Indian Idol Should Just END Now.

Shaitan-Haiwan thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail 13th Anniversary Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 13 years ago
#1
Honestly, this show has become a joke and a disgrace. I really honestly hope that it gets cancelled and it never airs another season again. I thought after the disaster that was Season 5, this show would not renew or come again. But no...Indian Idol has returend and is more awful than ever.
Its so obvious that the final three is going to be Dev-Vipul and Poorvi and its pretty obvious Poorvi is going to win because of the judges obession over her. She cant even sing properly and they claim she is the best thing. I am even shocked that she was even selected in the first place, and she gets to stay over Ritika? Thats even more of a disgrace.
Obviously this show is not about singing.
W*F is wrong with the judges? Why does Sunidhi always say the opposite of everyone? Im damn sure its intentional adn then Salim runs along to support her. Asha always has a different view and then Anu is kabhi yahan kabhi wahan.
I am so done with this show, I just want it to end so I could watch KBC instead.
Please Indian Idol, DO NOT Come back with Season-7. We have been tortured enough.

Created

Last reply

Replies

9

Views

1.7k

Users

9

Likes

16

Frequent Posters

gayatri.143 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
Uhm Just because you don't agree with the results, it does not mean that they should end Indian Idol. :|
Reetika has a beautiful voice but she dId mess up the songs yesterday infact in chikni chameli it sounded as if she was yellin at several points. So the results are fine an the judges were right. Everyone is pin pointing poorvi bcoz the judges favor her a lot & bcoz shes only best at western. I dont see whats wrong with that bcoz no one else os that versatile either. They cant sing as western as poorvi and poorvi cant sing indian songs too well either. So its best if people accept the results instead of making an issue out of it just becoz it isnt what they want the results to be as. I hope i didn't sound rude coz i didnt mean to, i just wanted to put this out there.
acjbmb01 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#3
I agree that this season hasn't been that great, but I still have hope in Devender and Vipul. Hope one of them becomes Indian Idol. And I wouldnt mind if we get a Season 7 as long as the judges are a different set (not Anu Malik again please!).
kadami thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#4
It does not matter who is judge but there are many categories in song to give points which can prove talent of a singer if marking is honest.''

There should be one qualified judge who supervise the wrong action of Judges. Then, Judges must be replaced.

They are keeping dust because they have decided it before the show is started.

Next time, they should keep all other singer worst than the dust one so that there would be less disappointment.
Shaitan-Haiwan thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail 13th Anniversary Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 13 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: gayatri.143

Uhm Just because you don't agree with the results, it does not mean that they should end Indian Idol. :|
Reetika has a beautiful voice but she dId mess up the songs yesterday infact in chikni chameli it sounded as if she was yellin at several points. So the results are fine an the judges were right. Everyone is pin pointing poorvi bcoz the judges favor her a lot & bcoz shes only best at western. I dont see whats wrong with that bcoz no one else os that versatile either. They cant sing as western as poorvi and poorvi cant sing indian songs too well either. So its best if people accept the results instead of making an issue out of it just becoz it isnt what they want the results to be as. I hope i didn't sound rude coz i didnt mean to, i just wanted to put this out there.

I completely disagree. This show is all about versatility. Why else do you think they would have a "versatile" round and make contestants sing 2-3 songs of different moods in the same performance? Obviously Versatility is a important aspect of the song. Its kind of implied.
WIth that said, yes, the show lacks versatility this season. But Some contestants ARE more versatile than others. Ritika is surely more versatile than Poorvi. Ritika has also sang many "different" songs and been appreciated. One Chikni Chameli, and shes gone. Completely unfair.
The boys seem to be more versatile than Poorvi as well (I think any singer is more versatile than her)
There is a reason why so many people hate Poorvi. It's not because she can only sing "one-type" of songs or that the judges love her. People hate her because she is an extremely AVERAGE singer and the fact that she is the least versatile from everyone. Many people have left the show who are more deserving to be there than her. She isn't even TOP 20 material. There were so many girls in the auditions who were far better.
And just to clarify, I am not saying the show should end because I disagree with the result. That may be apart of the reason. But I am mainly saying that because, well, the show overall sucks. I think many people will agree with me on this.
Edited by DIDfan89 - 13 years ago
suresh555 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#6
I totally agree with DIDFan89

This show is a total disgrace and is becoming openly shameless as the weeks go by

The judges results first

Dev
Poorvi
Vipul
Amit
Ritika

Judges & (invisible) audience bottom 2
Amit
Ritika

Wow, what a coincidence

The judges actually think that we believe that Poorvi deserved to be # 2

Amit who had the best performance with the Dabanng number is # 4? (even Katrina said this was the best performance that evening)

OK, lets move to today's tribute

Devender hogged the majority of the songs followed by Vipul while Amit got to sing one song "Raimaiya vasta vaiya" They did that to Charit and Amitabh too earlier.

