MSK Memory Loss- A Genuine Condition or A Mask

Page

Next Last

@rickks

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 14 years ago

Okay Since MSK's Selective Memory Track Started its bcome the Most Talked about Topic be it here on IF or on Facebook,And after today's episode discussions and debates have grown by leaps and bounds

Hence Lets Just try to find out, ki what one actually feels and thinks about MSK's Memory Loss, ki Whether He is Faking it? or Whether Its Genuine etc...

If he is Faking is what do you think is making him do it...If He is Not Faking it why do you think He was All restless in the Album seq????

So what's your Intuition Saying????

Does Maan Singh Khuarna have Selective Amnesia?

or

Is Maan Singh Khuarna using Selective Amnesia as a Mask to accomplish his Motive?

Do Leave Your Comments

Hit The Like Button if you like what you read...

Love Viji

Note: This Post is not opened so as to Feed Ideas into CV's head or to that of the IF members or anything of that sort, its simply a Discussion Post, where one can simply state what they feel and why they feel so😊

Edited by rickks - 14 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

AvNeil123

@AvNeil123

Stunner

+ 4

Posted: 14 years ago

i am confused..at times i feel that he has lost his memory but then it looks like he is faking it..but then the question will be why is he faking it? bcuz i dnt see a reason

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

617251

Hibernated

Posted: 14 years ago

Its really confusing.. I agree with luv_gurTi

at times it seems as if he has actually lost his memory, at times it seems like he is faking it...

I guess we will have to wait and watch 😃

The curiosity factor is back with a bang!

Quote

@rickks

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 14 years ago

So Basically its a 50/50 Situation????

Does Anybody Have a Strong POV???

Quote

something

@Silentsoul

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 14 years ago

He has selective amesia...I think so.

Edited by kuls11 - 14 years ago

Quote

eminent

@eminent

Dazzler

Posted: 14 years ago

Viji...I have rattled my brain with this...really I have!! (w/ Nihu's and Deez convincing posts!😆)
It is quite confusing- at least now it is...but & at last I stick to my previous statements- that Maan is not merely pretending...I feel like that's not his style...

But we have to wait and watch...😆

response to Deez:

Ok so I've been reading posts regarding his 'fake' memory loss, and I've come to a conclusion that he can't be merely pretending. For one, because culprit has already been sent to jail-assuming no one else was behind Evil-Mummy.

Now even if she had an accomplice, according to MSK's personality- I don't think he's the type that will 'hide' and play! I mean-from what I've come to understand- he's a man of principles & integrity- whatever he does he'll do in front of his opponent. MSK is shown to be an intelligent man, and by faking his memory loss, I feel like it'll defy his personality.

And plus if anything, he hates liars! Pretending to have a loss of memory is, lying-one thing he despises the most. We even saw that being reiterated by Geet today, when Dev and Daadi make a 'fake' story...
As for the details you mentioned perhaps a loose script..??
Anyway whatever the story I just want it to be logical with a magical twist!!😳!

Edited by eminent - 14 years ago

Quote

@rickks

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: kuls11
He has selective amesia...I think so...

And Kulu Manali what are your reasons?????Why do you strongly say ki ML hai???

Quote

Muniza Riaz

@Infinitedreams

Stunner

+ 4

Posted: 14 years ago

Reserved for my T&K sis 🤗

----------------------------------------------------------------------------

I don't think so Maan is faking up, it's not Maan's Character to fake anything for any biggest reason...He s not weak person... He was restless cause he was trying to remember how the accident happened, and what he was missing...And somehow CV's was trying to show that 1 side, she was collecting her memories with him, which he forgot, and other side he was trying to remember what he forgot...I think it's so silly to think that Maan actually faking anything...As much i understand MSK, no way he would fake anything...

Edited by Infinitedreams - 14 years ago

Quote

Aditi

@adoremevirgo

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

ok, maan has lost his memory...he thinks it is still 2010...which means he is only a year behind...
i hv a feeling maan is playacting and the ML is actually fake...i cannot see that raw anger in his eyes like the MSK we knew in the first few months of this show...
somehow i feel wenever he is looking at geet...he is trying to tell her something thru his eyes...in the bedroom wen geet called him maan and then wen he reprimanded her to call her maan sir...i somehow felt he stressed on those 2 words maan sir...as if he was trying to tell her symbolisms of the words...it was decided long back that if geet calls her maan sir then he wud kiss her...i somehow felt that urge in him...

i dunno...maybe i am trying to see things which do not exist...maybe because i cant see maneet so near yet so far...

if maan has forgotten geet, then how come he has no issues that a married girl is staying in his house...geet is not a servant...he knows that geet is his employee...how come he is not asking anyone y an employee is staying in KM...serving food, cooking and all...that is not the job of a company secretary...

another thing i want clearance...does maan take bath daily, does he change clothes...does he stand in front of the mirror...if so then how come he is not aware of the taveez around his neck...how come he is least bothered about who put that around his neck...dadima doesnt seem like a taveez bhakt...so obviously she has not given it to maan...so how come maan is not removing that taveez...because a 2010 maan used to hate taveez...

Quote

Anju

@AnjuMaanManiac

Dazzler

+ 5

Posted: 14 years ago

#10

Hey Viji, 😛

I disagree yaar. His not faking it...its actually genuinely a temporary memory loss. He will get well soon...and something will trigger his mind and all his memories will come flooding back 😉

Just take the example of Maan fainting...that was REAL and it resulted with words being said which related to his life in the past year or so.

He looks at the bills and also thinks and believes he is living in 2010. Another instance that he is not faking this.

Maan was restless during photo album scene because after all Maan & Geet's souls are binded with love...what one feels the other senses...plus he still has the taveez which I always say brings Maaneet closer together for eternity 😳

A scene in Amritsar track that was similar when Maan was looking at Geet's photo in his wallet and hugged it tight ...Geet also reacted and woke up from her sleep 😳 she also was restless 😛

interesting discussion though 😆

~ Anju ⭐️

Edited by AnjuMaanManiac - 14 years ago

Quote

1 2 3 4

MSK Memory Loss- A Genuine Condition or A Mask

Related Topics

Explore Topics