The Mothers of Balika Vadhu

-Purva- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Engager Level 4 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#1
Don't you all think that except for Gehna and Dadisa all the mothers in Balika Vadhu are failures?

Here's why I think so:

Bhago - Obsessed with getting her daughter married. After marriage, forces Anandi out of school and then insists on sending her to the Saasra, when one of the village girls elopes. Despite Bhairon's objection, Anandi is sent away from her mother's house (traditionally in child marriages a girl is sent to the Saasra only after she reaches puberty like Suguna, but because of Bhago's obsession Anandi is sent here as a child). When Anandi runs away after being locked up by Dadisa, Bhago sends her back to the Saasra and convinces Anandi that she should lead her life only as per the dictates of Dadisa. That was a lesson Anandi would remember all her life. Bhago's involvement in Anandi's life has ever since been quite minimal, till her recent volte-face in accusing the very same saasra of ill-treating Anandi.

Sumitra - Timid by nature, she is content to leave the upbringing of her son in the hands of her mother-in-law. She has no idea of where her children are and what they are up to. She is equally at loss when Jagya gets into bad company at school, Suguna gets pregnant or Anandi (whom she treats as a foster daughter) is bullied by Dadisa. All she has done all her life is shed tears, and Jagya's second marriage has given her fresh reason to indulge in her favorite activity around the house.

Suguna - So involved is Suguna in winning the approval of Shyam's family that she fails to notice that Tausa is harming her son or terrorizing him after breaking his legs. In as much as Tausa, Suguna too is equally guilty for the handicap of her son.

Phooli's Mother - First she treats Phooli as a burden because she is widowed at an early age, then she tries to get Phooli married off to someone, knowing fully well that the man she is getting her 10 yr old married to is at least 20 yrs her senior. Phooli's education is only because of Bhairon's insistence. When the village louts harass Phooli, again the mother disappears from the scene and actually doubts and berates her own daughter. Then she tries to sell Phooli to get rid of her debts. Luckily for Phooli her dead husband's brother wants a child and so is ready to keep Phooli as his second wife, No idea what the future has in store for her, however.

Gaur's mother - Less said about her the better.

Gehna and Dadisa - Amazing way they are bringing up their children. I commend Dadisa for the values she has given Basant and Bhairon. Kalyani Devi might not be a good Mother-in-law or a model Grandmother. But when it comes to being a mother, she wins hands down. The other strong mother is Gehna. I like the way she is hawk-eyed about her son's education and even keeps a vigil on who he is playing with and his leisure activities. Way to go girl.

Created

Last reply

Replies

5

Views

3.2k

Users

5

Likes

18

Frequent Posters

vsumeetha thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#2
I beg to differ but I do not think Dadisa was that good a mother. Agreed that we are tempted to conclude this when we know bhairav but if you look at basanth before he got married and had a son with gehna you will see what kind of values she tried to inculcate within him.

Basanth's notions of manhood and rights of a husband (which is basically raping your own wife ) came from DS. Thankfully Bhairav was made of a different material and none of her teachings rubbed off on him.

But I will not agree that DS is a good mother.
tinoo thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#3
I agree with vsumeetha . Dadisa did raise her two children as a very, very young widow, and for doing that, particularly in the times she grew up, she needs to be given credit. I know she was poor and then she became wealthy through her hard work. The haveli was not ancestral wealth - she built it brick by brick. Over the course of three years, so many people have said to her "Kalyani, I remember the days when you went to work with two small children" .
In that respect, the fact that she raised two kids is awesome, and yes neither starved to death and her kids grew up healthy and educated to whatever level.
But the values that Bhairon has can hardly be credited to dadisa's upbringing. That can only be credited to exposure to certain other types of thinking/education and perhaps an inherent sense of right and wrong that all of us have without really needing to look to see if there is a law/legislation that mandates right behaviour.
Basant, quite frankly grew up like an untamed animal. If at all he is the way he is today and appears appealing to people - full credit should go to Gehna for her understanding and shaping his new personality - not dadisa.
intruderfast thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: vsumeetha

I beg to differ but I do not think Dadisa was that good a mother. Agreed that we are tempted to conclude this when we know bhairav but if you look at basanth before he got married and had a son with gehna you will see what kind of values she tried to inculcate within him.


Basanth's notions of manhood and rights of a husband (which is basically raping your own wife ) came from DS. Thankfully Bhairav was made of a different material and none of her teachings rubbed off on him.

But I will not agree that DS is a good mother.

i agree gehna is a good mother no doubt on that point but ds no, they way she poisoned basant mind against gehna time to time , it was bad basanth is more or less like ds only, he has changed somewhat, bhairon is a gr8 man but i wont give ds credit for that,
bhairon simply was a very good person , from the beginning
Edited by intruderfast - 14 years ago
Blukitten thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#5
Basant is DS's nephew not her own son...DS is actually his chachi...his father was a bad person in his younger days.
Being brought up by DS he is not tht bad...but some shortcoming of his father is bound to rub on him...DS's husband seems to be a very nice person frm whatever flashback scenes they have shown thts why Bhairov is also good he has got father's nature
Both of them must have got same upbringing frm Dadisa they different nature can be genetic since they have different fathers with drastically diferent nature.
vsumeetha thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#6
Though genes do play a big role, it is also nurturing and upbringing that matters. Basanth in the initial days seemed more like the true son of DS. DS brought up both of them and probably gave them both the same nurturing. But her attitudes towards the daughter-in-law of the house, her obsession with male child and the condescending way she behaves towards the parents of her daughter-in-law did manifest in basanth. When Basanth got married to Gehna and she refused to sleep with him, bhairav tried to explain to basanth about building a emotional relationship before having a physical but DS comes to him and tells him that he should go and sleep with her irrespective of whether she is interested in him or not.

Bhairav seems to have an innate sense of right and wrong despite her upbringing for which we should be thankful. DS herself has expressed her disappointment in his attitudes several times.

1) when he refused to send Suguna to Pratap's house even after she attained puberty
2) when he enrolled anandi in the school along with J
3) when he stands for anandi, gehna or sumithra against DS
4) when he keeps vrat along with his wife

I guess he is what he is despite DS's influence. But that does not mean that she is a great mother. She was just lucky that she had two sons who did not put her to shame. Unfortunately for Bhairav, J turned out to be biggest jack ass.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".