Jaise tu chhor aaya tha...

*Reemz* thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#1
Oops they did it again ☺️☺️☺️ What did they do? They said everything with those expressions. Though there have been topics about the GK meeting today, I had to point out the line in my topic. The decision to break the DV was hers not his but today when Gulaal replied with 'Jaise tu chhor aaya tha', she didn't just mean it in the literal sense of dropping her off home. It was her way of asking him 'why did you leave me?' and I sensed that even yesterday with her expression when Kesar agreed to break the DV. It's like she needed that push from him, just once if he had clearly rejected the break up!! But he didn't...! Kesar is letting her go when she doesn't want to at all but what explanation does she give to that emotion? You have to see Manasi's expression when and after she says those words. It was simply marvellous!!! Gulaal looked so in love today, through her smile and tears. Once again, hats off to the writers for showing her change so gracefully and realistically. She was already missing Kesar but the extent only hit her when she actually SAW him. They only had eyes for each other 😍 Did you see that big grin on her face? That's what true love does to you.

Jzee ab mein tere topic mein aa rahi hu baaki ka scene discuss karne! :P

Created

Last reply

Replies

13

Views

2k

Users

7

Likes

84

Frequent Posters

AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#2
*sigh* Love the title! One of my FAV. lines from the scene today😍 Copy/pasting what I said about it elsewhere:

My fav. exchange in that scene is:

"Acchi lag rahi hai"

"Kaisa hai tu?"

"Tu kaisi hai?"

"Jaisi tu chhod aaya tha"

There is such simplicity and the dialogues are JUST RIGHT...that is where the magic comes from.

I mean just think...first he tells her she's looking nice...she doesn't reply and instead asks him how HE is...he also doesn't reply to that and instead asks her how SHE is...and what does she say in reply?? Jaisi tu CHHOD aaya tha"...I think that is such a BEAUTIFUL line yaar...it has SO much meaning in it that I doubt even Gulaal realizes what she just said there..."jaisi tu chhod aaya"...as you left me...does she realize the wistfulness in that line?

Manasi was SUPERB today...the transition in Gulaal was so wonderfully shown! I can go on and on about the wonderfully nuanced actress she is👏...and Neil was fantastic as always...goes without saying... I'm gonna post CAPS soon to elaborate ;-)

*Edit to add one more bit:

Their expressions when they see each other at the mandir...Kesar ki reaction toh chalo phir bhi expected thi...GULAAL'S reaction is very intriguing...the way she falls back and just watches him with so much emotion in her eyes...and when he finally walks over to her, you can see the joy on her face, in her body language too at seeing him again...Koi KAASH Gulaal ko us waqt mirror dikha sakta😆


Edited by nureat01 - 14 years ago
..Anita.. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#3
She is falling in love now
she really misses keasar
i am so happy
*Reemz* thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: nureat01

*sigh* Love the title! One of my FAV. lines from the scene today😍 Copy/pasting what I said about it elsewhere:

My fav. exchange in that scene is:

"Acchi lag rahi hai"

"Kaisa hai tu?"

"Tu kaisi hai?"

"Jaisi tu chhod aaya tha"

There is such simplicity and the dialogues are JUST RIGHT...that is where the magic comes from.

I mean just think...first he tells her she's looking nice...she doesn't reply and instead asks him how HE is...he also doesn't reply to that and instead asks her how SHE is...and what does she say in reply?? Jaisi tu CHHOD aaya tha"...I think that is such a BEAUTIFUL line yaar...it has SO much meaning in it that I doubt even Gulaal realizes what she just said there..."jaisi tu chhod aaya"...as you left me...does she realize the wistfulness in that line?

