ROSHNI'S STATEMENTS TO JAI POINT TO.....

Hello All:

Everyone has been busy over the weekend. Savi made some wonderful videos for our enjoyment and most of the other members are trying to analyze the pregnancy report.

However, for some time now I have been concentrating on Roshni and her dialogues especially with Jai.

This is what I have come up with:

I was reading the update in which Doyel wrote that Roshni tells Jai that

'she knew it clearly that how their secret if revealed can affect lives of each one of the members of walia house.' I saw the uploaded video ( 3 times) where she says if the raaz comes out 'kis kis ko kahan tak' it will effect. (She also said the same thing to Jai on the day Rano hit her with the car)

This had me thinking what could be the common factor that could affect each one of the members of the walia house and I got the answer – Aditya.

Aditya, Kiran, Jai and Roshni were friends.Jai and Aditya both met Kiran at polo matches. Aditya and Kiran became close friends and one thing leads to another……..Aditya was never told by Kiran about Bani because he was married or engaged to Jigyasa. She came in contact with Jai years later and revealed everything to him since she was having health complications due to being a diabetic. She may have confessed to her husband Nishikant who knew the truth. To keep him quiet Jai must be giving him money. Jai was friends with Roshni at that time so she knew everything. The meeting took place on Park Road. Jai was driving with a distracted mine and they had an accident in which Roshni was injured. That is why his guilt towards Roshni and helping her. Roshni must be insisting on bringing this out in the open and so the fallout in their relationship.

Both Kiran and Aditya are older than Jai. If Bani is Aditya's daughter and the secret is revealed it would change all relations in that house:

Bani would be Aditya's biological but illegitimate daughter and Dadi's biological grand-daughter.

Jigs would be the step-mom (ex).

Ranveer, Sahil and Anu would be her half-siblings on Aditya's side.

Rano and Pia half sisters on Kiran's side.

And Jai and Bani would not be related at all so their relationship would be OK. For him the welfare and honor of the family is at stake. Even though Adi and Jigs are divorced it would still be a blow to her to know her ex has an illegitimate daughter from a relationship.

This would shake up the whole relationship equation in that house. Bani would never forgive Jai from keeping the truth from her. She would have a terrible identity crisis. Now he is emotionally involved with Bani (most probably in love with her). Also Aditya is Jai's best friend and Dadi has treated him like her own son and they would be hurt and angry at Jai for keeping this secret from him. It would effect Jai's and Aditya's friendship in a big way. Aditya was married to Jai's sister and now Jai is married to Aditya's daughter. This is why Jai is so horrified with the truth coming out now and the fact that he was rattled only after Roshni's entry. Till then Jai was not affected by the situation at all.

Nobody was killed in any car accident. I say this because when they went to the temple they were driving on Park Road. They were scared because they remembered the accident. But that night they show Roshni fast asleep and Jai sleeping like a baby on the couch. If Park Road had such horrible memories about someone being killed, no on would be able to sleep that soundly.

Symbolism so far – Aditya keeps referring to Bani as his daughter. Even in the farmhouse video he says every father would be proud to have a daughter like Bani.

He is the only one who had this immediate bonding with Bani right from the beginning.

She is always taking his aashirwaad for everything.

He did Bani's kanyadaan to Jai at the time of wedding. (Aditya thought he was doing Pia's)

Today Bani refers to Anu as a younger sister.

Otherwise why would Jai promise somebody he barely knew to look after their daughters if something happened to them? Why does he give Bani a good job and give them a comfortable lifestyle? He must have promised because Kiran may have wanted Bani to reach her real father and Jai may have stopped that for the sake of the family and taken it on himself to look after them little knowing what that would eventually lead to. He may have made some detached deal which has now become personal and he himself is deeply emotionally involved.

The only thing not matching up is the crystals and why it is Jai's dark past and what is his real relationship with Roshni. (Maybe Kiran and Roshni are related or were best friends). Don't know if it is connected or not.

I am only putting forth my theory and I can be absolutely, completely wrong and something totally different may emerge. But I just had to share this with everyone. It's spinning in my head.

Sorry if I have bored you and this seems impossible. But sometimes when everyone is trying to dig deep we may just miss the obvious!

I would love to have everyone's feedback on this.

very well written pinky. But, i guess v will al have to wait for the truth to unfurl itslef. I am sure Ekta's creative team does not know the truth themselves 😆 , at this minute they r scrppaing up things to fit the jigsaw puzzle together.

Wow...great theory!! Sounds good to me, you could be right on target! Really enjoyed reading it, well written...made complete sense to me 😊

Hi Pink,

We did discuss this before and and as I said earlier, I find your theory to make a lot of sense and to be pretty logical, ofcourse a few loopholes are still there, but then the Makers might just be deliberately confusing us!

The byword of the Mystery Funda is that whenever the Mystery will come out, "All the relationships in the Walia House will get a jolt / undergo a change"...safely assuming that Bani and Jai have no blood bond, which is pretty clear by now, then the only bond she can have with is Aditya...by virtue of which Bani will be sister to Ranveer, Sahil and Anu....who are the nephew and nieces of Jai....

