Created

Last reply

Replies

26

Views

2.3k

Users

9

Likes

64

Frequent Posters

Swethu. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#21
Hi, I am usually a silent member of this forum. But after watching yesterday's episode, I couldn't stop myself from posting in this forum. First of all, a very nice post as others have already said. U spoke about Suhaana's humanity side and the way she treated her maid equal to her. But I was thinking about MADHURI. Does characters like her exist in real life also? I mean today people are not caring about their own parents..she is with her husband just because she married him?Is she not irritated with him? She could have even left him to his fate and can go her own way. BUT she is taking care of him just like her own child. How can this happen? Then I realised that this is a SHOW. In show, people are shown are great and mahaan. IF this happens with someone in real life, will she be able to take care of husband all her life who just stays on bed? I don't think so...Sorry for venting out like this on your post. It is just that the scene has been so touchy that it brought tears into my eyes.
Edited by Swetha27 - 13 years ago
infinity00 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: Swetha27

Hi, I am usually a silent member of this forum. But after watching yesterday's episode, I couldn't stop myself from posting in this forum. First of all, a very nice post as others have already said. U spoke about Suhaana's humanity side and the way she treated her maid equal to her. But I was thinking about MADHURI. Does characters like her exist in real life also? I mean today people are not caring about their own parents..she is with her husband just because she married him?Is she not irritated with him? She could have even left him to his fate and can go her own way. BUT she is taking care of him just like her own child. How can this happen? Then I realised that this is a SHOW. In show, people are shown are great and mahaan. IF this happens with someone in real life, will she be able to take care of husband all her life who just stays on bed? I don't think so...Sorry for venting out like this on your post. It is just that the scene has been so touchy that it brought tears into my eyes.



Very true, I was thinking about it too, but this is Woman for us, when a woman decides to love somebody it's unconditional. I know many ladies who are in similar situation , not exactly like Madhuri but yes , very much so, they could walk away from there partner's life but they choose not to, not by force but out of love and responsibility, and this is a woman's love.

Nishaan, I didn't notice the friends requests, I am very weary these days of who to accept as I don't want to be treated with disrespect without any reason just because they don't like what I say.
I will accept it .
mjtruelegend thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: MadameX

I see we're appreciating maids...😆

Personally, the greatest thing Suhana probably has done for Madhuri was give her a job at her place even though Madhuri wasn't needed at all. So I guess that's humanity too. 😆



Thats right, inadvertently, that is also being a good human being.

I have known people to employ maids/helper, even if its just for a few hours a week just to help out that person because they don't want that person to lose their self respect. So rather than offering the money or help, they give them a job, I think Its rather remarkable of that person.

shilu999_balani thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: Swetha27

Hi, I am usually a silent member of this forum. But after watching yesterday's episode, I couldn't stop myself from posting in this forum. First of all, a very nice post as others have already said. U spoke about Suhaana's humanity side and the way she treated her maid equal to her. But I was thinking about MADHURI. Does characters like her exist in real life also? I mean today people are not caring about their own parents..she is with her husband just because she married him?Is she not irritated with him? She could have even left him to his fate and can go her own way. BUT she is taking care of him just like her own child. How can this happen? Then I realised that this is a SHOW. In show, people are shown are great and mahaan. IF this happens with someone in real life, will she be able to take care of husband all her life who just stays on bed? I don't think so...Sorry for venting out like this on your post. It is just that the scene has been so touchy that it brought tears into my eyes.


hi... im in class now so wont write a long post but i will definitely get back to you on this...yes in real life it is possible too...i am a living example of it...my husband has been sick for the last 18 years and in bed wiht a stroke since the last 9 years... i will go further into it later...

it brought tears to your eyes...but just think if you were in that position would you be just able to walk away...you married him and mutually promised each other to stick together in sickness and in health...in richness and poverty..etc etc... but when really the time comes...are you going to be irritated (your words) and leave him to his fate and go your way(again your words)... its easier said than done...when you spent 16 happy years with him...when he took care of you... did you think of walking away?...why not? because at that time he was able to provide you with all the comforts..but now that he cant..you want to leave him to his fate...will your conscious allow you to do that...?
my husband has been just like maduris husband for the last 9 years.. the only difference is that he can talk while madhuris husband could not...

and dont think i am an ancient woman talking of old fashioned customs...although it has been 35 years to my marriage..i have moved on with the times... i am not from a village but from a city and very much educated too..a graduate from a university...but this has nothing to do wiht education... it is your own moral standards... and last ..if you were in that position instead of your husband...how would you feel if he just walked away leaving you to your fate...?


