Mayuresh vs. Kruti

Starting with Mayuresh... he was fantastic! Just WOW! Well his performance as everyone saw got Marzi to stand on the table and bow to him, and also made Remo give a standing ovation. His performance was a well deserved 30. And i am not saying this because i am a huge Mayuresh fan but i hope that people agree with me here that he did deserve a 30.

it wasnt mayuresh vs kruti here, it was vrushali vs kruti, and kruti indeed was better than vrushali today

^ I agree. If it was Mayuresh vs Kruti, that would be a totally different comparison. It was Vrushali vs Kruti, and if Vrushali deserved a 9 (which she actually did..or maybe 8.5) , Kruti definitely deserved a 10.

i never compared kruti with vrushali here. i compared the episode as a whole. If mayuresh got a 30 and kruti got a 30, how is that fair?

Originally posted by: Priyanka_AAIICH

^ I agree. If it was Mayuresh vs Kruti, that would be a totally different comparison. It was Vrushali vs Kruti, and if Vrushali deserved a 9 (which she actually did..or maybe 8.5) , Kruti definitely deserved a 10.

LOL in the case of equal marks, Prince didn't deserve the same score as Dsir, The trios from both groups never deserved the same marks because Jalwa's trios were always better... I guess it basically depends on who you're comparing.

Originally posted by: Namrata_12

i never compared kruti with vrushali here. i compared the episode as a whole. If mayuresh got a 30 and kruti got a 30, how is that fair?

Yes i agree Vrushali didnt deserve a 27 either but Kruti definitely didnt deserve a 30 whereas we saw a much better performance from Mayuresh who got a 30.

Originally posted by: Namrata_12

i never compared kruti with vrushali here. i compared the episode as a whole. If mayuresh got a 30 and kruti got a 30, how is that fair?

Yes i agree Vrushali didnt deserve a 27 either but Kruti definitely didnt deserve a 30 whereas we saw a much better performance from Mayuresh who got a 30.

I agree to some extent what you are trying to say...

But if Vrushali was given 9, then there is no reason y kruti should not get 10 as she deserved better marks than Vrushali for sure...

It's simple. It was takkkar and someone among Vrush-kruti had to get a perfect score as it was takkar and one has to win. In this case, win means 10 I suppose...

So comparing solo and takkar marks will not make sense... If it was comparison among solo round, then it would have made sense... but now sorry no comparison can be done 😉

If you compare Kruti and Vrushali - it is clear that Kruti was the winner there. You could say that Mayuresh's 30 is not the same as Kruti's 30, so then the judges should have given Vrushali 8+8+8 and Kruti 9+9+9 ... however, judges clearly said that they are not capable of properly judging classical dance, hence the lack of clarity in the scores.

I do not like the way they score the trio and duo performances - sometimes the scores are really messed up! Jalwa's trio with the three girls as someone said earlier was definitely much better than Prince/Paulson/Alisha's performance.

Originally posted by: *Woh Ajnabee*

If you compare Kruti and Vrushali - it is clear that Kruti was the winner there. You could say that Mayuresh's 30 is not the same as Kruti's 30, so then the judges should have given Vrushali 8+8+8 and Kruti 9+9+9 ... however, judges clearly said that they are not capable of properly judging classical dance, hence the lack of clarity in the scores.

I do not like the way they score the trio and duo performances - sometimes the scores are really messed up! Jalwa's trio with the three girls as someone said earlier was definitely much better than Prince/Paulson/Alisha's performance.

Originally posted by: Namrata_12

Starting with Mayuresh... he was fantastic! Just WOW! Well his performance as everyone saw got Marzi to stand on the table and bow to him, and also made Remo give a standing ovation. His performance was a well deserved 30. And i am not saying this because i am a huge Mayuresh fan but i hope that people agree with me here that he did deserve a 30.

On the other hand, was it justified to give Kruti a 30? She was also fabulous and everything but giving her the same score as Mayuresh seemed a little unfair... Or they just gave her a 30 to make their team win since the Josh team won last week.

This is just my opinion and i dont think that she deserved the same score as Mayuresh in todays peformance. She can do much better than what she did today and one day she will get a 30 that she deserves.

I am not bashing here, i just want to know who agrees with me.