her necklace wouldnt match her saree and for small small issues esp regarding her outfits where everything had to match.

😕 Even Karan Johar cancels shooting when he himself is not dressed up properly or his tie doesnt match his suit Does that make him arrogant ? It's the star-mood thing which every individual in Bolly has ..

Anyways coming to the topic, I agree with the article of O.P.Nayar saab.. He doesnt own any singer.. 😊 And if we do something for others, we shouldnt keep blowing our own trumpet 😛

Ashaji is not God.. She too can hold grudge against someone.. At least she is not faking it.. 😊 I dont think singers like Lata, Asha, Kishore are 'mautaaj' of music director's find and all.. Sooner or later, they all will sign 😛

Quote

IamSwapnali

@IamSwapnali

Inactive

Posted: 13 years ago

#10

Originally posted by: tina59
Asha's ji though a tremendous singer and a legend, am sorry to say as an indivisual, she is highly arrogant.

Her bias towards singers and her staunch opposition towards new compositions are not praiseworthy.

Its very muich true that Asha and Lata were not on good terms and there were ego clashes between them when both were at their peak. It was all later sorted out and they became one again which is wonderful.

I also happen to recall an article which was posted during a season of SA re ga ma and Asha ji was one of the special judges and it was said that she used to hold up shootings bcoz her necklace wouldnt match her saree and for small small issues esp regarding her outfits where everything had to match.

I love asha's songs and singing more than Lata's but personality wise, asha ranks very low in my books

I also like Asha's singing more than Lata's. About Lata & Asha's rivalry, I heard in one of the old interviews of Lata that it was mainly due to Asha's husband (Mr. Bhosale). He did not like her meeting with Lata or rest of the Mangeshkar's. Things started getting better after their divorce.

About being arrogant, I think very few celebrities can stay away from it after achieving so much. Even in the past, Lata & Asha tried their best and used their influence so that no other female singers could establish in the industry.

Actually both Asha & Lata have earlier criticized the singing reality shows and ironically both appeared as judges later... I enjoyed watching II5 and had started watching II6 too, but lost interest very early. Now I just come to the forum to read if there are any updates... I was trying to think what could be the reason behind me not enjoying the show this time, and started wondering if it could be because of Asha, because rest of the judges are the same and I liked them last year..

Quote

1 2

why did Ashaji kinda snub about OP Nayyar

Related Topics

Explore Topics