DOTW - About Doctors Reservation - Page 2

general category ppl (may not in general case) go through poor life-style often

and there r a lot of so called OBC, SC/ST, who r gaining the benefits of reservation- though living in higher quality life-style - and again gaining the benefits 4 the next generation

but the actual context is that, not according to the financial status or caste, meritorious candidates should get the oppertunity 😊
it'll serve the country better 😊

one more thinng - if there r needy ppl(according to the life-style of them not according to ne caste)... Govt can help them by providing financial help
but reservation isnt the actual solution 4 long run 😊

Originally posted by: pranx

doctors are under essential services n ideally they should never hold patients lives to ransom. But they r normal students too who will be badly affected by this disgusting policy. And if the govt stubbornly turns a blind eye to their problems, wat option are they left with? If its a strike by some union then d govt acts very promptly n approves all their demands. But when students do it they r called villans.

u r also right

if there is no option left to express their views, wat should they do

I agree with all of u

if govt want to help needy ppl then proivide them finacial help that will be better reservation is not the correct way of helping bcoz of reservation they all get admission in colleges they dont deserve and all those who deserve dont get admission

yes mit u r correct

and 4 admission issue, deserving ppl doesnt mean ne caste too , may be one OBC student has gr8er merit than one general catagory student , then he should get the chance 😊

Its easy to say there should b no reservations at all, but tht cannot b a reality when social inequalities still exist in d country. But I feel that only reservations based economic conditions can be justified. Not any other criteria. According to d govt's line of reasoning, OBCs require reservation in order to help them get their economic status on par with d 'general' population
(govt has assumed tht
1.all non-OBCs are cash rich!!
2.all quota ppl work for d upliftment of their community
3.even if the father was a quota student, the upliftment provided is not enuf so his children are still eligible for quota!!😆 😆 )
If tht is d case, y confine urself to 1 particular caste only? Include all d economically backward ppl in reservation- high caste or low caste. The objective should b 2 erase d caste divide; not making it more prominent.

But I guess this quota thing started by Babasaheb Ambedkar and he asked goverment only 10 yrs and then they will not require ne quota but this thing is still going on and the reason is that all the political parties want votes from these backward class thats y they r not removing it

And other thing this thing was started bcoz there was injustice taking place on backward class but now due to thing all the cast r facing injustice

I strongly say that this quota thing should not be continue if not then there will be a day where a person getting 80 will not get admission bcoz of such a high rate of compidition and ppl with 40 will get in easily

Mittz i beieve the quota sysytem was started by ambedkar. Coz he was from the backward class.

ya I was thinking that only thanx I will edit now 😛