Bani is Jai’s Nemsis- In support of Bani!

mistletoe thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 19 years ago
#1

Jai's nemesis had to come, and it came in the form of the woman he loves the most…..This is the way Life pays you back with the same coin, it gives you a long rope, but takes back with compound interest! And more often than not, we have no option but to pay back to Life!

I did not write much in my update yesterday regarding Bani's reaction, since I was short of time….at that moment I was confused when I saw Bani telling Jai that she hates him! But in retrospect, I think it was the most natural, the most expected and the most instinctive reaction that any human being would have!

The only thing that confused me was that both Jai and Roshni told Bani the truth, then why is that she reacted differently to both of them? When Jai told Bani that he had accidentally killed her Mother, she doesn't utter a word but goes running into his arms to die alongside him! But later, when Roshni tells her the same thing (with a lot of added inflammatory sentences) Bani reacts in an almost contrary manner! As I said before, it is Bani's first reaction that confuses me more than her second…..I can think of only one reason why Bani went running to Jai and embraced him tightly….She wasn't even listening to what he was saying, all she had in her mind was that in a matter of minutes, the man she loves most will be separated from her forever and she won't let that happen at any cost and hence when Jai finishes his story with a "Main Jaa raha hoon…" Bani does what only she could do, run to him, not to stop him from dying, but to die along with him! Bani's first reaction was her gut reaction……a reaction which was purely from the heart and involved nothing else!

But later, when she realizes that Jai is safe, and then, Roshni tells her how miserable she is going to be, when she realizes that she has ended up not only marrying, but loving the man who killed her Mother, Bani realizes the staggering magnitude of Jai's past and how it has come to change everything they shared till now!

I really admire Bani's fortitude and sense of justice, even when she accused Jai of being responsible for her shattered childhood, she never rakes up anything else….Bani never talks about how unfair he had been to her, how he had cornered her after their marriage and made her spend countless days and nights in terror and under his naked hatred without any reason, how he had used every conceivable method to emotionally shatter her……I think what Jai did to Bani after their marriage is his biggest crime, not the fact that he had killed her Mother accidentally! Bani doesn't even count that in the scheme of things……that really shows the largeness of her heart! Bani forgave Jai for everything he made her go through simply because she thought that she was paying for Pia's mistake and then she fell in love with him!

That way Bani has a far stronger and more resilient character than Jai, he had no feeling of guilt for taking Kiran's life and worse, hiding such a truth from Bani all the while, till the day he realized he was in love with Bani and did not want to lose her. But Bani, she repented and paid heavily for the mistakes made by Pia…all of her own free will. I don't think Jai even realized that he could make Bani suffer all the while, only because she chose to do so….Bani could have walked out of the marriage anytime she pleased, but she stayed on…..for both redemption and for love! It takes a character of great courage and inner strength to do so, and that way Bani is definitely a notch up!

Coming back to Bani hating Jai, I don't think that is ever possible. Bani is simply not made to hate anyone……least of all Jai! If she couldn't hate him for the monster that he was till now, how can she hate him when he is truly repentant about what happened and in love with her (Bani knows it now!) Bani finally reacted in a way, which made her look as humane as Jai is…..A person who has some amount of bitterness, anger and regret in her heart…..Infact, when Bani tells Jai that she hates him, what she meant was that she hates herself for falling in love with him and still does…..the words just didn't come out the way they should have! Bani has gone too far in her relationship with Jai, and by that I do mean that she has consummated her marriage, no….She has gone too far emotionally with him, so far, that leave aside tracing her steps back, if she turns back, she won't even find the path that led her heart and soul towards Jai…..Bani has erased all her steps leading to Jai and now she cannot go back, even if she wants to……When your love for someone is so strong, so deep and so profound, nothing can really affect you in the long-run……There might be moments of regret, of confusion, of self-pity and of anger, but these just remain moments and nothing else……Love finally washes off everything and paints its color on you! Even if Bani tells Jai that she hates him and means that, she can never really 'not' love him now.....Bani might have a new emotion for Jai (Hatred), but she really cannot forgo of the Old One (Love) she has for him......And when Love and Hatred both co-exist, Love always wins hands down!😃

