CSA: The ground reality

-Purva- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Engager Level 4 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#1
I came across this article today and that set me thinking on what we can do. Read the article please. I have bolded a few points I want to highlight and I'll share my thoughts on what can be done in my comments. All thoughts, opinions and suggestions welcome.

Exploited street kids see no hope in new law

HYDERABAD: The legislation to protect children below 18 years from sexual abuse was passed in the Lok Sabha on Tuesday, but 15-year-old Bala (name changed) is not convinced that it would help him from potential abusers as he stands at a corner of Public Gardens in Nampally in his fluorescent yellow T-shirt waiting for a customer. Alongside are other street children like him, sex workers and MSMs (men who have sex with men), all waiting for customers to stop their cars and pick them up. Bala, who had left his family in Ponnur and hopped on the first train from Nidubrolu railway station in Guntur four years ago, had changed several jobs till he decided to work as a rag-picker during the day and a sex worker by night.

"I used to stay on the Nampally station platform with five older boys. One day two men whom the others called seths came and took me along with another new kid in an autorickshaw telling us that we will be employed in hotels. It was a big hotel, somewhere in Begumpet, and we entered through the back gate. We were given clothes, asked to take a shower in a big bathroom and were kept locked in a room for a day. Then for the next one week we were sent to different rooms by turns to both male and female customers. I was terrified and numbed but after the week got over, the seth gave me Rs 150, which is the highest ever amount I owned then," recounts another 16-year-old boy.

In Public Gardens alone between 100 and 125 boys sell sex, most boys being between 13 and 16 years of age, according to Philip Issidore of Divya Disha, Hyderabad partner of Child Line. Some other areas of operation include Kacheguda railway station, Sundarayya Park in Baghlingampally and Yousuf Sharif Baba Dargah at Nampally. Mostly living on footpaths, railway stations, under the flyovers, on the stairs of showrooms, these boys do a variety of jobs during daytime including wiring, welding, loading and unloading of goods, cleaning in hotels and working at wedding halls. "Most of these homeless children enter this profession initially out of peer pressure. They are exposed to abuses of all sorts from older boys, men, transsexuals, and even women. Once they realise that they cannot stop this abuse but can utilise it to earn a living, they continue the cycle by initiating more boys," says Issidore.

However, most of these boys do not use any protection while indulging in sexual acts even though they are aware of STDs. HIV is an alien term for them although they know that AIDS means death. The very few who have used condoms have done so on the insistence of their customers. Issidore says that lack of acknowledgement on the part of the government that male children are also sexually abused and a false notion that trafficking is restricted to girls alone has led to this situation. "Even APSACS which distributes free condoms to MSMs does not take into consideration these boys and sex education is limited to girls alone," he says.

When enquired about this, APSACS additional project director Dr B Jayamma told TOI that condoms are available for all and anybody can use the vending machines at the railway stations.

Help from police remains a mirage. The website of the AP police lists mobile numbers of child welfare officers (CWO) across the city. But when the number listed under the CWO of Nampally police station was called, TOI was told that there is no office or officer of this type. Similar was the case with Kacheguda CWO where the person attending the call said, "wrong number" and disconnected the call.
While the inspector from Nampally police station was unwilling to comment on the issue, the Kacheguda inspector was unavailable for comment.

Admitting that police have always played the role of a silent spectator, Issidore says that the new legislation against child abuse is the first of its kind in terms of the fact that it is gender-neutral. "Although the modalities of its implementation are yet to be chalked out, one can only hope that young boys who have never been protected enough will find a legal and hence social recognition of their abuse. This is the first step before they can be given any sort of security," he says.

http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/hyderabad/Exploited-street-kids-see-no-hope-in-new-law/articleshow/13420534.cms
Edited by Chitrashi - 13 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

9

Views

2k

Users

4

Likes

18

Frequent Posters

undisclosed thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#2

this is heart breaking...i find it interesting that in such a conservative country there is such liberal views on sex...to the point that their was till recently no bill CSA ...that police turn a blind eye to what they know is happening...but maybe now that the "written" law exist...they can actually act...as before the law they would not have any grounds for arrest...but i am wondering...is prostitution legal in india?

