Roshni is Jai Walia’s ex-wife ?

pinklily thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#1

I think that Roshni is jai walia's ex wife and she has let him before and now she has come back to get him. Or it could be that Roshni was Jai walia's first love and left him on the day of the marriage. Jai walia was not able to forget roshni that's why he did not marry and ater 20yrs when he saw pia he fell in love with her. Pia also left him on the day of the wedding. So I think history repeated with jai walia and he was so mad that he want to ruin everything. I definitely think that roshni is jai walia's ex-wife and aditya was telling roshni that she should understand jai is married to bani and as she is woman she should know what saat phera means. So probably this indicates that roshni mrried to jai and didn't understand what saat pheras meant to her when she got married to jai. I think that it was roshni's fault and she left jai that's why dadi and mausi ddin't like roshni coming back. Everybody in the walia house is scared to tell about roshni. Or it could be that Jigyaasa was the one who poisned jai and roshni's happily married life and jigs was the one who turned roshni against jai and that;s why roshni left him.

Edited by pinklily - 19 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

18

Views

3k

Users

10

Frequent Posters

mistletoe thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 19 years ago
#2

Pinky, I swear upon God that I am not repeating myself like a broken record....but I have typed just about the same thing and was going to post it..... 😲

Oooh, Darcy, your symptoms are all coming true...we all seem to share a terrific telepathy! Even yesterday, Anu and I posted an almost similar post at the same time....Kya hum sab Soul Sister ban gaye hai? 😆

Jokes apart, yes...I strongly think Jai and Roshni were married....they must have been very young at that time and just took the decision rashly and then later Jigyasa must have contrived some circumstances that must have led Jai to annule the marriage, before Jai and Roshni could go public about it......probably forcing or bribing Roshni to grant him a divorce and keep quiet about it.....all that Roshni says and does indicates that she knows everyone in the Walia Family like the back of her hand, especially Jai! Also, that explains why that uncalled for sympathy towards Bani....when Jai shouts on her! Remember, Roshni also tells Jai that he hasn't changed one bit, he still gives more importance to his work than to the people in his life....and then in an earlier episode, Roshni tells Bani that it is Jai's old habit of always being careless about his most priced possessions....indicating that Jai never cares for people who care for him, she was surely referring to herself and then to Bani!

This can be the only reason that Roshni is giving the shivers to everyone and that is the only reason that Jai is doing his utmost to keep Roshni away from Bani!

You know why I think so too, because yesterday, Aditya tells Roshni, "Tum toh ek aurat ho aur tum se accha Shaadi ka matlab aur kaun janega" Translated it means, that you are a woman and who else but you will understand what a marriage means to a woman......And Roshni's face clouds darkly with sorrow....

Yup, I am pretty much convinced that Jai and Roshni were married and out of circumstances, Jai must have annuled the marriage and told Roshni to go out of his life.....wonder what Bani will have to say when she comes to know of this! Btw, I don't think Jai would have ditched Roshni, all said and done, Jai is a lot of things but not an irresponsible man, something drastic must have happened for him to take such a step......something in which Jai had no or little say!

Love,

MT

Edited by mistletoe - 19 years ago
khoo thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 19 years ago
#3
omggggggg!!!!!! MT i was sooooo thinking that!! while i was watching the movie malamaal, i don't the thought of it just came to my head!!

i was sooooooo thinking that jai might have been married to roshni probably in the past!! because like u said, roshni knows him so well! and i was again thinking of what aditya told roshni about the marriage part!!

hailaaaa!! man this is weird!! hahaha!! i was thinking of coming back to your other post and was gonna raise this issue!! ahh man than i saw this post!! i can't believe that i was just thinking the same thing like a moment ago!! even during the movie i was thinking about the mysterious relationship of roshni and jai!!

kool man!! this is what i thought too!! 😆 😆
mistletoe thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 19 years ago
#4
😆 Yeah Khoo...this is scary....saat samandar paar, hum sab ek jaise kaise soch rahe hai....maybe Cuddles Darling ka asar ho raha hai hamare dimag par! 😕 😆

Roshni keeps saying that, "Mujhe kuch adhore kaam pure karne hai...." Now whatever could that mean???