Manasi was SUPERB today...the transition in Gulaal was so wonderfully shown! I can go on and on about the wonderfully nuanced actress she is👏...and Neil was fantastic as always...goes without saying... I'm gonna post CAPS soon to elaborate ;-)

*Edit to add one more bit:

Their expressions when they see each other at the mandir...Kesar ki reaction toh chalo phir bhi expected thi...GULAAL'S reaction is very intriguing...the way she falls back and just watches him with so much emotion in her eyes...and when he finally walks over to her, you can see the joy on her face, in her body language too at seeing him again...Koi KAASH Gulaal ko us waqt mirror dikha sakta😆



I'm VERY excited for the caps!!😳

Oh so true about Gulaal's initial reaction. You could sense her silent excitement!! She was so sinking it all in. There was HER Kesar and he was running towards her. All Gulaal could see was HIM!

The whole conversation was so beautiful especially when Kesar goes 'Tujhe kisne kaha maine tere liye liye hai?'. He said it SO CUTELY!!! Oh and how I loved her reaction when he said 'Tere siva kisi aur ke liye leh sakta hu mein?'.

They're epic dude! Simply EPIC!
*Reemz* thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: anita_21492

She is falling in love now

she really misses keasar
i am so happy


I think she's been in love with him for a long time now. It's only about the realization ;)
snehasri thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#6
when this is going so so so lovely . ye weekend bhi dikhaya hota kitana achha hoga na
Premeer_Mayur thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#7

finally Gulaal is realising her luv for Kesar...she misses him all the time...can't wait when she confesses it. 😍

Edited by Premeer_Mayur - 14 years ago
ChicagoCarole1 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#8
I so agree...she is falling in love now...not out of some duty of the DV but because she now has Kesar in her heart. She wants to be with him so badly, she just doesn't know how ...one move from him and she is his!!! I can hardly wait!

So what have you done in this world if you have never fallen in love?
VJ-LNMDJ thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: *Reemz*

Oops they did it again ☺️☺️☺️ What did they do? They said everything with those expressions. Though there have been topics about the GK meeting today, I had to point out the line in my topic. The decision to break the DV was hers not his but today when Gulaal replied with 'Jaise tu chhor aaya tha', she didn't just mean it in the literal sense of dropping her off home. It was her way of asking him 'why did you leave me?' and I sensed that even yesterday with her expression when Kesar agreed to break the DV. It's like she needed that push from him, just once if he had clearly rejected the break up!! But he didn't...! Kesar is letting her go when she doesn't want to at all but what explanation does she give to that emotion? You have to see Manasi's expression when and after she says those words. It was simply marvellous!!! Gulaal looked so in love today, through her smile and tears. Once again, hats off to the writers for showing her change so gracefully and realistically. She was already missing Kesar but the extent only hit her when she actually SAW him. They only had eyes for each other 😍 Did you see that big grin on her face? That's what true love does to you.

Jzee ab mein tere topic mein aa rahi hu baaki ka scene discuss karne! :P



Very well written ...that was the best dialogue of the day - even if there were many more wonderful ones...
You really hit the nail on the head - it had touched me and stayed with me - that line - and her expressions and tears as she said them...but I had then moved on to so much else that further happened in the few instants of their meeting...
"jaise tu chod aaya thaa" has such a sweet and sad "shikwaa - shikaayat" hidden in it ...u are so right , its as if she thought "even if I left you under some compulsions, how could YOU leave me "

This reminded me of what she said the night he took care of her in fever...when she asked, after getting back Kesar's care and concern after ages, "Kesar, tu kahaan thaa ab tak? " ...whose meaning he missed in the first instance and innocently said "yuhi doston ke saath ghumne gayaa tha" ..till she said "maine woh nahin kahaa tha" and he saw her smile and understood the meaning behind her words...

This time , I think he missed the underlying message as he went on to see how different she was today... but soon he will realise what she now feels ..and she will too...and how beautiful will that be !

thanks for bringing up this beautiful point...

VJ

*Reemz* thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#10
[quote]"jaise tu chod aaya thaa" has such a sweet and sad "shikwaa - shikaayat" hidden in it ...u are so right , its as if she thought "even if I left you under some compulsions, how could YOU leave me "[/quote]

YES! She always kind of depends on him to make the first move and even in yesterdays scene it was as if Gulaal was just waiting for him to say something which she wouldn't be able to refuse to any more.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".