Sonu deserved to lose Sahiti

cl0wn thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#1
Wow, we lost Sahiti today... that's awful... she deserved to be in the Top 3!

I think this is a lesson for Sonu for being oversmart last week and voting out Piyush when he needed to stand by him and let the terrible Amit Jadhav go home! It sends a wrong message to the audience and that is why, today we saw Shreya's team was completely safe, which is such a shock! This wouldn't have happened if Sonu stood by his own singers, who were much better than everyone!

Yeah right, you will say that Sonu was very honest last time by judging them only on the FACE-OFF round, so where did the honesty disappear today? Yes, I myself say that Sajda sisters DEFINITELY sung better today in the face-off round, so why did he take Sahiti's name then? Sorry but it was too late to support your own team now, Sonu. Let me repeat, he sent the audience a wrong message by supporting a singer like Amit last time.

Piyush, Sahiti and Seema were the best contestants in the show and it is a disgrace to see them go and I blame Sonu to some extent for her elimination. When their own mentor supports contestants of other teams, this is what happens.

Anyways, let's hope that the ONLY HORSE left in his team now, Seema, gives the toughest fight to all the other contestants now and emerges as the winner in the end. If a solo singer deserves to win the title of X-FACTOR, there is one and only one contender left: SEEMA JHA!

P.S. I forgot to mention one very important thing. In every reality show, we have been complaining that the audience votes out all the better contestants and keeps the bad ones in and the judges have no say in the eliminations. But now, when the judges luckily have such an opportunity in a show like X-Factor where they can save the better contestants from getting eliminated inspite of them getting lesser votes from the audience , are the judges really utilizing that opportunity???

All the good singers are still getting kicked out, and the bad ones are still stuck right in there!

Edited by cl0wn - 14 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

14

Views

1.9k

Users

9

Likes

24

Frequent Posters

music-a-muse thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#2
😆I don't think it has anything to do with audience or their votes.😳

Votes are one factor. there are lot of other factors.

You seriously think people like Sonu or shreya who are literally masters in the music field do not know good from bad singers?😆

In the end, it is what has been pre decided by the producer, advertisers, channel and the judges play a minimal role in the whole process.

that is what i wrote before that all the judges have sold their soul ie . music for money in these reality shows..The judges are mere puppets.

Harsh, unpalatable but true.😳
Edited by musicmuse - 14 years ago
music-a-muse thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: cl0wn

Wow, we lost Sahiti today... that's awful... she deserved to be in the Top 3!

I think this is a lesson for Sonu for being oversmart last week and voting out Piyush when he needed to stand by him and let the terrible Amit Jadhav go home! It sends a wrong message to the audience and that is why, today we saw Shreya's team was completely safe, which is such a shock! This wouldn't have happened if Sonu stood by his own singers, who were much better than everyone!

Yeah right, you will say that Sonu was very honest last time by judging them only on the FACE-OFF round, so where did the honesty disappear today? Yes, I myself say that Sajda sisters DEFINITELY sung better today in the face-off round, so why did he take Sahiti's name then? Sorry but it was too late to support your own team now, Sonu. Let me repeat, he sent the audience a wrong message by supporting a singer like Amit last time.

Piyush, Sahiti and Seema were the best contestants in the show and it is a disgrace to see them go and I blame Sonu to some extent for her elimination. When their own mentor supports contestants of other teams, this is what happens.

Anyways, let's hope that the ONLY HORSE left in his team now, Seema, gives the toughest fight to all the other contestants now and emerges as the winner in the end. If a solo singer deserves to win the title of X-FACTOR, there is one and only one contender left: SEEMA JHA!


If it is a group?
cl0wn thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#4


That's a tough one. All 3 groups are really good (unlike all 3 singers in Shreya's team 😕) but if I had to pick one, I'd pick NIRMITEE because there is THAT x-factor in them.

Either way, Seema and Sahiti were like playback-singers and it's awful to see even one of them go so soon.

I wonder why they don't have a VETO power to reverse an elimination, like they did in Indian Idol. Weirdos.
Padmajaan thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voice of India 2024 Participant Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#5
I totally totally agree with each and every thing that you said in your post. It totally reflects my views.
Thanks
Padma
annu_ms thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#6
Sahiti Of all ?Is this a musical show?Geet was so horrible today.People like Nirmiti & entire Shreya team is there & sahiti has to go.Pathetic 😳. Now the result is Seema since sonu has to be there to judge.They can take out the name Reality show.
chiru_ thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#7
The question is if Sahiti deserves to be in bottom two.

My views totally reflect those of SLB's.

This is a pathetic asessment of talent by means of public voting and comparing groups with solos. However this was a means for her to reach out to a large audience
-Nightingale- thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#8

Sonu definitely deserved it...but not Sahiti...poor girl after her 2 fine performances got eliminated...😳

people always complained about her diction..which she seemed to have corrected this week..👏.
makers n judges does not seem to think of deserving candidates future😳
akash08 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#9
Sahiti and good singer? my foot.. Except Seema Jha and Nimriti none deserves to be in this platform. Who cares if they stay or go..all awful.
Sahiti was saved at the cost of a better contestant (Sovan) once, She already overstayed 5-6 weeks.. high time to go.
And I salute Sonu.. He is the only real honest judge.Though he stood by Sahiti, he made it clear that he is not doing so because she is better than Sajda sisters.. just because she is from his team..
Week after weeks Sahiti gave worst performances.. Where are people getting good performances?Last 5-6 weeks , she was criticised in her every performance by the judges..
Edited by akash08 - 14 years ago
suresh555 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#10
Why complain only about Geet and Amit? The other judges too have bad contestants that are overrated, I'd take Geet and amit anyday over Sahiti and Sajda's screaming singing. There are very few performances where they were good.

I cracked up today when they gave Sajda sisters the silver coin over Seema's Abhiman number. Sonu calling Audience "Papi" was the joke of the century and SLB whining about how good singers were lost and bad ones are still there was a drama queen act.

I believe that the audience is finally catching up with SLB & Sonu's nautanki and disregarding their team. I think their Paap of constantly bullying Geet and Amit is working against them. I have yet to see such unfair judges like Sonu & SLB
Edited by suresh555 - 14 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".