uknaik99 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 19 years ago
#1
Okay let me start saying I am not A Fan of UA

I rarely watch EMET.. and whenever I watched I saw BS giving very medicore performance... I personally think that Banjo is a bad singer.. and sharib is GOOD but not serious person...

Today I watched the episode where Alka and Abhijeet were judges... BS sang very average.. (while UA did good )I end up wondering how can they came so far 😕😕😕, where the elimanted couples were even bad than these Two..

I am seeing so many post supporting BS.. so I wanted to know - WHAT IS SO SPECIAL ABOUT BS???

Did you see Abhijeet singing at the end of the programme.. now that is what I call SINGING 👏👏😊
Edited by uknaik99 - 19 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

61

Views

3.1k

Users

23

Frequent Posters

rocker1 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: uknaik99

Okay let me start saying I am not A Fan of UA

I rarely watch EMET.. and whenever I watched I saw BS giving very medicore performance... I personally think that Banjo is a bad singer.. and sharib is GOOD but not serious person...

Today I watched the episode where Alka and Abhijeet were judges... BS sang very average.. (while UA did good )I end up wondering how can they came so far 😕😕😕, where the elimanted couples were even bad than these Two..

I am seeing so many post supporting BS.. so I wanted to know - WHAT IS SO SPECIAL ABOUT BS???

Did you see Abhijeet singing at the end of the programme.. now that is what I call SINGING 👏👏😊

Kavita.. simply see the next weeks episodes - esp the one with Madhur Bhandarkar, and you will get the answer.

Or you can also go back one week and see the Kunal Ganjawala episode, particularly the 3rd round, in recording studio.

The particular episode you mention, yes, it was BS' bad day.

Edited by shadyhtown - 19 years ago
apparaohoare thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#3
The only think special in BS is S. B is aweful.
Viewer12345 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: shadyhtown


Kavita.. simply see the next weeks episodes - esp the one with Madhur Bhandarkar, and you will get the answer.


Or you can also go back one week and see the Kunal Ganjawala episode, particularly the 3rd round, in recording studio.


The particular episode you mention, yes, it was BS' bad day.



The fact is that BS had rare good days. Most of the days were bad for them. The reverse is true for UA.

Another thing is BS were Voted Out long time back. They are still at the competition by the mercy of Groovy Gurus as they used Veto power to save them.

I agree with the original post that BS do not deserve to be in the final. Having said that I also agree that they have a very good chance of winning this competition (as they are leading by fair margin from UA). Anyway the fact in India is that hardly the competent contestents win the reality shows.

rocker1 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: Viewer12345


The fact is that BS had rare good days. Most of the days were bad for them. The reverse is true for UA.

Another thing is BS were Voted Out long time back. They are still at the competition by the mercy of Groovy Gurus as they used Veto power to save them.

I agree with the original post that BS do not deserve to be in the final. Having said that I also agree that they have a very good chance of winning this competition (as they are leading by fair margin from UA). Anyway the fact in India is that hardly the competent contestents win the reality shows.

If BS had rare good days, and the reverse was true for UA, then the amount of singing stars for each should also be at opposite ends of the spectrum. But as it turns out, there is a neglibible difference, as I have earlier stated. We calculated UA and BS' average singing stars per round throughout the competition to be 5.38 and 5.08 respectively. That's a difference of .30 stars. Don't tell me that less than half a star difference decides the difference between talent. Note - here we're not even counting the un-rated elimination day performances, where BS were very good.

As far as veto power is concerned, that was something that was already in place under the rules and supposed to be used. Don't call it GG's mercy. They wouldn't give it to anyone who didn't deserve it. And if you go back to C2005, Gajji technically also vetoed the exit of either Nihira/Hemachandra by declaing a tie between them in the early rounds. We all know there was no possibility of an exact tie, and that one of them (possibly Nihira) was obviously eliminated, but was saved by Gajji because it would be unfortunate if either of them left at that point. Does that mean they didn't deserve to be in final 5, because one of them had been voted out long back? At least BS' veto was well within the rules.

