KARUNYA WAS MINDBLOWING!!! - Page 3

Originally posted by: kachhori

Well karunya is technically a good Singer... Recall he came bottom 3 very first GALA.Ever since he has shown good progress. But What bothered me was when Anuj sang in TOP 3 gala... Sonuji Pointed out that Anuj's Standing Notes/landing Notes R not very good.. Cmn for a Layman who listens to a SONG for Just 90 Seconds ... how does these Minuuute TECHNICALITIES matter. I have learnt Music But Millions of Indians for Whoom this Competetion is ,.it is all about Indian Idol.

😕 I think TOOO MUcH of technicalities really do not matter to COMMON man at all.

ya i totally agree with u😃

Originally posted by: Bubbles_Rox

karu was really good but i think that sandeep wasnt any behind! 😉 SO VOTE SANDEEP!!!!!!!! 😃

ya sandeep is also good but i really want karunya to win because he is the best😃

Originally posted by: Bubbles_Rox

karu was really good but i think that sandeep wasnt any behind! 😉 SO VOTE SANDEEP!!!!!!!! 😃

sandeep was 🤢. sorry but r v talking about the same indian idol. well sandy se sur ki ummed tho kabka chod diya but performance... woh bhi itna khaas nahi. wot was with the fake crying in the indian idol song. .... it just looked wierd. so dekah haye tho sandy was no where near karu in any criteria except for smiling i guess😆... poor sandy prolly thinks performing is smilling😛

Originally posted by: kachhori

Well karunya is technically a good Singer... Recall he came bottom 3 very first GALA.Ever since he has shown good progress. But What bothered me was when Anuj sang in TOP 3 gala... Sonuji Pointed out that Anuj's Standing Notes/landing Notes R not very good.. Cmn for a Layman who listens to a SONG for Just 90 Seconds ... how does these Minuuute TECHNICALITIES matter. I have learnt Music But Millions of Indians for Whoom this Competetion is ,.it is all about Indian Idol.

😕 I think TOOO MUcH of technicalities really do not matter to COMMON man at all.

I'm sorry but I don't agree with you. What the judges say is also partly for the contestants' benefit coz that's the only interaction they have with the judges and the only time they can benefit from their knowledge. For a layman it might not be important but for someone who wants to take singing to a professional level it is very necessary to pay attention to the details and technicalities! I know coz I perform quite a bit and I have learnt music as well and I must say that I have benefitted from quite a few comments made in the show personally. It is very important for a singer to be technically aware and also for a good listener in fact especially if the listener has the power to make a contestant's career. It is always wiser to make informed decisions rather than ignorant ones.

Originally posted by: Piscean

I'm sorry but I don't agree with you. What the judges say is also partly for the contestants' benefit coz that's the only interaction they have with the judges and the only time they can benefit from their knowledge. For a layman it might not be important but for someone who wants to take singing to a professional level it is very necessary to pay attention to the details and technicalities! I know coz I perform quite a bit and I have learnt music as well and I must say that I have benefitted from quite a few comments made in the show personally. It is very important for a singer to be technically aware and also for a good listener in fact especially if the listener has the power to make a contestant's career. It is always wiser to make informed decisions rather than ignorant ones.

Okay if theTechnicalities matter.. then ..FOR What percenatge of the PUBLIC???.Most of the public who vote R MUSIC LOVERS/MUSIC LISTNERS.They will NOT Bother TO GO in detail OF THE SONG FORMULA. FOR U & ME probably who have learnt MUSIC OKAY What Sonyu Talks might make Sense. Millions Of the Voters Vote for Song that Sounds good to them.That is my opinio.Sonu need not make it look like a Maths Formula.😕

Originally posted by: kachhori

Okay if theTechnicalities matter.. then ..FOR What percenatge of the PUBLIC???.Most of the public who vote R MUSIC LOVERS/MUSIC LISTNERS.They will NOT Bother TO GO in detail OF THE SONG FORMULA. FOR U & ME probably who have learnt MUSIC OKAY What Sonyu Talks might make Sense. Millions Of the Voters Vote for Song that Sounds good to them.That is my opinio.Sonu need not make it look like a Maths Formula.😕

You said it doesn't have to be a math formula and yet you ask for what percentage of the public! Well they're not going to make different shows for different parts of the public now are they? If people are music lovers then they would appreciate the techincalities and even listeners i've noticed like to know the details even though not completely they like to be educated about why a song sounds nice. Not everyone votes blindly....and like I said earlier their comments are not just for the voters or the listeners it's also a educating process for the contestants and they for sure need to know the technicalities. It's encouraging for the viewers to know that the judges are concentrating on improving the singing of the contestants by pointing out where they can better themselves. I wouldn't completely dismiss all of the Indian audience for not knowing why they like a song......our culture is so that we're exposed to music from birth to death and hence all of us are musically oriented in some way or the other so even the aam janta is able to appreciate technicalities. Give the audience some credit!

yes "jhanak jhanak "was perfection .and "jaana hai mujhko" was proof of his immense talent. 😊

i would'nt say perfect because to me what manna de sang was perfect but yes it was the best than anyone else other than manna de could have sung 👏

Karunya was way ahead of sandeepin yday's gala

Originally posted by: priyav

Karunya was way ahead of sandeepin yday's gala

😃