I think the one reason that Jai is so terrified of the truth coming out might be that incase Bani is Aditya's daughter, he has knowingly married his best friend's child, which is a pretty odd situation...for everyone...marrying an acquaintance's daughter was one thing, but getting married to your oldest and best friend's daughter is simply another!

What has always struck me is the horror and shock that Jai went through when the reality of his marriage to Bani sunk in his mind...I could understand Jai's anger and hatred towards the girl who became his unwanted wife, but what I couldn't understand was the "shock" and "disbelief" that Jai went through...remember, how he even flinched when Bani came anywhere near him, in the inital days of their marriage!

And now also, when Jai is quite in love with Bani or atleast very much on his way, he still wants to get seperated from her...as if he wants to stop a Pandora's box from opening...

Bani is connected to the Walia Family in some deep way and the only possible connection I can see is through Aditya...the relationship between Aditya and Bani has always been that of a Father and Daughter, the most telling part being Aditya doing the Kanyaadan for Bani!

Now, if Jai hadn't known this truth beforehand, things could have been different, but the fact is that he knew about Bani being Aditya's daughter from a long time and hence he dreads this fact to come out in the open...everyone involved will be shattered, especially Aditya and Bani!

But then there are still a lot of things unaccounted for....

Overall, I love your theory and of all the theories I have read, this kind of makes the maximum sense to me...lets see what happens!

Cheers,

MT

Pinky,
As I read through your analysis, the idea became more and more feasible. You are absolutely right about someone not getting killed...I think we are on the wrong track with this one.

There are two things that do not add up though -
1. Crystals - You already mentioned this one.
2. Aditya's age. In your analysis you said Adi was older than Jai. THis is incorrect. I distinctly remember, Jai retorting to Jigs once that he never made any objections when she wanted to marry Adi even though she was older than Adi by two years.
This makes Adi, younger than Jai, Jigz and Kiran Singhania..

Also, when Jai and Adi were sitting in their car, soon after the trio arrived from Mt. Abu. Jai was telling Adi, "Remember Kiran Singhania? blah blah.." and Adi never looked shocked or affected. He ws very Matter-of-fact.

What say you?

Cheers
Darcy

Ha Darcy, The age thing is extremely botched up in Kasamh Se!

According to what has been shown till now, we are clear on only the ages of two people in the Story, Jai who is 40 years old and Bani who is 23 years old!

Jigyasa is younger than Jai, even if she is just a year younger, that makes her 39! As you said before, it has been mentioned that Aditya is 2 years younger than Jigyasa, which makes him 37!

Now that is really wierd...even if Ranveer is just 20 years old, does that mean, Adiyta was 17 when he was born! 😆 I mean, how on Earth is that possible, yaar!!!

The makers are a bit confused on the Age issue...I think intially they wanted to show Jigyasa being elder to Jai, which would have made more sense, considering she has three grown up children...but later, they showed her younger than Jai, as he was to be shown as the Head of the Family!

Aditya cannot be younger than Jai...he has to be older, incase Bani is his daughter!

I don't think the Crystal thing is very important...neither was it ever mentioned afterwards nor was Jai ever shown with the Crystal again...Bani anyway threw her Crystal in the Ocean...

I kind of have a strong feeling that Aditya and Bani are indeed connected...and Jai might have been the one who would have willfully seperated Aditya and Bani's Mother because Jigyasa was in love with Aditya or maybe married to him already...all said and done, Jai is the sort of guy who would do anything for his Family's happiness!

Yes, the accident did not kill anyone, but what might have happened was that Roshni would have come to know of the secret and in the shock, Jai might have banged his Car causing her grevious injury....and then given her enough money to shut her up forever...

Also, I have a feeling that Bani is not Kiran Singhania's daugher either, she is Aditya and someone else's child....Jai would have made some deal with Nishikant to adopt Bani as their own child in lieu of Financial help from him...

Yes, I remember Aditya shows no reaction on the mention of Kiran Singhania and if Bani was indeed her daughter, then Jai wouldn't have mentioned her in front of Aditya...

Cheers,

MT

Thanks Darcy for pointing out that Aditya is younger than Jigz. Also I have not watched the serial from the beginning so I do not know about the conversation between Jai and Aditya.

There are loopholes I know but I just had to put this up as a track although I was hesitant due to the fact that I started watching it after Bani started her job at the hotel.

Anyways lets see what the creators have in store for us. Appreciate your feedback.

hey nice theory, could be true but then again you can never guess on an Ekta Kappor Serial

**P.S: what's the deal with the crystels??? I mean I don't recall an such incident. Help?

oh wow pinky your theory is just so mind boggling, it just jolted me, it never crossed my thick brain 😆 😆 😆 that adity could be bani's dad or could not be we just have to wait and watch. but i still feel that you might be on the right track but we are all still missing some pieces in the puzzle.yeah remember at pias some rasam thing he becomes the mamaji and puts the bangles on her hand. 😕 😕 i still think that roshni has a big part in this besides knowing the raaz.
omg if this is true i can't wait to see jigyasa reaction. she will definitly throw bani out of the house. hey but rano and sahil won't be related right 😃 😃 what do youll say

ya the age thing is a bit dodgey in ks...
could roshni be related to bani? that would totally change the family dynamics too..
whats the deal with the crystals actually???
great theories and analysis guyz u rok!