Is this Necessary?? - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

37

Views

2.6k

Users

10

Likes

63

Frequent Posters

KhatamKahani thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#31
Yup, agreed. That's all that was needed. And then the little line about the regret she wasn't able to get his love--which I thought was fine.
Parm. thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#32

Originally posted by: anitarani

True, mainly because they are deliberately malicious...both showed absolutely no remorse at
Kastur taking the blame...and were just satisfied that they were out of the soup.🤢



Exactly! Saroj new she would be in the melting pot from babji as she is responsible for the kitchen and so used Kastur as a scapegoat and we all already know what sia is like.


manasi_31 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#33
Oh dont get me started on that ... I absolutely hated and I will keep hating the fact that she took up this blame ... It makes her char so so blunt ...

But maybe it needs to be in our face everytime that she is a dharampatni ... and so she did it just because she is supposed to prove herself an ideal dharampatni and dharambahu 😊 Well thats the only sensible explanation her taking up the blame can have 🤢 I dont feel it has any link with she doing it because she wanted to save MG because she loves him ... because you know that part was totally missing in her dialogues yest 🥱
-Nakshatra- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#34

Originally posted by: Soaps1

Dunno i am confused ... ideally she should not have ... but the only saving grace for me is that in this case Mohan was being punished for no fault of his, i mean bringing a friend home is not a fault for which you should be kicked out of the house ... so that qualifies kastur's sacrifice a little in a different light

And the fact mohan said today she does not have to do it and he has responsibility too makes me think with ot without the sacrifice mohan would have realized love sooner or later ... it was not needed


@Bold: This is where they could have brought a difference if Kastur stood for Mohan and fought the nan sense against Baapji that would be more appropriate and a welcome change in serials. Mohan would have loved Kastur even more if that had happened. CVs why can't you think forward always up with regressive ideas.

That's why i put that question in first place. Mohan doesn't need sacrifice or anything of that sort to realize his love. Even this Sacrifice thing will only make him guilty.
-Nakshatra- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#35

Originally posted by: manasi_31

Oh dont get me started on that ... I absolutely hated and I will keep hating the fact that she took up this blame ... It makes her char so so blunt ...

But maybe it needs to be in our face everytime that she is a dharampatni ... and so she did it just because she is supposed to prove herself an ideal dharampatni and dharambahu 😊 Well thats the only sensible explanation her taking up the blame can have 🤢 I dont feel it has any link with she doing it because she wanted to save MG because she loves him ... because you know that part was totally missing in her dialogues yest 🥱


@Bold: Not only blunt but dumb enough to accept whatever MIL says😡

Thajurba, Kartavya are just fancy words used by Saroj to put Kastur down. This Stupid Kastur who learnt Dp lessons taught by Shardha will keep on following this. And for my own sanity i stick to believe that she decided to take the blame bcoz of her love for Mohan. Like Nads said if they made Kastur reason it based on love it would have been more impactful


Soaps1 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#36
i agree with manasi it was more about kartavey and dharampatni and dharambahu than for love yesterday

And yes kartavey and all are fancy words saroj used but sad fact is kastur believes all that too about the duties of dharampatni and dharambahu ... its not that since saroj said so she accepted it, we have seen in the past that kastur believes in all that too
sam123_0 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#37
I have said this before I am saying it again.. since the dialogue-writer of DP has changed... the new one uses all kind of non-sense words.. but misses out the most important ones😡 Yesterday Kastur saying.. I love you so please let me do it would have been more than enough... there was no need for a Dharampatni lecture there... non-sense
There was no need for them to make Saroj say those words that all bahu's have to do it... bcoz it is their duty.. again non-sense! They could have easily made Saroj say... Mohan it is wrong.. but if kastur does not take the blame, baapji will kick you out and Icant see you living away from me so please let kastur take the brunt... i do feel bad for kastur but let it go this time... (almost like requesting mohan to be quite and leave the matter alone... there was no need for that attitude Saroj to surface there... they never showed saroj feel even an ounce of sadness on realising htat it was NOT kastur who got the sauce but Sia... A mother like Saroj who had come to the airport to receive her son would have felt bad... that is the saroj of before... this saroj is totally different!)
Next where the CVs messed up was... baapji after punishing kastur should have told Sia that kastur did the blunder bcoz of her... so it is better she leave the house.. this is what happens in normal life... didnt kastur say she mis-understood mohan-sia's relation... then why didnt baapji think.. if sia remains in the house.. how will kastur not repeat another mistake... and before that.. why didnt Baapji question Kastur... "if you allowed her to stay at home why did you mis-understand them".. wasnt that a obvious question...
Now if what kastur did is right or not... I am not sure... but that is the only way the matter would have settled... what will be interesting is (if the CVs dont take a 7 day leap😡) what will mohan do... will be go with the 7 day punishment or will make baapji change his mind... Mohan needs to do something to change the rules of this house... baapji did say.. "the weather in the house is changing" so does it mean Mohan is going to make big changes!
-Nakshatra- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#38

Originally posted by: sam123_0

I have said this before I am saying it again.. since the dialogue-writer of DP has changed... the new one uses all kind of non-sense words.. but misses out the most important ones😡 Yesterday Kastur saying.. I love you so please let me do it would have been more than enough... there was no need for a Dharampatni lecture there... non-sense

There was no need for them to make Saroj say those words that all bahu's have to do it... bcoz it is their duty.. again non-sense! They could have easily made Saroj say... Mohan it is wrong.. but if kastur does not take the blame, baapji will kick you out and Icant see you living away from me so please let kastur take the brunt... i do feel bad for kastur but let it go this time... (almost like requesting mohan to be quite and leave the matter alone... there was no need for that attitude Saroj to surface there... they never showed saroj feel even an ounce of sadness on realising htat it was NOT kastur who got the sauce but Sia... A mother like Saroj who had come to the airport to receive her son would have felt bad... that is the saroj of before... this saroj is totally different!)
Next where the CVs messed up was... baapji after punishing kastur should have told Sia that kastur did the blunder bcoz of her... so it is better she leave the house.. this is what happens in normal life... didnt kastur say she mis-understood mohan-sia's relation... then why didnt baapji think.. if sia remains in the house.. how will kastur not repeat another mistake... and before that.. why didnt Baapji question Kastur... "if you allowed her to stay at home why did you mis-understand them".. wasnt that a obvious question...
Now if what kastur did is right or not... I am not sure... but that is the only way the matter would have settled... what will be interesting is (if the CVs dont take a 7 day leap😡) what will mohan do... will be go with the 7 day punishment or will make baapji change his mind... Mohan needs to do something to change the rules of this house... baapji did say.. "the weather in the house is changing" so does it mean Mohan is going to make big changes!


Agreed.. Nothing more to add.
@Bold: Looking forward to this.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".