Are They Really Murderers?

Page

cynthia32

@cynthia32

Navigator

Posted: 14 years ago

As much as we hate Varsha-Dharmesh-Manju-Rasika (VDMR), the death of the child wasn't purely due to them. Ultimately, the doctor conducted the operation even without the money. In fact, the medical staff had just gotten ready for the operation when the doctor came and asked Archana's nurse to bring her in. So the child's death was an unfortunate incident but it may not have been prevented even if VDMR gave Manav money.

Of course, I want them punished as well for their wrongdoings but Manav is blaming them for the wrong thing. Although Manav should be upset at VDMR for not being there for him when he needed them the most, he can't really hold them responsible for the death of his child.

This is probably just a blooper though haha. If the doctor hadn't treated without the money, it would have been a different situation all together.

Thoughts?

Please Note: I am not in anyway supporting VDMR, just saying that the true reason Manav is mad at them is unwarranted. The child probably would not have survived even if the money had been arranged earlier.

Quote

Frequent Posters

112642

Suspended

Posted: 14 years ago

who knows. maybe if varsha gave the money ASAP, then Manav could have gotten there sooner and the whole thing would have turned out differently???

the point is that VRMD's inhumanity against the man who supported them and ALWAYS helped them at the cost of himself.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Nikita Lakhe

@nikitagmc

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: cynthia32
As much as we hate Varsha-Dharmesh-Manju-Rasika (VDMR), the death of the child wasn't purely due to them. Ultimately, the doctor conducted the operation even without the money. In fact, the medical staff had just gotten ready for the operation when the doctor came and asked Archana's nurse to bring her in. So the child's death was an unfortunate incident but it may not have been prevented even if VDMR gave Manav money.

Of course, I want them punished as well for their wrongdoings but Manav is blaming them for the wrong thing. Although Manav should be upset at VDMR for not being there for him when he needed them the most, he can't really hold them responsible for the death of his child.

This is probably just a blooper though haha. If the doctor hadn't treated without the money, it would have been a different situation all together.

Thoughts?

Please Note: I am not in anyway supporting VDMR, just saying that the true reason Manav is mad at them is unwarranted. The child probably would not have survived even if the money had been arranged earlier.

Its not just a question of death, but also a matter of intention. If the baby had not died, still Manav would have hated them- reason? The 4 people made it clear that they had NO INTENTION to help him in any way. They couldn't care less whether the baby lived or died. And that is what drove Manav mad.

Its not just a question of 'whose fault it was'. Its the intention which differentiates a person as a murderer or otherwise. IMO, they are very much murderers.

Yes, who knows child would not have survived even if money had been arranged, but then it would have shown that intention of Varsha, Manju etc was not of indifference or spite (as in Dharmesh who actually smiled when he got news of MC). As I said, it is the intention which makes a difference.

Edited by nikitagmc - 14 years ago

Quote

hawo/amaal/cuyuun

@Maneet13

Navigator

Posted: 14 years ago

if manav goes missing then i am sure he will be back rich and not like this he will be stronger i am sure and then they will beg hi manav please be stronger

i want him to show the their position and what they deserve

Quote

Dabulls23

@Dabulls23

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

Whether baby lived or died does not matter..

These 4 criminal hypocrites had no intention of helping Manav or the baby..They were Malice minded..So they are killers on the humanitarian and moral bases..

Archu should be the one who should have issues and gripe against all these and question her sanskari parents why are they forcing Manav in forgiving VRMD? So many expectations on Manav and none on Ks?

Quote

Sonii

@..Sonii..

Sparkler

Posted: 14 years ago

Yes, Gair iradatan hatya 😡 still it is murderer...

We dont need to ask, it is duty of relatives to help our, Moral duty, if not as relatives but as humans...but the people mentioned above dont even fall in this category...

The child could have saved if help reached on time...

I hope they will be punished

Quote

peaches4u

@peaches4u

Explorer

Posted: 14 years ago

To be honest... Archan's pregnancy was really problmatic to begin with.

I can't imagine any pregnancy with that much paid... Obvisously something is seriously worng if you have to take so many pain killers.

To me there was a great possibility that the baby would not have survived the way Archana was screaming... It had nothing to do with the money...

Quote

Dabulls23

@Dabulls23

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

Ghor Anyaay to the unborn baby and Manav...Archana now has to face the consequencies of the henious act by VMRD...Too bad..

Quote

Mandy

@mandy0310

Alumni

+ 8

Posted: 14 years ago

While it is not known if the baby would have survived had Manav got the money sooner, what is known is that Manju, Rasika, Dharmesh and Varsha did nothing to help. They knew that Archana was fighting for her life and the life of her child yet they turned their backs. The way I see it, they are responsible for what happened.

Quote

Are They Really Murderers?

Related Topics

Explore Topics