All in all, I don't blame Bani one bit for her reaction to Jai…..I was confused a little bit, but now in retrospect, I think that it is Jai's nemesis! I am sure a lot of us think that he has already paid for his mistakes, but he has not! He has surely suffered 7 years in dread and guilt (That too I am not sure, Jai had no guilt till recently, only fright of getting caught!) and yes, faltered badly in wrong relationships…..but where has he paid for what he made Bani go through? Also, I found it very intriguing, that Bani instanteonlsy forgave Jai when Ranvijay told her the lie about his wife being the victim of Jai's Car, but later, she is not able to digest the fact that Jai had killed her Mother……It was really nice to see that Bani reacts in the way 99.99% human being would react…Apna Apna hota hai, aur paraya paraya…..Bani, unlike most other over-righteous Balaji heroines, puts Love ahead than any moral responsibility…..She put her love for Jai ahead of Ranvijay's dead wife, but later she put the love of her dead Mother in front of her husband's love…..For probably the first time, a Balaji Heroine has reacted like any woman would do in such circumstances!

I think Bani's current situation is the Pits, she is in the worst time of her life...She missed Love, Security and Warmth all her growing years, yearning for someone to keep a hand over hear head, someone to embrace her tightly from all dark shawdows, someone to wipe away all her tears, someone to light up her days and brighten her nights....and when she finally finds the man, she realizes that he is the one who was responsible for all that she had missed in her life....😭 Bani actually ended up falling hopelessly in Love with Jai and expressed the same to him! Bani can only stop herself from giving anything else to Jai in future, but try as she might, she cannot take back the Love, Caring, Understanding and Togetherness she has already given to Jai....A part of hers has become Jai's forever.....physically, emotionally, spiritually and mentally!

It's a twist of irony, which we almost always end up paying for mistakes that we did not commit at that time, but for some other mistake that we committed and got away scot-free! As Jai himself said, that for all his hatred and anger, Bani only gave him love and understanding in return, now it is his chance to payback! Love is a two-way street……Until and Unless Jai suffers the same pain and longing for Bani that she underwent, he will probably never understand her true worth in his life!

A few things where I felt that Bani was unjustified;

When Bani accuses Jai of marrying her inspite of having accidentally killed her Mother! Now that is totally wrong, not only all of us, but even Bani knows why Jai had to marry her......What Bani should have told Jai was that how could he propose marriage to Pia when he had such a black past to hide! Pia is as much Kiran's daughter, as Bani is! I think by saying this, Bani has only proved her love for Jai.....She did not even mention the fact that Jai was going to marry someone else, Bani talked in a way, that suggested that Jai has never thought about any other woman apart from Bani!😊 See, Bani gives herself away everytime, especially infront of Jai!

Secondly, I disagreed with the fact that Bani blamed Nishikant's death on Jai. That was totally false, Nishikant died, because he was a weak character, a man who put the responsibilities of his two young daughters on his eldest child and himself resorted to escapsim. If every man took to the Bottle when his spouse dies, then every child without a Mother would become an Orphan. Jai had nothing to do with Nishikant's death at all and hope Bani realizes that later no!

All in all, I am looking forward to see how Bani reacts to Jai from now onwards. Bani tells Jai that she won't punish him for anything, she will let the Law of Nature take its course but he would have to live with her hatred from now onwards......That means, Bani has every reason to live with Jai....She talks about living with her hatred, not about living without her.....More important, I want to see how Jai reacts to Bani's indifference and cold attitude towards him! Will Jai become a recluse and an alchoholic like the same Nishikant that he hated and will wither away in self-pity or will be be the man that he is and win back Bani's lost love and trust once more?

My two penny's…..Would love to listen to your views and comments….

Cheers,

MT😊


Edited by mistletoe - 19 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

31

Views

2.5k

Users

25

Frequent Posters

soap-critic thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 19 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: mistletoe

Coming back to Bani hating Jai, I don't think that is ever possible. Bani is simply not made to hate anyone……least of all Jai! If she couldn't hate him for the monster that he was till now, how can she hate him when he is truly repentant about what happened and in love with her (Bani knows it now!) Bani finally reacted in a way, which made her look as humane as Jai is…..A person who has some amount of bitterness, anger and regret in her heart…..Infact, when Bani tells Jai that she hates him, what she meant was that she hates herself for falling in love with him and still does…..the words just didn't come out the way they should have! Bani has gone too far in her relationship with Jai, and by that I do mean that she has consummated her marriage, no….She has gone too far emotionally with him, so far, that leave aside tracing her steps back, if she turns back, she won't even find the path that led her heart and soul towards Jai…..Bani has erased all her steps leading to Jai and now she cannot go back, even if she wants to……When your love for someone is so strong, so deep and so profound, nothing can really affect you in the long-run……There might be moments of regret, of confusion, of self-pity and of anger, but these just remain moments and nothing else……Love finally washes off everything and paints its color on you!