-Purva- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Engager Level 4 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#3
Prostitution is illegal in India. Interestingly, the law serves to protect the customers in this case. It is perfectly legal to visit a brothel, but it is illegal to solicit. So in case of a raid, it is the sex workers who are charged and put behind bars and the people who visit them go scot-free with not even their names and contact details kept on record. Ironical, since everyone including the officers conducting the raid know that these poor girls are victims of flesh trade.
-Purva- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Engager Level 4 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#4
My suggestion to help these children - every time you notice such children standing in public places and they are not very difficult to identify, call the Childline service or the police control room. You can even call the office of a newspaper or media center. Keep doing that often enough so that someone is forced to take cognizance and act upon your report. It may take half an hour of your time, but it'll save a child's life.
642126 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#5

Good Lord! This is shocking!😲

But then, we can only suspect something going wrong. We can't think every rag picker must be abused. Though it is true such kids are not just sexually abused but also exploited by beggar mafia, drug peddlers etc. It is tough to ascertain accurately which kid could be suffering.

I feel the best which we citizens can do is to make as many people as possible, aware of organisations and helplines like Childline so that they can call up whenever they feel like they need help.

But then, the kids are desperate for money...why would they call up Childline anyway? If they are bearing so much trauma and risking STDs for sake of money, then why would they want to escape?

It's the police at fault, which is many times in partnership with the mafia and allows everything to happen right under their noses!😡

It's very tough for normal citizens to take action in case a child is willingly allowing himself to be abused for sake of money. 😕

-Purva- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Engager Level 4 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#6
A child cannot be allowed the same discretion of judgement that an adult can. That is fundamental difference between adults and children. One cannot say that the child is willingly allowing himself or herself to be exploited.

Mostly the children enter into this business as well as their day-jobs in order to earn a livelihood and find shelter. There is no other reason for this kind of life. So in either case if you see a child working in a hotel or a garage or as a rag-picker you need to alert the authorities so that the child can be adequately taken care of. As per the law it is illegal to employ children below 14 in any capacity - whether it is as domestic help, casual labor, organized or unorganized work sector.

In fact as responsible citizens you need to alert the authorities if you see a child working in the families of your friends/relatives etc. and at the very least make the employer aware of the wrong they are doing.
undisclosed thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#7

oh prostitution is illegal...good!...and that is a good idea of just calling the help lines when you see something like this happening...since i've been watching this show...i find that i am so alert...even in the US...in my own circle...i am just more alert...and feel like i am ready to jump to action at any time if i see something suspicious...i hope if needed i won't be paralyzed and actually help someone in need...

charminggenie thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#8
e@Chitrashi,

Excellent article, to say it rendered me numb and took me to the times when I sit in the cars, sumtyms not even sparing a glance towards these rag-pickers , broke and shattered my heart completely, it touched me more than SJ's episode.

Just imagining the numbers of these kids is mindboggling, the extent to which the poor is tortured is horrendous,This story should have been covered in SJ, not undermining the traumas faced by the participants on the show but to broaden the exten to which the malice of CHild Sexual abuse has spread across our society.

@you brought an excellent pt regarding the law about prostitution, but in CSA case it should be a through and through crime even if it was consented. But i remember reading a lot about some activists pushing for legalizing Prostitution atleast to counter the spread of many STDs and also to minimize it altogether, I wonder if that is a solution?

I want streets of India filled with these social msges with helpline numbers highlighted rather than some heroine selling soaps, imagne if 1 person everyday calls and reports about these kids at every traffic light signal ,v might say the true future of ths country.


Edited by charminggenie - 13 years ago
-Purva- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Engager Level 4 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#9
@undisclosed

The good point of this show is just that, it forces us to take a harsh look around ourselves. The issues raised so far are those which can addressed within the four walls of the home itself - it only requires a clean conscience and clear heart.

@genie
Prostitution per se is legal in India, but soliciting and seducing is not. So go figure the difference. My only grouse is that in a prostitution case the police can arrest the sex worker, the pimp and the brothel owner, but almost always the client goes scot free. Now if we made prostitution legal, and ensured that these 3 do not get arrested or charged, but a customer is charged and booked - first offense 2 years in prison, second offense 5 years, 3 or more offenses - minimum 10 years Imprisonment. Pass this law and the entire market for flesh trade would disappear in a day. One cannot sell a commodity if no one is willing to buy.
undisclosed thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: Chitrashi

@undisclosed

The good point of this show is just that, it forces us to take a harsh look around ourselves. The issues raised so far are those which can addressed within the four walls of the home itself -
it only requires a clean conscience and clear heart.

my beliefs exactly...it all goes back to basic humanity...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".