But if she was indeed married to Jai once upon a time, why on Earth was she being sympathetic towards Bani, who is Jai's wife and in that sense Roshni's biggest rival!

MT
khoo thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 19 years ago
#5
hmm!! probably she went through the same thing that bani is going through!! that's why as a woman, she feels sympathetic towards her!!

Do you probably think that her adhooray kaam can be settling scores with jigzz!! I mean if she was to hurt jai, then she could have done it long time ago!! i mean why now!! Is it because jigz is the one who invited her to india!! sometimes i do have a feeling that probably, she's here to make jigz life a living hell, but then other times i think that probably she's trying to make bani and jai get closer

But u know the article said that jai will realize that he loves bani, but how, i think roshni might be here to help them two get together!!

Another thing, if roshni does feel sympathy towards bani, then why is she getting all mushy with jai in the first place!!I mean wouldn't that hurt bani now!!
sam111222 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#6
jai married to roshni in the past,i don't think that is possible.remember one of the articles said that b'coz of some circumstances,jai and roshni's mariage could not materialise.
Tomiko thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 19 years ago
#7
wow! this is a different view!
well...the argument seems pretty convincing...and maybe Jia and Roshni have been married before...but i don't think that Jai actually loved her...cause i'm sure he said that Pia was the first girl/woman he loved...someone correct me if i'm wrong...but i think this was what he said!
Tomiko thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 19 years ago
#8
wow! this is a different view!
well...the argument seems pretty convincing...and maybe Jia and Roshni have been married before...but i don't think that Jai actually loved her...cause i'm sure he said that Pia was the first girl/woman he loved...someone correct me if i'm wrong...but i think this was what he said!
khoo thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 19 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: sam111222

jai married to roshni in the past,i don't think that is possible.remember one of the articles said that b'coz of some circumstances,jai and roshni's mariage could not materialise.

but the director wasn't specific!! the marriage might have took place, but there no one probably wouldn't have known about it except jia's close peoplez!! materialize also mean become visible!! so the director might trying to say, that the marriage was only known to jai and his family, and not the society!! ah i don't know!! i'm waiting for the update!! okay im gonna hit the bed now; so late; and ya this is my last post!! lolzzzz😆

mistletoe thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 19 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: sam111222

jai married to roshni in the past,i don't think that is possible.remember one of the articles said that b'coz of some circumstances,jai and roshni's mariage could not materialise.

Hey Sam, The article mentioned about their marriage not getting materialized. Maybe what it meant was that the marriage could not be formalized in the way that a marriage is meant to be...as in it could not get a social recognition! Maybe, something happened that Jai decided not to go ahead with the proper marriage and told Roshni to agree to a Mexican Divorce and just get the hell out of his life....prodded by Jigyasa!

I don't know why, but all that Roshni says and does gives a strong indication of her being married to Jai...she seems to know him too well....and remember, when she meets Dadi and Mausi, she touches their feet....now that is primarily done by the Bahu of the House.....😕

Even I think that Roshni is back to settle scores with Jigyasa and not with Jai....but at the same time, she won't try and get Bani and Jai together...she still seems to hold pretty strong feelings for Jai! The reason why Roshni felt bad for Bani was because as Khoo said, Bani is going through exactly what Roshni had gone through....being ignored and uncared for by her husband...and hence, the woman to woman sympathy!

Also, Roshni doesn't see Bani as a rival at all, because she presumes that Jai hates her and is in the marriage only till Mausi is around. It is only when Aditya tells Roshni that Jai is now a married man and that if given a chance, Jai and Bani's relationship might just work out, Roshni gets rattled!

MT

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".