WOW MT thanks for clarifying the whole thing is such detail. I have picked out the above paragraph from your analysis because this thought has been on my mind since I read the update and later on saw the video. That Bani being Bani cannot hate anyone. Then how will she be able to hate Jai. You have put her situation very well and do hope from the bottom of my heart that what you have written will come true - that love will finally wash away everything.

I have mentioned this in some other post also that I would like to see how Jai faces Bani's anger now. Will he be able to do it in the same quiet and dignified way as Bani had faced his? Or will he go back to his bottle and find solace in drinking?

lil_desi_goddes thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 19 years ago
#3
MT.. loved ya analysis..!! well i havent actually watched the episode as yet..
but i must say... i will probably end up agreeing with what you have just
said..!!
sam111222 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#4
well said MT.i too agree with u.earlier when bani came to know that accident victim was ranvijay's wife but when she came to know that it was her mother ,she reacted differently.i think that bani was more hurt because jai hid the truth from her that he killed her mother in an accident and married her.i remember she even asked him that why he married her. so i think that is the reason why her reaction was so strong because she felt betrayed by him.
suku thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#5
I tink this hate drama that Bani pulled of is just Balaji's TRP SHAM. It worked for them in Kutumb, Kaisa yeh pyaar hai and many other countless shows tat maybe I am not aware of. U said tat for the first Bani reacted in a humane way this could be seen in positive light but tis also goes against her character. I mean they cannot turn Bani into Meena Kumari in half of the show and just in seconds turn her into Angelina Jolie . I KNOW wen put under certain situations people change but tat change does not happen in seconds. It takes time!! Maybe they could have tried showing Bani's hatred to Jai's previous actions and tat hatred builds up into tis big anger. But there was nothing to build up on so where did this hatred come from.If Bani thought tat Jai's past actions were justified due to Pia's betrayal and Of course wat happened wid Jai and Bani's mom was an accident ten there should be no problem here.

Actually wat I tink happened here is tat they wanted the Raaz to be an instrument for Bani's hatred towards Jai but Raaz certainly couldnt live up to its hype and really wasnt tat big of ting anyway so they r just Pushing Bani's hatred theme at us which no one is going to buy anyway. And the reason tat people r not going to buy Bani's hatred is tat Raaz didnt show Jai guilty enough to make viewers Sympathize wid Bani and support her for going against Jai.
Edited by suku - 19 years ago
aksn thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: sam111222

well said MT.i too agree with u.earlier when bani came to know that accident victim was ranvijay's wife but when she came to know that it was her mother ,she reacted differently.i think that bani was more hurt because jai hid the truth from her that he killed her mother in an accident and married her.i remember she even asked him that why he married her. so i think that is the reason why her reaction was so strong because she felt betrayed by him.

i totally agree with you.

after i watch yesterday epi. i think bani's mom didn't kill jai's car. that's for sure..

Lucky_Z thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#7
gr8 analysis MT 👏 .. n i agree with u .. bani n jai reacted 100% humanly as any real human being would have reacted , n that is the charm of KS , having real characters not reel ones ..!!!
WiLd FiRe thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#8
thanks MT for ur wonderful analysis. its great to finally hear a ur full views. I was always on Bani's side from the beginning and i tried to explian my views but ofcourse im no MT but you u did a very well job of explaning them. its excatly wat i think. her reactions were normal. any human being wud go through that, i mean u'd have to be a rock not to feel what bani felt at that moment. shes mad at jai rite now but with time she will forgive him, just like how he forgave pia and pushkar. I also believe that bani can not hate jai. she just loves him too much. unlike jai, wenever she will try to hurt him, she will end up hurting herself more. i think or atleast hope that her anger does not stay for long cuz i wana see em together and happy!!!

thanks again for bringing this topic up. greatly appreciated.
Edited by WiLd FiRe - 19 years ago
princessjojo thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 19 years ago
#9
Hi MT! Need I say it was a great analysis?! I think not..

Here are my 2 cents on what I think of the whole scenario, just copying and pasting from another post!

For some reason, even though the majority of the forum has its pointer at Bani, Im in support of her. Doesnt mean I dont support Munna. But I dont think Banis reactions are unjustified. They are totally reasonable. Its close to impossible to think as a wife in love, and as a child/sister simultaneously, in this scenario. Hence her reaction to the situation cannot be expected to be consistent.