Do they think by shoving Dev in our faces the audience will be manipulated? Then the repeated nautanki of Dev and gopiyas in Idol goes to Pune and Idol goes to Udaipur etc etc etc. Honestly the overdose of Dev is very annoying to me (I know it's not Dev's fault, but the channel and or judges). I have yet to see a contestant so openly promoted before a contest ends. And after whatever airtime is left over from Dev darshan, Poorvi pooja seems to take over. Poorvi yeh and Poorvi woh and aahs and oohs, come on give us a break

The biggest blooper:

Sunidhi the great was asked to comment on Shanker Jaikishan and she stated some of their popular numbers as an example of their versitality. Can someone tell her that the number "Laga chunri mein daag" was not composed by SJ but Roshan

I was not surprised when Ritika said that between Poorvi and her, poorvi would be safe and I was also not surprised when Anu complimented Ritika for putting Poorvi before herself.

I know the last two left will be poorvi and dev

It will be funny if they show Asha and Anu in a masaledaar fight, fighting to make thier laadla and laadli winners




Blossom5 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: DIDfan89

Honestly, this show has become a joke and a disgrace. I really honestly hope that it gets cancelled and it never airs another season again. I thought after the disaster that was Season 5, this show would not renew or come again. But no...Indian Idol has returend and is more awful than ever.

Its so obvious that the final three is going to be Dev-Vipul and Poorvi and its pretty obvious Poorvi is going to win because of the judges obession over her. She cant even sing properly and they claim she is the best thing. I am even shocked that she was even selected in the first place, and she gets to stay over Ritika? Thats even more of a disgrace.
Obviously this show is not about singing.
W*F is wrong with the judges? Why does Sunidhi always say the opposite of everyone? Im damn sure its intentional adn then Salim runs along to support her. Asha always has a different view and then Anu is kabhi yahan kabhi wahan.
I am so done with this show, I just want it to end so I could watch KBC instead.
Please Indian Idol, DO NOT Come back with Season-7. We have been tortured enough.

Indian Idol's standards aren't high at all. Once in a while you come across a gem of a singer in the lot like we did last time around but if you watch other music shows like SaReGaMaPa, their standards are much higher. This show is so commercial, now the judges are shamelessly promoting their favorites, it's like what's the point of this show? I knew from day 1 Poorvi would be the judges' favorite, most likely she'll win, it's as if the other contestants try as hard as they can, sing their hearts out but it was all scripted from the beginning. No, i am not anti Poorvi because she makes me insecure about the chances of my favorite to win, no i am not anti Poorvi because i can't comprehend or appreciate her style. 😆 Frankly i have no favorite this season. I am pro music and music is the last thing of importance this season, how sad! While Poorvi isn't a bad singer, it seems the judges have lost focus this season, they were busy cracking wise comments and poking fun at contestants during the auditions and failed to pick the best of the lot for this season. Ok, so they messed up then, they worsened the deal by practically killing themselves praising 1 or 2 contestants over the rest while the competition is still going on. Idol needs to get its act together, the show's rep is going downhill and it's not fair to the viewers or contestants. It's not the current lot's fault that their singing isn't as good or that the judges choose 1 or the other to promote.
Edited by LuckyJade - 13 years ago
prerna4rishav thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#8
Can't believe I thought II6 would be different from II3 / II4 ..

It is reminding me of the wrong backings of Prashant Tamang and that manipuri gal in 4th season as winner😵

Wont be surprised if Poorvi wins ! That is it ! ( In Remo style ).. II will be over for me.. I am disgusted to see so much support for Poorvi from the JUDGE panel ! 😵 Are they like DEAF ? 😵
vansh thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#9
i gave poorvi many votes so before blaming the judges see how many we are giving.i saw her versality on friday so i don't think judges were wrong.ya ritika was bit week this friday so rightly eliminated but i will miss her
nafeesaeed thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#10
originally posted by DIDfan89...Honestly this show has becomea joke and disgrace". i totally agree with this view they shud check da TRP and feed back...then understand wats going on...bt it seems preplanned they least concern with jantas opinion...judges ko sirf poorvi n Dev nzr aa rahe hain while Vipuls singing is better thousand times than these LAADLA n LAADLI k jo jitni worst singing kre ga utney hi achhey marks milain gey.so aisa hi krna hey to please dont come next time with next season...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".