.scorpio10 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#1

Hi guys ...

Sorry for the delay , had a crazy weekend ..I know ...I know , how can one on a dry weekend ...But I did ...nd it would be perfect , if Italy would won ... 😭...Italy broke my heart ...now my vitals organs will have to pay the price... Anyways here is my POV of AS , So sowie ..if I hurt someone ...

*************************************************************************************************************

D's AS 'That what I will call her . D's AS why ? Becoz being D's AS she got herself , the world around 'infact everything . All she remembered and cared for was D . U might wow , that's great .. or how lovely . But I say no . She was D's everything , but not someone I would call a perfect mother or woman . I found her very selfish and negligent as a mother .

Yes ! She brought the son of her husband's killer , gave him all the love and care in the world . But in doing so , she forgot that she had three daughters . I am not saying , it was wrong to take D in . But when you do so , you should be ready for the challenges ahead . She ignored or did not realise the effects of D's presence on Kala . Kala was not right , but as child when something effects you '.in the manner her father death did ''.it leaves an impact , difficult to erase . As Mother , I feel AS failed in handling the situation . She failed as Kala's Mother '..as she never helped or spoke to Kala to bring her out the shock and anger . If she would have , Kala might not have turned the way she was '

As D's AS I found over obsessed '' a bit too much 'U will say she treated him like a son , I would she treated like someone else child ''..as you even more careful abt someone's kids than own at times '''.This what I found abt AS ''.It was always D's Kundali , D's this ..D's That '..She was always around him''.Trying protect him as if he is breakable '''.I am saying a mother should not do so''..every mother is protective abt their kids '.But she forgot that if D's her son like wise Naku too was someone daughter ''.In Naku's case , I found her selfish '...D's accepted Naku , so she did ''Naku was good for D's as per Panditji , Only then Naku was her Bahu ''..But even then anything went wrong for D'''..Naku was first to blame .

Lastly she loved D right ''But ignored to correct him and stop , when time came ''..She could stop D from marrying Naku the first time '..But she did not even try , if she did ''..He might not done so '..Forget the marriage ''If she wanted , she could stop him becoming a Don 'But instead of stopping , she is excuses herself by giving the excuse of poverty .. I am sorry , but that answer of an escapist not of a mother .

Acc to me , she was not the perfect mother ''


Edited by scorpio10 - 13 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

11

Views

1k

Users

12

Likes

46

Frequent Posters

stranger2rose thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
she forgot that if D's her son like wise Naku too was someone daughter ''.In Naku's case , I found her selfish '...D's accepted Naku , so she did ''Naku was good for D's as per Panditji , Only then Naku was her Bahu ''..But even then anything went wrong for D'''..Naku was first to blame ....agree with u completely , nakku was important for her only because she could save dutta's life without even thinking once that all this could endanger nakku's life as well, infact she was the one who emotionally blackmailed nakku to not show her real face to dutta before they get married..how bizzare is that?
''If she wanted , she could stop him becoming a Don ..absolutely on the contrary she enjoyed the status of Aayi saheb ..the only thing that i like about her is that she gave dutta motherly love even though dutta's father accidently killed her husband.
aishwish thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#3
Hey pri! I agree every bit of your post, but my problem is I love her, even with all her pendulum acts, a comman joke in forum, I love her to bits, it's some thing hard to expalin I know she is wrong yet I love her,respect her, may be the pleasant persona of the actress playing the character that worked for me or what? A loving, caring,angry or selfish, Aayi saheb, I always loved her, even with her dual standards, I wish some body can explain my psyche!
As far as your post is concerned, a very well written one, you covered almost every part of the character...good job!
Ani_La_Iam thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#4

Great post Priya…😃 but sorry I do not agree with everything. 😳

Do not have time for a detail comment…on vacation…but I really loved AS and for me she was a perfect mother.

AS relationship with Dutta was beautiful. It is true that for her, Dutta was everything…just the way for Babi Naku was more important.

About Kala…I know she was not there for her when she needed her mom. But AS was a single mom with four very small kids and she had to take care of them, there trauma and her own lost…all by herself.

For me she did her best and thinking about the situation she was in…she did a great job as a mother.