In the last few seconds of Jais life, the only thought that occupied her mind was his life. It didnt matter whether he was a killer, a murderer or not! All that mattered was he was her husband, and she loved her husband. And if we think rationally, nothing else could have creeped in her mind for the simple reason that she had no time to think of anything else! In those 4 minutes, I bet her state of mind didnt allow her to dwell on any thought except the life of her husband. She may have heard what Jai had to say, but I doubt if she processed it! Even if she did, she knew in her mind that this was it! There was no scope for anything else. She couldnt accuse him in the last seconds of his life, now, could she? That would be ridiculous! And there was no way she was going to walk away in disgust! Because, whatever it is, she does love her husband and he was dying in front of her eyes! Her only option was to show him she loved him, and the only way she could do that was by embracing his fate-death along with him.

Now, after the blast, when Roshni came to the duo, passing those contemptuous remarks, Bani finally had the time to let everything sink in. First she realized they were alive, that her husband was alive. Then she had the time to bring back the RAAZ in focus, and finally it sunk in that her husband had killed her mother! Just imagine the chaotic frame of mind she may have been in! I for one would be devastated If I found out something on these lines...dont even want to put it in words! To top it all, the absence of a mother has affected Bani the most! Her father wasted his life intoxicated, so much so that he never may have felt the burden, he just felt his wife's absence. But Kiran's absence not only hurt Bani through out her young adulthood, but it also added physical and emotional burden on her! She had to become her sisters' safety cushion, their anchor, and their financial support. How sad can her situation get... She had no one for herself! These experiences made her resilient, but all the latent frustration of all these years had to come out at the disclosure of this RAAZ. Its absolutely human! Infact, if she had responded calmly, even after Roshni did whatever she did to provoke her feelings, I would have been baffled at her hardiness keeping in mind that she is a young woman! And women are emotional creatures, for the most part, at least.

The only thing I did not approve of today, was Bani's accusation that Jai is also responsible for her father's death! Whatever Bani! Your father was too weak a man. Sorry...but he could have handled everything better. And if he was soo in love with his late wife, then he should have been worried about her soul's peace and taken care of the three of you with the best of his abilities! Death is no excuse to give up responsibilities...

Overall, I dont think Bani's reactionS are unreasonable. She is human after all..

Btw, I cant wait to see how Jai will take this indifference from Bani! The creatives better keep his character intact during this process! I dont want to see a Jai wallowing in guilt and self-hatred, moping around, brooding, sulking etc etc! That charisma has to remain...hope they are listening.

luv, Jojo

Jojo
heyitsrupy thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#10
Hi MT,

Well as I wrote yest in a topic which incidentally has vanished off the forum, Bani's reactions are totally understandable...In fact, in the whole scenario, it is her position which is most terrible...She has acknowledged that she cnt live without Jai...her life is meaningless without him, but she cnt live with him either...Its a strange twist of fate...He was responsible for the things she has missed all her life...love, security,care and stability...And then he turned up as the promise of all those very things...Its going to be so hard for her to turn her back to all these things which she has longed for, for the sake of her past and her mother...I wonder how long she can fight it out...how long she can shut out her heart to Jai...

I agree with you that she has gone too far along with Jai...More importantly, its not in her to keep grudges against those she loves...Time and circumstances have taught her to forgive those who are close to her...Whether its her sisters, her father or now Jai...It would not be in keeping with her character to hate him...Its just not HER...And I hope the scriptwriters dont portray her otherwise and destroy the very essence of Bani...Her fortitude, resilieance and capacity to love and care!!!

Abt love being a two way street....well so true again...But as far as I am concerned, there's a catch here....I DON'T want this guilt and torment to destroy Jai's character...I know its irrational...He should pay for his crime...He's been selfish and manipulative...He deserves to be go through some torment....But I still dont want him to grovel...I dont wnt Jai to lose his basic charm...his ease of manner and authority...Not be able to meet Bani's gaze...U see the dilemma??...I wish to see him upright and in the clear...And for that he probably has to go through a bitter process of penance...But I dont want to SEE that penance happening... 😕 ...Its troubled me to see the unbalanced J-B relationship with Jai calling all the shots...Now I dont want the balance to tip totally the other way...

So to deal with this irrational complexity, I am just hoping that they would come out with some stupid twist where Jai wasnt guilty at all...Any stupid conspiracy would be fine...I dont really care this time!!!

Rupy

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".