Edited by shilu999_balani - 13 years ago
Swethu. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#25
^

First of all, I want to salute you and bow to u. After reading your post, I have cringed with guilt for thinking like that in case of Madhuri. You are so right ' When you shared happiness with him, you should also share sorrows with him. This is really true.

But what if you just get to see only sorrows with him? I think I should be more clear- - - sorrows just BECAUSE of him? U shared your story now it is my turn. My father is mentally disordered. He does not do any work and stays at home presently. But he is very well educated and even got very good job offers. But due to his illness which was not identified by anyone at that time was mistook to be ill attitude and lost all of them. His parents( that is my now grand parents) have hid the truth from girl's family and married to her(that is my mom). After marriage, my mom got to know the truth she has been cheated. But my mom did not do anything. She just did not do anything.My grand parents told that he has been cured and is now a normal person. But alas! Mental illness can never be cured, I feel that. Months passed by, my father again lost his job and he was put in jail because he has been caught beating up his officer in his illness. My mom and family brought him home and told him not to work anymore. My mom, even though she was not educated at that time, she managed to do the degree after marriage to get a job and run the family. Even after all this, my father still gets attacks( doura) and at times beats my mom. One time he even tried killing her. But she just joined him in a hospital and took care of him. She continued to run the family of her and 2 children with her earned money. 27 years passed of their marriage and she is still leading the same life as if she is happy and contended with. The only difference is that now living has become a little better because now her son is well educated is doing a good job in one of the MNCs. Her daughter(that is me) recently got a job in campus placements. My mom felt so happy as if her life has been so successful.

I came to know this truth, when I am 15 years old, now I am 20. I have asked my mother to leave him, my mom answered just like u. She said she is married to him and now she is not going to leave him. But I still feel the pain. I feel the pain when I think about my mother. Just think about a girl who is young and got married recently. She will have so many dreams and wishes. All her dreams shattered just because of one person. All her happiness is gone. But she is still supporting him. Don't u think she deserves happiness like any other girl in her life? I FEEL my mom deserves all the happiness of the world and I vowed to myself that I would give her that. The thing is that you are thinking from the POV of a responsible wife and I am thinking from the POV of a daughter who just want her mother's happiness. Please don't ask what about your father? He cheated my mom and tried to kill her. Even though he did that because he was not in his right state of mind. I hate him. I am sorry for saying this but I hate my father because he tried to harm the only person who is truly dear to me, my mom.

Till now I used to think, only my mother is like this. But I think all the mothers are like this. Just bear the pain for your family. But I should say this, I used to get inspiration from my mother and be strong. Now I've got even you. U truly inspired me a lot. Thanks for that and Sorry for the long post!

