Seema was REALLY good this week: Shreya is biased!

Page

dreams_bhatt

@dreams_bhatt

Beginner

Posted: 14 years ago

I seriously cannot see how Shreya could critique Seema Jha's rendition of "Kabhi Alvida naa Kehna." It was SOOO GOOD. I think Shreya is jealous that now ,Seema will become the next big thing, and she is worried about her competition...given she has no shows like Kartar and that guy who dances well, but can't sing well.

Sonu was absolutely right, now it's each man to his/her own team!

Quote

Frequent Posters

Ranbir.Fan

@Ranbir.Fan

Inactive

Posted: 14 years ago

You cant call her biased as last infact soo many instances Shreya praised Seema alot. As a judge she has the right to point out weak points & give constructive criticism, so that Seema improves & performs better. I understand that you are a Seema fan & therefore sensitive about her receiving a criticism, but please get a reality check!

Btw even Sanjay leela bhansali also pointed out Seema's weak point in that KANK song.

Edited by Ranbir.Fan - 14 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Fatema-Tuz-Zohora

@fzohora

Explorer

Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: dreams_bhatt
I seriously cannot see how Shreya could critique Seema Jha's rendition of "Kabhi Alvida naa Kehna." It was SOOO GOOD. I think Shreya is jealous that now ,Seema will become the next big thing, and she is worried about her competition...given she has no shows like Kartar and that guy who dances well, but can't sing well.

Sonu was absolutely right, now it's each man to his/her own team!

@bold Best joke of the year...Singer like Shreya Ghoshal is jealous of that lil kid?? Couldn't resist 🤣 🤣 🤣

Quote

Fatema-Tuz-Zohora

@fzohora

Explorer

Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: Ranbir.Fan
You cant call her biased as last infact soo many instances Shreya praised Seema alot. As a judgeshe has the right to point out weak points & give constructive criticism, so that Seema improves & performs better. I understand that you are a Seema fan & therefore sensitive about her receiving a criticism, but please get a reality check!

Btw even Sanjay leela bhansali also pointed out Seema's weak point in that KANK song.

Well said...I agree with you in every point 👍🏼 "She is biased & jealous" its the best joke of the year...No no Decade!! She even criticized Geet's performance...Remember?? @redBold Super Agreed... 👏

Quote

@-Nightingale-

Stunner

+ 5

Posted: 14 years ago

the negative comments Seems got were not for her singing but for the change in the music as it was tadka round...Sonu could not impress the judges with the variations n both Sahiti n Seema suffered...now that Sonu got his dose...i guess he will bonus back into the show more stronger

Quote

luvmuzik

@luvmuzik

Inactive

Posted: 14 years ago

I am amused...how can Shreya even imagine that these new comers will be a threat to her.

I agree that Sonu is really experimenting too much with both the girls and he is making that girl Sahiti very high pitched songs and most of them or so slow paced.They are so difficult and in my opinion she may not get votes.He shd leave the choice to her and she shd sing more peppy ones.

Edited by luvmuzik - 14 years ago

Quote

Jagavi

@musicheals

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: dreams_bhatt
I seriously cannot see how Shreya could critique Seema Jha's rendition of "Kabhi Alvida naa Kehna." It was SOOO GOOD. I think Shreya is jealous that now ,Seema will become the next big thing, and she is worried about her competition...given she has no shows like Kartar and that guy who dances well, but can't sing well.

Sonu was absolutely right, now it's each man to his/her own team!

Thats not called criticizing..she was saying good things about her too..not only bad! and she said it in a nice way..she wasnt being rude or anything...That shows that she still cares about Seema and wants her to perform well...if she was "jealous"...she woudnt even tell Seema what was wrong with the perfo. and just say she didnt like it...

This forum is just wonderful..when judges dont criticize...they have a problem...when they do, they still have a problem..what's up with that?! Make up your mind :S

Quote

Red_eyes

@Red_eyes

Inactive

+ 5

Posted: 14 years ago

i loved her she waz rocking

Quote

Summer3

@Summer3

Trailblazer

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

I am sure Shreya ji knows what she is talking about and it is good that she helps her to improve. She has also pointed out Seema's good points. There are many technical skills to learn and Seema can benefit from the Judges. Right attitude and discipline will take her far.
But favoring one's own team is also expected due to attachment. Sonu ji stated a general fact but the judges do try to be impartial too.
There are many very good singers in India but not everyone makes it. Fate and connections too play a part.

Quote

dreams_bhatt

@dreams_bhatt

Beginner

Posted: 14 years ago

#10

Originally posted by: --JagLovezSD--

Thats not called criticizing..she was saying good things about her too..not only bad! and she said it in a nice way..she wasnt being rude or anything...That shows that she still cares about Seema and wants her to perform well...if she was "jealous"...she woudnt even tell Seema what was wrong with the perfo. and just say she didnt like it...

This forum is just wonderful..when judges dont criticize...they have a problem...when they do, they still have a problem..what's up with that?! Make up your mind :S

listen, it's my opinion. And if some people agree with that, they can. if they dont, they dont.

I feel that she sang flawlessly...so it was a bit weird having Shreya SUDDENly become so critical.

As far as other performers like AJ (that dancer/singer) from Shreya's group or Kartarji, i mean...they weren't that good this time...but they didn't get too many critical remarks.

I found that a bit amusing.

Quote

1 2

Seema was REALLY good this week: Shreya is biased!

Related Topics

Explore Topics