I think stopping Dutta to become a Don or Dutta's first marriage…no one could have stopped Dutta.

sona89 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#5

nice post 😊AS was a selfish mom to a extent ...great thread 😊

Iridescence1 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#6

I would say nobody is perfect, my perspective over the fact that AS was focused on Dutta more so then her own children, maybe because when she knew the story, what happened, and what Dutta had gone through as a child, he was pretty much not cared for by his own father, maybe she felt she needed to flip that experience for him so did exact opposite of Damodar. Sometimes you forget the kid may not have had clue what was going on. But I do definitely agree with the fact that she did in a way neglect her own three daughters...not realizing her own three daughters had a problem with Dutta's presence. AS was a confused person, I don't think she even knew what she needed to say or do at any point and Dutta did kind of was her support in that sense so yes selfish as well...but she did always want happiness in the family, just felt she was not one to think for herself she went with the flow...like you said especially with Nakusha issue, no one even considered her to be a human, a person who also had a family and life..it was as if she was their toy ...when wanted played with her and otherwise tossed her aside...so defo agree with that.. and your last point too...agreed ! defo she stood around and did nothing when she needed to use the authority she had ...but no...

Anyway well done post! 👍🏼

ivy_11 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#7
Another Brilliant and thought provoking post, Priya 😊

IMO, AS may not have been the greatest mother but she did try to be a good mother. She took in Dutta at a time when nobody wanted him and showered him with love and affection. She had a large heart to look beyond the fact that Damoder was the person who had killed her husband.

She was extra protective toward Dutta..maybe she felt that he had been abandoned by fate (his Mom had died) and Damoder's harsh and inhuman treatment towards him. She wanted to protect him in layers of love and affection ...to the extent that she forgot the emotional needs of her own daughters, specially Kala, who was at an age where she could understand a lot of the happenings but did not have the maturity or the character to accept the son of her father's killer as her step brother.

Let us not forger that AS was a regular non working housewife who had to shoulder the responsibility of bringing up four fatherless children single handed. Maybe this was the reason she could not spend time emotionally bonding with the older children. Maybe Leela and Roops would have been less bitter towards DSP if it had not been for Kala's constant feeding their pea sized brains with negatives about Dutta.

Yes, AS should have atleast tried to stopped Dutta from entering the underworld...but would Dutta have listened...maybe he would have given it a second thought because of the love and respect he has for his Aiyee.

AS welcomed madhu into the family on one hand but was mostly not fair towards naku...even for baaji...I would say she accepted Naku and Baji for their worth and place in Dutta's life.


Was Dutta the son which AS never had ? The reason for paying less attention to Kala/ET ?
Warda. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#8

hi priya...great post 👍🏼

very well written...To me yes AS was not a perfect mother but just like aish mentioned that it was the persona of the actor palying that character that one cannot dilike her...she has got a very graceful personality...

The most unfair role she has played i think thats with kala... as a child the hatred which developed in kala against dutta i wonder why as a mother she figured that out...because a child cant be manipulative with his behaviour and though we miss that part in the show but im sure that kala when she was even 10 years old diliked dutta ...here i wish AS has stopped or counselled her...
Where as She stands to stop dutta entering underworld or tasha's first marrige their i would give her the margin considering dutta's rage and stubborn nature...
'U will say she treated him like a son , I would she treated like someone else child ''..as you even more careful abt someone's kids than own at times '''.This what I found abt AS ''
very thought provoking lines in deed...
enjoyed reading your analysis and just like you i was inclined towards Itlay too
mirage123 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#9
Aai saheb 😊loved the post
Strawbella thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#10
Priya i am catching up this topic so lately. There is one proverb in tamil that OORAN PULAIYA OOTI VALATHA THAN PULA THANE VALARUM which means that if you take care of strangers kids you kid will grow by itself. Mahatma Gandhi couldn never be a great father to his own kids but he is the father of the nation:-) am not comparing them. Ma Pov is that AS had extra care for boy child. I wanna share ma own experience my badi ma is having four daughters and they all are thirty plus and they address with respect(including me) but ma brother address without respect. Not even once ma didi's have questioned once. As love to dutta is natural as per ma pov. Hope i made sense:-)

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".