A letter to our critics~! - Page 8

Created

Last reply

Replies

76

Views

7k

Users

42

Likes

445

Frequent Posters

malinn thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#71
This whole post has some wonderful points made...The discussion here, while originating from the serial, has come to the larger points like censorship, viewer rights etc... As always, there is no single truth...We are all right... Those who thought it was aesthetic and beautiful and showcases a coming of age for Indian media/audience etc... And those who thought it hurt their sensibilities and value system...
There were a couple of points here that were glaring though... There seems to be a justification for strong language and 'putting people in their place' by saying they were justified... since this whole post was in response to some people who had created posts against the show/characters etc... You are singularly responsible for your own conduct... There is so much herd mentality and brutal cutting down of people with harsh words (always backed up by likes and agree comments by friends)...
Another was that protesting something against your beliefs is not old fashioned or outdated or trying to take India back...
In the western world too...Eg. There is a constant campaign against the likes of McDonalds and Moms get together to ensure that junk food/soft drinks are not served in/near schools... Mothers unite against drunk driving...Smoking is not allowed in movies...Bad language is beeped out...Child locks/parental controls are in place on TV/computers ...Parents do want to control what their kids are doing...
Celebrities are always used to endorse products...WHY???? They have the power to influence people...Celebrities find it most easy to enter politics...since they are recognised/respected... Arun Govil/Smriti Irani are examples... So, people have certain expectations from the people who are their favourite actors...It may not affect you or me...But it most certainly would affect many others... They expect the actors to be righeous and put their foot down and refuse to play such parts...Like some heroines refusing nudity/love scenes while others do it... People possibly expect Sakshi Tanwar to be more like the Parvati/Priya she plays...
It is entirely possible that the way people have vent out their anger is not correct...But an eye for an eye is not the answer... We need to understand where they are coming from...Why this anger and disgust????? If these people are accepting of all the dirty dancing and the jawani songs and the sunny leon's...Why this sudden moral policing when shown on balh????? It is possible, because the time, place, people, audience etc...was all wrong...They possibly don't want such nosense entering the living rooms of India through the much needed daily dose of escapism...They don't want to RUN AWAY from the TV...which is their only true and reliable source of entertainment...
It is all in the context...
Edited by malinn - 13 years ago
janardana thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#72
Yeah.. Yeah.. Yeah.. Its another post on the Monday episode.. I have had enough . So Iam here to put in my 2 bits as well.. There are posts comming in from all over, each having his opinions be it good or bad. One has gone far enough to say that the serial might go off air for the "so called explicit" scenes shown.. Explicit??? I don't think that they know the meaning of the word... The episode has sensous scenes.. Ok.. Point taken.. But as most of us would agree, it was not sleazy or dirty. All that hungama... Oh my god!! They keep telling us it was too bold and questioned the morals, indian culture and family values... All this for a kiss that lasted 3 seconds.. Family values?? Oh.. Common.. even your children know that dad and mom kiss and make babies.. how it is done is all over the newspapers and net!! And hoo boy.. to those who think that their kids are innocent little tykes who only watch Animal planet and discovery channel should get their brains checked.. Animal world shows more explicit contents than any other daily show!! And every TV network, be it news, SSBs abd SBS's and other telly talk shows keep telecasting the same scene over and over again during primetime.. news time.. family time.. So it that ok? Even Sony cut off the kiss in the repeats not wanting to cause any more problems.. A minister watching p*** did not even get so much critisism as this episode got... Indian Culture?? My foot!! I also wish that the forum stops such articles being posted.. Get this guys.. its over and done with...
Edited by janardana - 13 years ago
fosla thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#73
It's done and dusted. The actors have moved on and we have.. but the world seems to have stood still post the episode.. 😆
luvbalh thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#74
wow guess ur angry on critics.. 😆 kids knw mom dad kiss to make babies ..😆
maris08 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#75
Yep we have had enough and moved on and looking forward to Monday..
BTW Mods if anymore topics about 12th March epi is opened please club it or close it..
-Carrie- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#76
I do not see any reason for you to be so upset.Just like the "C" promo gave an indication of the content of the upcoming episode heeding which a tiny group of viewers such as myself stayed away from it the same way topic headings too give an indication of the content of the post which in itself should make you stay away. Skittish viewers were emphatically told "Don't like It, Don't watch It". I implore you to do the same. Don't like It, Don't Read It. 😳
yomamma thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#77
Well, you have a problem if your kid is watching TV at 10:30pm...don't blame the shows please!
Does Indian culture call for not sleeping with your spouse?

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".