Less of a Reaction to the Child Sex Abuse Issue... - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

17

Views

2.2k

Users

9

Likes

89

Frequent Posters

mitzification thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#11
I guess cause this dsnt need a direct intervention like female infanticide. Female infanticide ..the action is more clear ...shut such clinics, dont go for it, fast track cases.
In child abuse the guilty party isnot clear , in infanticide ..i guess every 3rd household is guilty .
More over infanticide is a bad thought and culcript 's emotions need to be touched and there is chance of change of heart
ssexual assault .. is perverted mentality and culcript has no guilt ... I'd say that cucript is hidden in this case ..and in cae of infanticide .. culcript is almost everyone ... man woman ,family, doctor ...
mitzification thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#12

With the pathetic position women have in most households ... yes the mother was scared for her sister .. its not an equality based society ..here females are so dependent on the men that the lady wld side with her cucript husband rather than leave him .

undisclosed thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#13

@ pallavi25 ...when human rights are put before culture and society...this sort of mentatlity tends to evolve...and becomes part of peoples phsyche even before they learn to talk...its a behavior that has been carefully taught and passed on from generation to generation...so that the line between right and wrong is blurred...so to unlearn these bad behaviors it will take a few brave people that are willing to take a stand and make some more noise about it...

@ mitzification ... yes both cases require different types of solutions...though you can say that both intertwine...there is a distortion in the mentality...allowing such things to happen because they won't speak up in deffence of the child by bringing down another member of the family is like being an accomplice in the crime...
sweetvidisha thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#14
I dont want to offend anyone..but no indian would want to beileve that their kid was sexually abused by their own family memeber. even if the child goes up to their parents and tell them all they say is shut up how can u say that u r lying, dont even say this to anyone ever again. no one wants to beileve that its true.and for this very resson no child come forward. i read article how people think all these people who came to show are lying. that they were asked to come to show and say stuff just to raise trp..
trust me i know no one beileve a child when they tell parent that they have been sexually abouse by their own family memeber. next topic is dowry even though its illegal people still take dowry. like i said before trust me i know i have seen it happening and its so sad we cant do much about it. :/ :/
sweetvidisha thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#15
I know what u mean. parent rather protect their name in socitey and family memebr than speak up for their own child. its really sad. No child will even tell the truth or speak up and parenst say to be truthful. how can a child be truthful and sharing when you dont even beileve them.

Originally posted by: pallavi25

Thats because Indians are too embarassed and ashamed to discuss child sexual abuse! Its a taboo topic and ppl prefer to shove it under the rug when it happens in their families. Discussing it or confronting it would open up a can of worms that may break up the family.

Thats why that poor boy's mother didnt believe or support him when he told her his mausa (aunt's husband) was molesting him regularly since when he was 7 yrs old!
Can you imagine that? This boy finally gathered up courage to tell his mother abt it and she didnt believe it! 😡 She was too scared to take action against her brother in law as that may mean her sisters marriage would break up!
This is exactly why so many child abuse cases happen in families but everything is hidden, kept a secret. Thats why so many kids dont even tell their parents abt it!
As we can see from the lack of reaction or feedback from the media abt this episode, even the so called progressive, educated ppl are embarassed to discuss this issue! No wonder there are no proper laws to punish the offenders and pedophiles who commit such heinous crimes!
Indians are all hypocrites and want to ignore these embarassing topics as it makes them uncomfortable!

undisclosed thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#16

@ vidisha...its a sad reality...but not one that we have to accept...i hope that more forward thinking people (parents or not)...start to spread the message about CSA and make is so that the victims can come out ...but currently the low response is telling of the current state people are in regarding this abuse

Freethinker112 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#17
Yeah, the so called "honour" of the Indian family and the lengths they will go to "maintain" it, it's just pathetic. Someone married by their own choice, kill him or her for "honour". Don't debate with elders even if they are wrong or they will lose their "honour". I don't know how we have got such a skewed concept of honour and respect.

And then there is the "abla" or the helpless woman. Husband is your God, whatever he does is right, and you can't survive without him. No, he is a damn human and can make mistakes too. Get some education, confidence and be independent. Many problems of our society would not exist today if only people took a stand for what they believed in. But no, they just watch.

I don't know how such parents can even claim to love their children. Your child was being abused and he built up the courage to tell you and you don't believe him. For what "honour"? Seeing your child getting abused and doing nothing makes you honourable? Not in my book, thank goodness. Same goes for people who kill children who do love marriages. Killing your child is such an honourable thing to do, isn't it?

I could see the pain in Harshit's (may be wrong, I forgot his name) eyes when Aamir asked how he felt when his mother didn't believe him. Poor guy has learnt from childhood how mother is supposed to be all loving and nurturing. And seeing just the opposite reaction, a 180 degrees turn, as a child. That must have caused massive pain. But due to the image of mother, he was forced to say "I felt, yes my mom is all loving and caring, but I felt she is not for me." The way he said the first part as a meaningless and scripted line, and the pain on his face when he said the last part "but I felt she is not for me" just broke my heart. A child felt his parent was not for him. What a cruel thing to realize as a child!
Edited by Freethinker112 - 13 years ago
642126 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#18

My two cents on this:

- This is a taboo issue and I suspect even the ratings of this particular episode must have been low considering how taboo such issues are in Indian society.

- Female foeticide already has many laws pertaining to it and it is something in which external organisations like hospitals etc. are involved. So it's easier for government also to take action on such clinics or corrupt doctors but it is not possible to identify or weed out CSA offenders in a week! They did not catch offending parents in female foeticide cases! Only cracked down on doctors! Far easier to crack down on external institutions than individual perpetrators of a crime.

- The bill on this issue has not even been passed by government. No laws on this. So Aamir can't even call for implementation of laws! But I think SJ team should have started an online or real life petition for it, and presented it to government to call for passing of the bill.

- Aamir did write about the issue and do many radio shows through the week. Childline got flooded with calls, donations etc. Those featured on show like Harish etc. also kept the discussion alive across radio, and online media. The only positive outcome was people coming out in open about this issue and sharing their own experiences. A good sign at least.

- More than Rs. 23 lakhs worth of donation raised for Childline. It's much less than what they managed to raise for female foeticide (Rs. 64 lakhs for Snehalaya). It shows many perhaps did not watch or did not bother, since this issue is taboo in Indian context and not as universal as female foeticide.

This particular episode's prime victory has been in raising awareness and initiating talk on this issue which is totally ignored by people in Indian society. An NCPCR official praised Aamir Khan and SJ team for their efforts and called for the pending bill to be passed. But it's much less than what happened in case of female foeticide.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".