24 April 2012 Written Update - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

44

Views

4.1k

Users

16

Likes

159

Frequent Posters

sukanya_77 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#41

Mad -dad-goli could also do it but then they would do it in a hushed up manner . why sensationalize? Rangoli would do it only if she wants to be the CM and not CM'S wife where as Giridhar had angst against Daddaji . In a patriachal society giridhar was the rightful heir but daddaji made his damad ( an outsider) the heir.

Isa_de thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#42
Giridhar ji do not have the brains to set up a shooting...but he can do it with his jiji blessing.
sukanya_77 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#43
[ Originally posted by Durum
I really dont want BBP to acknowledge Puja because there is a baby. That is plain wrong. Women being baby factories to be owned by men goes against my grain...but then reproduction is a big deal for Indian stories it seems...
I would rather he acknowledges that he would lose a part of himself without her....acknowledges the real reason that he trapped her through marriage - because like he once said he could not bear the thought of a life where she did not exist alongside him.
It is quite deplorable that women in a society like ours have to resort to the institution of motherhood to claim their rights but with a man like BBP it might be her strongest point. To understand and exhibit the subtleties of relationship , the individual's socio- cultural millieu ,upbringing and personal values play a vital role. Unfortunately BBP had been an orphan; he has spent half of his life with a bunch of psychopaths and has the tendency to give in only when he is pushed to the wall .In the confession EPI he confess after pooja had a near death experience. If he acknowledges Pooja only for love , it would be very liberating but if he doesnot then the baby may help him to release himself from the darkness that surrounds him .
Edited by sukanya_77 - 13 years ago
durum thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#44
@Sukanya -

I agree with what you say. In some ways BBP's caving in to Brija only after a near death experience for Puja (perversely) makes sense - his being married and that to a political mafioso type family meant that pulling her in would only make things extremely messy for both of them. In reality, even if the marraige was dysfunctional, he really never should have led her on in the first place. And when he did, he should have explained why he did an about face when he came to Bhopal. Things might have been nipped (or not) but nevertheless he would at least have cheated on one person less.

I agree with societal morals, values and upbringing shaping one's thought. But there is one's own individuality and the freedom f choice. My problem with Shakuntala is also its reliance on motherhood during the "recognition". Dushyanth, when he going through his memory lapse, is shown yearning for an heir. And in Kalidasa's version of the events, he first spots his heir even before he runs into Shakuntala. I wish it had been in the reverse order. True, the way that they have displayed BBP indicates that Puja represents a path out of his bleak situation. And maybe having an heir would actually give him the guts to walk out of it. But nevertheless, wishful thinking...that women have polytomic identities, being a mother is only one of them. Also the way Puja's character is written, she herself might want only motherhood and acknowledgement as a wife, not the imposition of someone else's version of a career or economic independence. Let us see...



Edited by durum - 13 years ago
Tunasnah thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#45
the biggest difference btw bbp and pooja is pooja is not ambitious and on the otherhand bbp is passionate abt his ambition ie CM.POJA want to achieve, become a popular singer only to give happiness to her love ones make her parents proud fulfill their wishes and thats all on the contrary bbp want to become powerful CM so as to take revenge from those who exploit him .he face a lot of humiliation in his life look the way rangoli treated him .he never experience a women love a love with out condition ,pooja never compete with him unlike rangoli who is jealous of bbp achievement she cant take it how can he become so powerful with out her help she want to control him like slave.for pooja bbp is like a hero .its just thier atitude towards life is so different.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".