tin eared judges

After acting as judge on so many singing shows, Anu Malik has finally become tin eared. Yeh to hona hi tha ek din. Although he claims that a slight note shift makes him upset, but he and alisha both were looking stupid when they praised Ragini for her immaculate singing for her song 'mugda' and twice they brought Ragini in top two with her out of tune, club type songs. Then they gave her full marks, wow, Anu Malik finally has started losing his credibility as a music director and a judge. Then when Manasi sang her song 'lambi judaai' after Ragini sang 'kaisi paheli zindagani' it was so difficult for Anu Malik to differentiate the quality and level of singing between the two performances, he could hardly see any difference, just half a mark??? Alisha is a sweet person and also she never bullies any performer nor she claims to be a Miss perfect.

In my opinion, Anu Malik should understand that we all can make errors in our judgement but he made his bias very obvious which was observed by the other participants too.

Itni bhi andher nagri nahin hai, theek hai reality show hai, but its not bigg boss, it is dependant on individual's performances.

I have only seen bits and pieces of the last few shows. But I have the problem with the scoring of Mansi. According to Anu Malik, she made a few minor mistakes. Yet he still gives her a perfect ten. I am sorry I thought a ten was for perfect singing. If she had few mistakes, I would think she would deserve a nine instead of ten.

Originally posted by: vcoolwater

I have only seen bits and pieces of the last few shows. But I have the problem with the scoring of Mansi. According to Anu Malik, she made a few minor mistakes. Yet he still gives her a perfect ten. I am sorry I thought a ten was for perfect singing. If she had few mistakes, I would think she would deserve a nine instead of ten.

But then again, everyone has determined that Mansi is the winner. I have never seen a reality show so lopsided to one contestant. The only contest who could compete with her was Sachin. However he getting lower scores than he was in the beginning. Now they are using Raigini's popularity to compete with Mansi for TRP sake. However it is just for show.

Mansi has been declared the winner since day one. Even Mansi herself is acting like she has already won the competition. She acts like she is better than anyone. I think she needs to tone it down already.

Thats why I said tin eared judges. What you have mentioned here goes more in line with my other post 'another hoax'. First week Manasi is no. 1, second week Manasi is in bottom three, third week Manasi no. 1 again. She acts complacent, but I guess she is a trained one and has been doing shows with her group at corporate level and also rendered her voice in chorus in movie Dev Das. During the practise sessions you know the singing ability of your competition. Sumeet and waqas lack the rockstar material whereas Manish still has a better showmanship. Sachin was hyped in the beginning but now he is back in his place. Chhavi has guts and tries to attempt songs which is outside of her comfort zone, Manasi also does that. Manish tried Maula mere lay le meri jaan but he was out at quite a few places but again Anu Malik seemed impressed.
They can add twisters to make the TRP skyrocket to heavens but atleast don't make a 'phudoo' out of their veiwers by calling black a white and vice versa.
But a music director with tin ears???????????? Unbelievable.

I agree. When Ragini was singing last week, her voice was actually hurting my ears and I wanted to turn off the T.V. It is nice to see performers feeling uninhibited, but the 'Gala faad' singing of Ragini and at times of Mansi are not appreciated .They should sing a variety of songs.

Originally posted by: SGPianShehreen

PEOPLE!! Why are you soo against Ragini! She is a good singer!! Just becuz Ragini is a good competitor for Mansi!! Mansi is a really good singer!! She has an amazing voice!! no doubt! But Ragini has got a amazing voice too! Dont criticize her! Ragini can sing in both high ans slow level!! When Mansi sang 'Azma Luck' ..it was hurting my ears!! but the judges praised her!!but when mansi sang ' Iktara' i loved it!!!

Ragini is a good singer! She has knowledge of sur and everything!! she is a good singer!! ADMIT IT! everyone has their own choice!!...If you dont like her dont criticize her ! There are alot more weeks to come..wait and watch ...Maybe becuz of the song choice you people dont like Ragini's singing at all! I ADMIT the songs ragini has choosen till now were nt really impressive!! 😳 but doesn't mean she is a bad singer!!!! She has the potential to sing!! If you think Anu Malik has started to get ear problems/or he doesnt have any knowledge about singing than fine! what about Alisha?? She also praises Ragini...Now she doesnt have ear problems at all?? 😳 Mansi is a great singer , they all are great singers! someone has to loose someone has to win!! Ragini is a good singer ...maybe you dont agree ..😳 Well , I am a ragini fan...I love her acting...and I LOVE HER SINGING! I didnt like her shammi kapoor's special performance...but doesnt mean she is a bad singer!

You must be a Ragini fan!! Thats why you missed the topic. 😃(just kidding!!) Its not a matter of liking or disliking someone, its just that the judges are there to judge the singing abilities of the performers. Acha lagnay aur acha honey mein faraq hai. Har maan ko uss ka baita acha lagta hai, chahe acha ho na ho. So you love Ragini, I respect that but if you say that she is better or equal to someone we have also heard singing than the bias in your opinion is obvious. .Alisha is a singer herself and also displayed her inability in so many cases, because the show is a hoax. Ragini has a good sense of humor and can dance much better than others on the show, but singing.. If she sings one complex composition and she will be out. She did a mistake of singing lag ja gale and after that she is only getting away with club type songs. I would love to see her singing 'lambi judaai'
Since good or bad is abstract, so I may agree with you that she is not a bad singer, but few others are much better than her.
But why are Anu Malik and Alisha ruining their credibility????

Let aside comparing Manasi and Ragini like apples to oranges and look the show the way it is supposed to be looked at.

why r u saying that they r using ragini's stardom.neha has also achieved stardom but they didnot used her stardom