And a final note - anyone who supported Debojit in C2005 and hailed Assam's support for him has no right to point fingers at Assam's support of BS. If BS win, their win will be as fair, square, and deserving as Debojit's was.

KDNBKD

Edited by shadyhtown - 19 years ago
sumesh thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 19 years ago
#6
The interesting thing is in one gala they were the worst & they become NO: 1 jodi of that week !!!

Before TOP 3 I have seen many times they get 8's & 9 stars !!!

In rules there was only one veto...They had to use it for SI (Rajkumar death in Karnataka) becoz of that they survived one more week though also improved too!!!

When TV out they said reason of Twinkle's words whcih she said when she become so upset !!!While BS out they said They were nto impressed abt Sharib comments like 1 yr he is in mumbai & all...hey said they r using veto becoz they beleive they got the caliber to NO: 1...

Does that means TV dont have the caliber...If so why they gave them good marks always...Its so sad judges using veto based on their comments !!!They didnt even think they were uspset singing good too they were in bottom line & even 2 face issue & ahamadabad press conference issues !!!They didnt even think the Rajeev drama made them loose much votes too !!!

Anyways in any show who is overhyped or got much appreciation didnt win at all !!!So it wont be any surprise for me If BS wins though I try my maximum to vote for UA!!!

I wish there was some UA fans who got 500 icecream parlor branches !!! 😆 😆 😆
uknaik99 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 19 years ago
#7
only 5 posts???? 😆 😆 😆

Looks like our friends don't know the answer...

and Shady.. few weeks back i asked the same question.. i got the same answer wait till you see next episode, it was just thier bad day.. same thing is happening again n again...
chatbuster thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: shadyhtown

If BS had rare good days, and the reverse was true for UA, then the amount of singing stars for each should also be at opposite ends of the spectrum. But as it turns out, there is a neglibible difference, as I have earlier stated. We calculated UA and BS' average singing stars per round throughout the competition to be 5.38 and 5.08 respectively. That's a difference of .30 stars. Don't tell me that less than half a star difference decides the difference between talent. Note - here we're not even counting the un-rated elimination day performances, where BS were very good.

As far as veto power is concerned, that was something that was already in place under the rules and supposed to be used. Don't call it GG's mercy. They wouldn't give it to anyone who didn't deserve it. And if you go back to C2005, Gajji technically also vetoed the exit of either Nihira/Hemachandra by declaing a tie between them in the early rounds. We all know there was no possibility of an exact tie, and that one of them (possibly Nihira) was obviously eliminated, but was saved by Gajji because it would be unfortunate if either of them left at that point. Does that mean they didn't deserve to be in final 5, because one of them had been voted out long back? At least BS' veto was well within the rules.

And a final note - anyone who supported Debojit in C2005 and hailed Assam's support for him has no right to point fingers at Assam's support of BS. If BS win, their win will be as fair, square, and deserving as Debojit's was.

KDNBKD

LOL grasping for straws. now it is singing stars. conveniently forgot performance stars? now now, science subjects may be important for a science major, but one cant flunk in languages, kyoon? LOL

ok theek hai. maybe LL cant judge. but now 5.08 and 5.38 is also not suficient, especially when averaged over so many episodes? chal phir aise kar, tu bata, what wld be a significant difference?😛

as for the rest of various "analysis", kabhie singing analysis, kabhie star signs, kabhie hometown support justification, kabhie cute pictures of BS on future album covers. arguments taking a walk all around the park, no?😉

Edited by chatbuster - 19 years ago
Anuradha thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 19 years ago
#9
One thing good about BS is that - Let me think.. I am still thinking.. 😉

ok, jokes apart, Sharib is really good.. and Banjotsna is a good singer too and only thing is that she gets tensed often... Sharib is excelent, superb, marvellous singer..

They have the best thing in them - Banjo from assam and Sharib from rajasthan.. The two states can vote till they make them win 😃
mojazwal thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#10
BS = bad singing
Some people find that special

Seriously, there is a lot of focus on how awful Banjo is, but even Sharib is not so special these days. I thought he was much better on C2005 and have been disappointed by his singing as of late. He should spend less time with the hair straightener and more time rehearsing. Or something.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".