Edited by Swetha27 - 13 years ago
shilu999_balani thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#26
@shweta...im sorry to have touched a very painful cord in your life...just like a felt you had touched a painful cord in my life by saying that in real life it doesnt happen... it does happen..i just told you a part of my story not the whole...yes i understand that what happened to your mom was very tragic to be really deceived at the time of marriage..that was a very mean thing to do...but you know...long ago sp. in india...the symptoms of this disease are not recognized... of wht you wrote i think your father was suffering from manic depression just what my husband was diagonised as... he also had the same bouts of anger and madness... where at many times he tried to harm me and my children too... once he pushed my son from his running car... luckily nothing happened to my son...once he tried to kill me and himself too... he fought with many people..for which i opologised to them... these are symptoms of manic depression...but unluckily for your mom he was not correctly diagonized so they thought he was mentally disabled but cures are there for such cases too...all this happened in my life 18-19 years ago... at that time i too was advised by even my own sisters to divorce him and make a life of my own...but i chose not to... as not only my children were small...but i knew if i threw him out of my life he would end up in the gutter as a homeless being... and my conscious would not allow me to do that... i got help for him...he was given medication...not that it finished there...as you said ..he still had many bouts in which he would act up and needed to be hospitalised to restrain him ... but he would get better and come home.. but he was useless as a husband or father... since the 18 years i have been both mother and father to my children... he played no part in theri lives... then 9 years ago he collapsed with a stroke... after which he had two more strokes which have left him bedridden...
living in japan ..i have medical facilities which help me a lot...i still have the option of giving up... after which the city will take care of him... but i havnt used that option becase i know it will simply kill him...
ok now you may ask (as you may have asked your mother ) why?... why? dont we give up on them?... i dont know your mothers reasons.. but i will explain you mine...i believe strongly in karma...fate... we have accounts to settle of our past lives with people that come into our lives... why do we get married to particular person ...why do we have children... becaue we have to settle our karmic accounts with them...its a give and take that continues in our lives from past lives... i dont know if im making any sense to you ...but its true...we are bound to each other because of our karmic accounts...if we werent... circumstances would push us apart...but since we have been put together ..we have to settle them... and since his seva has been put in my plate as it were...i perform it whole heartedly...mind you not because i love him or anything but i feel my god has given that seva to me to perform and if i dont...then i will be letting down my god...not my husband...in punjabi there is an adage "tera bana meetha lage"... that means what portion god has given us in this life we have to accept it willingly...
again i believe god sends us into this world for a purpose... if we come into this world...live for ourselves... enjoy our lives and die for ourselves ... then your life hasnt been worth living... but if you come into this world and make a difference in someone elses life... to make it better for them... then your life has been worth living... the purpose that god sent you into this life has been fulfilled... you have succeeded in making a difference in the life of one of gods creatures... thats why i know if i had left my husband those 18 years ago...he would have become homeless and died a long time ago... at least by my taking care of him..he has had a better life... i think i had come into the world for him and for my children for whom i worked literally my butt off to give them a good education and settle them in theri lives...
i think shweta there must be a link between us in our past lives for me to open up like this with you... i respect your mom for sticking to her responsibilities and taking care of you kids... now make it a point to bring happiness in her life and make her as comfortable as you can to compensate what she has gone thru for you kids... im happy to say..my kids also care about me a lot... they love and respect me and give me a lot of moral support... they too at times questioned me like you... but they understand my point of view and respect me for it... now that my husband sees our grandchildren at least he feels very happy...otherwise where would he be...? these are lessons that some people do learn in life... i really hope you kids dont go thru what your mom and i have gone thru...god bless you...
mjtruelegend thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: Swetha27

Hi, Hello I am usually a silent member of this forum. But after watching yesterday's episode, I couldn't stop myself from posting in this forum. First of all, a very nice post as others have already said. Thankyou U spoke about Suhaana's humanity side and the way she treated her maid equal to her. But I was thinking about MADHURI. Does characters like her exist in real life also? Yes they do, there are many people like that on this planet, I have seen a few myself! I mean today people are not caring about their own parents..she is with her husband just because she married him? For many, marriage is for life, in sickness and in health! Is she not irritated with him? Of course they get irritated, its only human but when you love someone and you accept them wholeheartedly, the even the irritation is not enough to push them away! She could have even left him to his fate and can go her own way. BUT she is taking care of him just like her own child. How can this happen? It can happen my dear, one cannot leave their spouse if they become disabled. Just because they are bed ridden, it doesn't change the person they are, one cannot stop loving because of ill health and its effects. Then I realised that this is a SHOW. In show, people are shown are great and mahaan. IF this happens with someone in real life, will she be able to take care of husband all her life who just stays on bed? I don't think so...Sorry for venting out like this on your post. It is just that the scene has been so touchy that it brought tears into my eyes. By reading your post I am guessing that you have not yet come across people like that but trust me there are REAL Madhuris in the world. Think about it, what kind of a person would Madhuri be, if she had left him? What kind of wife would she be if she left him when he needs her the most? This is done in base of love and tender care (and humanity) We all need that, in what ever form it comes in. Madhuri is being a dutiful wife and good human being. One does the best they can to take care of their loved one and that's what she's doing.



I hope you that's okay you 😊

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".