Watch

TEAM

Jhalak Dikhhla Ja 5 India Forums

Overhype of salman and ISha! [DT note Pg. 16] - Page 21

First Previous

Page

Created

13years

Last reply

13years

Replies

Views

Users

Likes

Frequent Posters

Shwetha

@quarky

Navigator

Posted: 13 years ago

#201

Originally posted by: nishu786
I wrote the same thing in my thread,writing it here too...

This is not first time i guess,Gauhar khan & yana gupta was also trained dancer who participated in JDJ,so stop crying foul for Isha & this show is not abt signing celebrity who is non-dancer.
This show is abt dancing with the celebrity whether he/she knows dance or not...

So was Sushant last year.

My motto while watching these shows: Enjoy their performances, the good ones. Winning / losing is mostly scripted. So it really doesn't "judge" the better dancer for me. When I see all performances throughout the season, I think I can know the best dancer, the most improved dancer and the dark horse.

The entire India is watching them, and they all get their due credit. Some people are bound to be disliked, so are some performances. Isha is disliked because of the excessive praises, Shibani is disliked for err.. not being Indian enough (yeah, I've seen it in so many places... people are bonkers) and Gurmeet is disliked for the sheer popularity.

While I'm not saying those are the only reasons they are disliked, people also dislike them because of their dance, but dance is supposed to be interpreted in the way you like. The judges seem to be fascinated by Isha-Salman and so am I. Can't expect everyone to like them.

So watch it as a weekly entertainment show. If we start talking about being unfair, that will take light years to finish.

Edited by quarky - 13 years ago

Quote

doyel

@doyelpakhi

Voyager

Posted: 13 years ago

#202

@ purva - you said it all! 👏

Seriously, how come it is unethical or wrong for Isha to participate?

The original format is called - Dancing with the Stars - Strictly dancing!

It's NOT about celebrity non-dancers. any celebrity - dancer or non-dancer can participate.

Every celebrity has advantage or disadvantage - if Isha has the advantage of being trained dancer then GC, Ravi Kisen, Gia and even Jayati have the advantage of being more popular than Isha and have the "Voting Advantage"

If Ethics has to be applied then the all the contestants should have been Only Non- Dancers and Not-so-popular celebrities or all of them should have been Non-Dancers and extremely popular celebrity.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

nishu786

@nishu786

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 13 years ago

#203

fans of almost all those celebrities liked the post of TM bcoz they have no confidence in their fav celebrity,even if their celebrity score good marks,they r insecure of Isha's marks 😆.

Even history of JDJ suggests that best dancer of show who performs consistently throughout the show never wins finale,still ppl r playing blame game that Isha's participation is not fair. If creative ppl of channel & show decided to bring Isha in show,then it's fair call. why blaming Isha here?

There were trained dancers in previous seasons too,why crying foul over Isha now?

Such fans need to show more confidence on their fav celebrity,instead of blaming Isha.

Quote

chocobear

@chocobear

Inactive

Posted: 13 years ago

#204

It's useless to cry foul actually because as nishu786 says a deserving candidate never wins a reality show. So it's unlikely that Isha will win the show now. So fans of the other celebs can take a chill pill. 😆

Quote

Arnav90

@Arnav90

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 13 years ago

#205

Originally posted by: chocobear
It's useless to cry foul actually because as nishu786 says a deserving candidate never wins a reality show. So it's unlikely that Isha will win the show now. So fans of the other celebs can take a chill pill. 😆

I agree with you dear when warned me abt warning level some days before in this topic, I got 2 for no reason so this time from saving myself from warning i will say...

Rakhi Sawant performaed very well from the Start in this JDJ, So Rakhi Sawant is the only only one who deserve to win JDJ 5...

I know RS is not a contestant in JDJ but acc to rules of this forum mentioning ur likes, dislikes n mentioning +ve -ve points of JDJ contestants is bashing so i will say agn

Rakhi Sawant must win this JDJ season bcoz She is performing well from day 1 of JDJ

Quote

605921

Suspended

Posted: 13 years ago

#206

Originally posted by: nishu786
fans of almost all those celebrities liked the post of TM bcoz they have no confidence in their fav celebrity,even if their celebrity score good marks,they r insecure of Isha's marks 😆. 🤣 Great post

Even history of JDJ suggests that best dancer of show who performs consistently throughout the show never wins finale,still ppl r playing blame game that Isha's participation is not fair. If creative ppl of channel & show decided to bring Isha in show,then it's fair call. why blaming Isha here?

There were trained dancers in previous seasons too,why crying foul over Isha now?

Such fans need to show more confidence on their fav celebrity,instead of blaming Isha.

Isha Salman Nhe jeetege becoz they r best 😆

jo i think sab se zaida improve karta ha wohi jeet ta ha so i think shibani on the cards 😆